Module 10: From smooth to lumpy · Lesson 10.1 · about 14 min
The seeds of structure
The young universe was smooth to 1 part in 100,000. How tiny ripples of every size, grown by gravity, became every galaxy, cluster and void we see today.
Module 10 · about 14 minutes. Read first: 8.4 Dark matter in the first light. When the first light was set free, the universe was an almost perfectly even gas. Today it is full of galaxies, clusters and huge empty voids. This module tells how one became the other. By the end of this lesson you will be able to describe the seeds that everything grew from, measure them with one number, and say why gravity makes them grow.
1. Almost smooth
The cosmic microwave background, released at recombination about 380,000 years after the start, has the same temperature in every direction to about 1 part in 100,000 (Lesson 7.4). Slightly warmer and cooler patches mark slightly denser and thinner regions of matter. Picture a perfectly calm lake with ripples a hundredth of a millimetre high on a surface a kilometre wide: that is how smooth the young universe was.
Cosmologists measure a ripple with the density contrast, already met in Lesson 8.4:
- ρ(x)
- the density of matter at a place x
- ρ̄
- the average density of matter in the whole universe at that time
- δ
- how far above (positive) or below (negative) average the place is, as a fraction. δ can never be less than −1, which is completely empty
- Physical meaning
- One number for "how lumpy". Early on, |δ| was about 10⁻⁵ for the gas and some tens of times more for dark matter. Today, a galaxy's halo has δ of a few hundred, and the middle of a void about −0.8.
2. Ripples of every size
The ripples were not one neat wave but a jumble of waves of every size added together, like the surface of a choppy sea. Cosmologists describe the jumble by its power spectrum: how strong the ripples are on each size scale. Two facts, both measured by the CMB and by galaxy maps, matter most:
- Nearly the same strength on every scale. In 1970 Edward Harrison, and independently Yakov Zel’dovich and (with Jer Yu) Jim Peebles, argued that the simplest seeds would have about the same strength at every size, measured as each wave entered the horizon. Planck finds almost exactly that: the spectral index is ns = 0.965 ± 0.004, where 1 would be perfectly even. Slightly stronger on large scales, a clue from the very first instant.
- Random, like noise. The ripples behave as a Gaussian random field: at any point δ follows a bell curve, and the bumps are placed at random, with no pattern beyond their strength on each scale.
Where did they come from? The leading idea is that they are quantum jitters from the first tiny fraction of a second, stretched to enormous sizes by cosmic inflation. That story belongs to Lesson 11.3; here we take the seeds as given and watch them grow.
3. How much matter went into each lump
A galaxy is tiny compared with the region it came from. Gather all the matter of a halo and spread it out at the cosmic average density: the ball it fills is the patch of the early universe that became the galaxy. Its radius (in comoving units, measured as if today) follows from mass = density × volume:
- M
- the mass of the galaxy's halo, or cluster
- Ωmρc
- the average density of matter today: 31% of the critical density (Lesson 5.3), about 4 × 10¹⁰ suns per cubic megaparsec
- R
- the comoving radius of the patch that collapsed to make it
- Physical meaning
- Mass tells you which ripples mattered: a Milky Way halo grew from a patch about 2 Mpc in radius, a big cluster from one about 20 Mpc. Each kind of object is made by the ripples of its own size.
4. The highest peaks go first
Because small ripples ride on top of big swells, a small ripple sitting on a big crest reaches the collapse threshold before the same ripple sitting in a trough. So the first objects form on the rarest high peaks, and those peaks are bunched together on the big crests, where great clusters will later grow. James Bardeen, Dick Bond, Nick Kaiser and Alex Szalay worked out the statistics of these peaks in 1986. It explains why the first stars (Lesson 10.5) and the brightest early quasars sit in what later become the densest regions of the universe.
- 1946 Evgeny Lifshitz shows that in an expanding universe small lumps grow only slowly, as a power of time, not explosively: there must have been seeds from the start.
- 1970-72 Harrison, Peebles and Yu, and Zel'dovich propose seeds of the same strength on every scale.
- 1986 Bardeen, Bond, Kaiser and Szalay describe how the peaks of random ripples cluster.
- 1992 COBE detects the ripples in the CMB, at about 1 part in 100,000 (George Smoot and colleagues).
- 2013-18 Planck measures ns = 0.965: slightly stronger on large scales, not exactly even.
“The spots in the CMB map are baby galaxies.” The spots Planck shows are about a degree across, which is hundreds of megaparsecs today: far bigger than any galaxy. They are the large ripples. The small ripples that made individual galaxies were there too, but too small for CMB telescopes to see, and they were partly smoothed out in the gas. What the CMB proves is that ripples existed, with the size and pattern needed.
- At recombination, matter was smooth to about 1 part in 100,000; the density contrast δ = (ρ − ρ̄)/ρ̄ measures how lumpy.
- The ripples came in every size at random (a Gaussian random field), almost equally strong on every scale: ns = 0.965.
- Gravity is unstable: denser regions pull in more and grow, so the ripples became halos, galaxies and voids.
- Each object grew from a patch of its own size: a Milky Way halo from a ball about 2 Mpc in radius (comoving).
- The rarest high peaks collapse first, and cluster together. The seeds themselves probably came from inflation (Lesson 11.3).
Check yourself
Sources
- E. R. Harrison (1970), Fluctuations at the threshold of classical cosmology, Physical Review D 1, 2726 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.1.2726
- Ya. B. Zel'dovich (1972), A hypothesis, unifying the structure and the entropy of the Universe, MNRAS 160, 1P https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/160.1.1P
- G. F. Smoot et al. (1992), Structure in the COBE differential microwave radiometer first-year maps, ApJ 396, L1 https://doi.org/10.1086/186504
- Planck Collaboration (2020), Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, A&A 641, A6 https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201833910
- J. M. Bardeen, J. R. Bond, N. Kaiser and A. S. Szalay (1986), The statistics of peaks of Gaussian random fields, ApJ 304, 15 https://doi.org/10.1086/164143
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.