Home / Learn / Exam prep / GATE Physics / Lesson 2.4
All lessons

Module 2: Classical mechanics · Lesson 2.4 · about 50 min

Central forces and Rutherford scattering

The orbit equation in u = 1/r, finding a force law from an orbit, the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector and closed orbits, the virial theorem, impact parameter and differential cross-section, the hard sphere and Rutherford formulas, closest approach, and moving between the centre-of-mass and lab frames.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 2 · about 50 minutes. By the end you will be able to get an orbit from a force law and a force law from an orbit, use the Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector, apply the virial theorem, work out differential and total cross-sections, use the Rutherford formula with real numbers, and convert scattering angles between the centre-of-mass and lab frames.

The effective potential, Kepler’s laws and orbital energies are in the JAM lesson on central forces. This lesson starts from there.

A central force turns every problem into one radial equation. Bound orbits ask what shape it gives; scattering asks how the angle of deflection depends on how closely the particle was aimed, and turns that into a measurable cross-section.

1. The orbit equation

With reduced mass μ, angular momentum ℓ=μr2θ˙ and a central force F(r) (positive outwards), substitute u=1/r and use θ instead of time. Since r˙=−(ℓ/μ)du/dθ, the radial equation becomes the Binet equation:

d2udθ2+u=−μℓ2u2F(1u)

Force to orbit. For F=−k/r2 the right side is the constant μk/ℓ2, so u=(μk/ℓ2)(1+ecos⁡θ): a conic. For F=−k/r3, the equation is u′′+(1−μk/ℓ2)u=0. If ℓ2>μk the orbit is u∝cos⁡(γθ), an open curve that escapes; if ℓ2<μk it is a spiral into or out of the centre. Inverse-cube forces have no stable circular orbits.

Orbit to force. Read the equation backwards. Worked example: a particle moves on the spiral r=cθ−1, so u=θ/c and u′′=0. Then u=−μF/(ℓ2u2), which gives F=−ℓ2u3/μ=−ℓ2/(μr3): an attractive inverse-cube force, with exactly the angular momentum that makes the bracket above vanish.

2. The Laplace-Runge-Lenz vector and closed orbits

For F=−k/r2 there is an extra conserved vector besides L→:

A→=p→×L→−μkrˆ,dA→dt=0,|A→|=μke

It lies in the orbital plane and points from the centre to the closest point (perihelion). Taking A→⋅r→=Arcos⁡θ and using r→⋅(p→×L→)=ℓ2 gives ℓ2−μkr=μkercos⁡θ, the conic again, with no differential equation solved. Because the perihelion direction is fixed, Kepler orbits close.

Any small extra force breaks this. A perturbing potential δU=−h/r3 (the leading correction from general relativity) makes A→ turn slowly: the perihelion precesses. For Mercury the relativistic part is 43 arcseconds per century. The extra symmetry behind A→ is also why the hydrogen atom’s levels depend only on n and not on l.

Bertrand’s theorem. Only F∝−1/r2 and F∝−r close every bound orbit. Near a circular orbit, small radial wobbles have frequency ratio ωr/ωθ=n+3 for F∝−rn: 1 for gravity, 2 for the spring. A slight change of exponent from −2 turns ellipses into rosettes.

3. The virial theorem

For a bound motion, the time average of r→⋅p→ does not grow, so ⟨d(r→⋅p→)/dt⟩=0, which gives 2⟨T⟩=⟨r→⋅∇V⟩. For a power law V∝rn:

2⟨T⟩=n⟨V⟩

Gravity and Coulomb (n=−1): ⟨T⟩=−12⟨V⟩ and E=−⟨T⟩. The oscillator (n=2): ⟨T⟩=⟨V⟩=E/2. Astronomers use the first to weigh galaxy clusters from the speeds of their galaxies; that is how Zwicky first inferred dark matter.

Worked example. A particle is bound in V=cr4. Then ⟨T⟩=2⟨V⟩, so E=3⟨V⟩ and the average kinetic energy is two thirds of the total.

4. Impact parameter and cross-section

Particles arrive in a uniform parallel beam of intensity I (number per unit area per unit time). Each has an impact parameter b, the distance by which it would miss the centre if it went straight, and is deflected through angle Θ. With E and ℓ=b2μE fixed, Θ depends only on b.

Count in. The particles with impact parameter between b and b + db cross a ring of area 2πb db.

Count out. They come out between Θ and Θ + dΘ, into solid angle dΩ = 2π sin Θ dΘ.

Define dσ. The number scattered into dΩ per second is I dσ, where dσ is the effective target area for that direction.

Equate. 2πb |db| = (dσ/dΩ) 2π sin Θ |dΘ|.

dσdΩ=bsin⁡Θ|dbdΘ|,σ=∫dσdΩdΩ
b
impact parameter: the miss distance of the undeflected straight line
Θ(b)
the deflection; small b means a close encounter and a large angle
dσ/dΩ
an area per steradian: the slice of beam cross-section that ends up in each direction
σ
total cross-section: the area of beam removed from the forward direction
Physical meaning
The target is replaced by an imaginary disc that each direction "owns" a part of. A particle hitting that part of the disc goes in that direction. Counting how many arrive in a detector measures the area of its part.

Worked example: a hard sphere. A particle hitting a sphere of radius a bounces like light off a mirror. Geometry gives b=asin⁡α with Θ=π−2α, so b=acos⁡(Θ/2) and |db/dΘ|=12asin⁡(Θ/2). Then dσ/dΩ=acos⁡(Θ/2)⋅12asin⁡(Θ/2)/sin⁡Θ=a2/4. The scattering is isotropic, and σ=4π⋅a2/4=πa2, the shadow of the sphere, as it should be.

5. Rutherford scattering

For a repulsive U=k/r with k=zZe2/4πε0, the orbit is one branch of a hyperbola with the nucleus at the outer focus. The angle between its asymptotes gives

b=k2Ecot⁡Θ2,dσdΩ=(k4E)21sin4⁡(Θ/2)

The same formula holds for an attractive −k/r (the particle swings round the centre instead of being pushed away) and, by a happy accident, in quantum mechanics. Its key features:

  • It falls steeply with angle, but large angles still happen. Rutherford’s surprise was that about 1 in 104 alpha particles bounced back from a thin gold foil, impossible for Thomson’s spread-out atom.
  • dσ/dΩ∝Z2/E2: heavier nuclei and slower particles scatter more.
  • The total cross-section diverges at small angles, because the Coulomb force has infinite range. In matter the electrons screen the nucleus and cut it off.
  • The closest approach for impact parameter b is rmin⁡=k2E(1+csc⁡Θ2); head-on (Θ=180°) it is d=k/E. When d is smaller than the nuclear radius the formula fails, which is how the size of nuclei was first measured.
Particles at evenly spaced impact parameters pass a repulsive or attractive Coulomb centre or a hard sphere. Small impact parameters give large angles; pick one orbit and compare its measured angle with the Rutherford formula.

Worked example: alpha particles on gold. Take 5 MeV alpha particles (z=2) on gold (Z=79), with e2/4πε0=1.44 MeV fm, so k=227.5 MeV fm.

  1. Head-on closest approach: d=k/E=45.5 fm, well outside the gold nucleus (about 7 fm), so the formula holds.
  2. Impact parameter for 90°: b=(k/2E)cot⁡45°=22.75 fm, and rmin⁡=22.75(1+2)=54.9 fm.
  3. Fraction scattered beyond 90° by a foil 1 μm thick (n=5.9×1028 m⁻³): each nucleus blocks a disc of area πb2=1.63×10−27 m², so the fraction is ntπb2≈9.6×10−5, about 1 in 10 000.

“A total cross-section is the physical size of the target.” It is an effective area, and it depends on the force and the energy. For a hard sphere it happens to be the shadow πa2; for Coulomb scattering it is infinite; for neutrons on nuclei it can be thousands of times the geometric size near a resonance. In wave mechanics, even a hard sphere has a total cross-section of 2πa2 at short wavelengths, because of diffraction round its edge.

6. Centre-of-mass and lab frames

The formulas above give Θ in the centre-of-mass (CM) frame, or for a fixed centre. A real target of mass m2 recoils, and the detector measures the lab angle θ of the projectile m1. For elastic scattering,

tan⁡θ=sin⁡Θcos⁡Θ+m1/m2
  • m1≪m2: the two angles agree.
  • m1=m2: θ=Θ/2, so no projectile goes backwards, and the target goes off at (π−Θ)/2: the two lab directions are at 90°.
  • m1>m2: there is a maximum lab angle, sin⁡θmax⁡=m2/m1. An alpha particle hitting an electron is turned by at most 0.008°, which is why electrons in Rutherford’s foil could not explain the large angles.

Cross-sections change too, because the same particles fill a different solid angle: (dσ/dΩ)lab=(dσ/dΩ)CM|dΩCM/dΩlab|, while the total σ is the same in both frames.

Worked example. A neutron hits a carbon-12 nucleus at rest and scatters elastically through 90° in the CM frame. Then tan⁡θ=1/(0+1/12)=12, so θ=85.2° in the lab. Its speed in the CM frame is unchanged and the CM moves at v/13, so its lab energy falls to (1+144)/169=0.858 of the original. This is how graphite slows neutrons in a reactor.

  • Binet: u′′+u=−μF(1/u)/(ℓ2u2), u=1/r; use it both ways (force to orbit, orbit to force).
  • Inverse square: A→=p→×L→−μkrˆ is conserved, points to perihelion, |A→|=μke. Only 1/r2 and r close every orbit.
  • Virial: 2⟨T⟩=n⟨V⟩ for V∝rn.
  • dσ/dΩ=(b/sin⁡Θ)|db/dΘ|. Hard sphere: b=acos⁡(Θ/2), a2/4, σ=πa2.
  • Rutherford: b=(k/2E)cot⁡(Θ/2), dσ/dΩ=(k/4E)2csc4⁡(Θ/2); total σ infinite; head-on d=k/E.
  • Lab angle: tan⁡θ=sin⁡Θ/(cos⁡Θ+m1/m2); equal masses give θ=Θ/2 and a 90° opening; sin⁡θmax⁡=m2/m1.

Practise: exam questions on this lesson

They start easy and climb to top-rank level. More on the central forces and scattering practice page.

Before this: lesson 2.3, Poisson brackets and canonical transformations. Next: lesson 2.5, small oscillations and normal modes. Basics: the JAM lessons on central forces and work, energy and collisions.

Going on to CSIR NET? Scattering: Born approximation and partial waves redoes this lesson’s cross-sections in quantum mechanics.

Check yourself

1The total cross-section for scattering of a charged particle by a bare Coulomb potential is
2A hard sphere of radius a scatters point particles elastically. The differential cross-section
3In an elastic collision of a moving particle with an identical particle at rest (non-relativistic), the two outgoing directions make an angle of

Sources

  • H. Goldstein, C. Poole and J. Safko, Classical Mechanics, 3rd ed. (2002), chapter 3
  • L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, 3rd ed. (1976), chapters 3 and 4
  • E. Rutherford, The scattering of α and β particles by matter and the structure of the atom, Philosophical Magazine 21, 669 (1911)
  • GATE Physics syllabus (Classical Mechanics), IIT organising institute; CSIR-UGC NET Physical Sciences syllabus, Part A Classical Mechanics

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.