Module 7: Solid state physics · Lesson 7.5 · about 45 min
Heat capacity: Einstein and Debye
Why solids lose heat capacity at low temperature: Dulong-Petit and its failure, the Einstein model, the Debye model with its density of states, cutoff and T³ law, the Debye temperature from sound speeds, heat and entropy at low T, zero-point energy, the dimension rule C ∝ T^d, and the electronic γT term with the C/T against T² plot.
Module 7 · about 45 minutes. With the phonon modes in hand, the heat capacity of a solid is just bookkeeping: put thermal energy into each mode with the Planck occupation and differentiate. Two famous approximations to the spectrum, Einstein’s single frequency and Debye’s continuum, bracket the truth and are what GATE and NET test. The classical background (equipartition) is in the JAM kinetic theory lesson.
1. Dulong-Petit and its failure
Classically each atom is a 3D oscillator with mean energy , so a mole has and
per mole of atoms (NaCl: per mole of formula units). Most elements obey this near room temperature, but diamond has only about a quarter of it, and every solid’s falls to zero as , as the third law requires. The cure is quantum: an oscillator of frequency has mean thermal energy
which is when and exponentially small when . (The zero-point energy does not depend on and adds nothing to .)
2. The Einstein model
Einstein (1907) gave all oscillators one frequency , defining . Then and
At this is still 92% of ; it drops to half at . At high , . At low , : exponential. That is too fast. Real crystals have acoustic modes of arbitrarily low frequency that keep absorbing heat. The Einstein model is still the right description for flat optical branches.
Worked example. With K ( THz), at 120 K : , J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
3. The Debye model
Debye (1912) replaced the true spectrum by that of an elastic continuum: three acoustic branches with . Counting in a sphere gives modes below , so
with , (a sphere with the volume of the Brillouin zone) and . If longitudinal and transverse speeds differ, use (the slow transverse waves dominate). The heat capacity is
- `$\theta_D$`
- Debye temperature: Pb 105 K, Na 158 K, Cu 343 K, Si 645 K, diamond 2230 K; high for stiff, light solids (`$\theta_D\propto v$`)
- High `$T$`
- `$C\to3R$`, with a correction `$-\tfrac1{20}(\theta_D/T)^2$`; already 0.952 × 3R at `$T = \theta_D$` and 0.90 × 3R at `$0.68\theta_D$`
- Low `$T$`
- the upper limit goes to infinity, the integral becomes `$4\pi^4/15$`, and `$C = \tfrac{12\pi^4}5R\left(\tfrac T{\theta_D}\right)^3 = 1944\left(\tfrac T{\theta_D}\right)^3$` J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹
Low-T energy. U = ∫ g(ω) ħω/(e^{ħω/k_BT} − 1) dω with g = 9Nω²/ω_D³. Substitute x = ħω/k_BT.
Pull out the temperature. U = 9N k_B T⁴/θ_D³ ∫₀^{θ_D/T} x³/(eˣ − 1) dx. For T ≪ θ_D the upper limit is effectively infinite and the integral is π⁴/15.
Differentiate. U = (3π⁴/5) N k_B T⁴/θ_D³, so C = dU/dT = (12π⁴/5) N k_B (T/θ_D)³. Per mole, 12π⁴R/5 = 1944 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
Where it holds. The T³ law needs the ω² spectrum to be accurate for all excited modes, which is true only for T ≲ θ_D/50. At θ_D/10 it already overestimates by about 3%.
Worked example (Debye temperature from sound). A solid with m⁻³ and m/s: m⁻¹, rad/s, K. Its heat capacity at 10 K is J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹.
Compare the two models in the figure. On log-log axes the Debye curve becomes the straight line at low while the Einstein curve plunges away below it.
4. Consequences at low temperature
- Ratios. : warming from 10 K to 20 K multiplies by 8 (an Einstein solid with going from 10 to 5 would multiply it by 38).
- Heat. with per mole.
- Entropy. .
- Zero-point energy. (Debye) or (Einstein); it lowers the cohesive energy but not .
- Compounds. With atoms per formula unit, at high and per mole of formula units. A good model uses Debye for the 3 acoustic branches and Einstein oscillators for the optical ones, which freeze out exponentially.
- Dimension. In dimensions , so : a chain gives , a sheet with linear in-plane modes gives .
5. Electrons and magnons
In a metal the conduction electrons add with . Only electrons within about of the Fermi level can be excited, so is about 1% of the lattice value at room temperature, which is why classical theory’s per electron was never seen. But falls more slowly than , so electrons win below
For copper ( mJ mol⁻¹ K⁻², mJ mol⁻¹ K⁻⁴), K, and at 2 K electrons give 78% of . Plotting against gives as the intercept and K from the slope. In a ferromagnetic insulator, magnons with add , separated by plotting against .
“The law holds for any temperature below .” It holds well only below about . At the formula gives , an impossible value far above the classical limit, while the full Debye function gives . Use the law at genuinely low temperatures, and the full function (or a table) elsewhere.
The heat capacity fitter fits measured data with the Debye and Einstein models plus an electronic term and returns , and .
- Dulong-Petit per mole of atoms ( per mole of formula units); quantum freezing makes as .
- Einstein: , ; 0.92 × 3R at ; exponential fall at low (too fast).
- Debye: , , ; low- law J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹, valid for .
- Low : , ; zero-point energy per mole; in dimensions.
- Metals: ; plot against ; crossover .
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Back to: phonons for the modes behind these curves, or the reciprocal lattice for where they live.
Next: lesson 7.6, the free electron model.
Check yourself
Sources
- C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, 8th ed. (2005), chapters 5 and 6
- N. W. Ashcroft and N. D. Mermin, Solid State Physics (1976), chapter 23
- P. Debye, "Zur Theorie der spezifischen Wärmen", Annalen der Physik 39 (1912) 789
- A. Einstein, "Die Plancksche Theorie der Strahlung und die Theorie der spezifischen Wärme", Annalen der Physik 22 (1907) 180
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.