Module 5: The equations of the universe, gently · Lesson 5.8 · about 15 min
Distances in an expanding universe
When the universe stretches while light travels, 'how far away is it?' has several honest answers: light-travel distance, comoving distance, luminosity distance and angular-diameter distance. What each one means, when to use it, and why very distant galaxies look bigger again.
Module 5 · about 15 minutes. Read first: 5.1 The scale factor and 2.1 Looking far is looking back. On Earth, “how far?” has one answer. Across an expanding universe it has several, and each is useful for a different job. By the end you will be able to choose the right distance for a brightness, a size or a “how far now”.
1. Four honest answers
Take a galaxy at redshift z = 1, in today’s standard model:
- Light-travel distance, 7.9 billion light-years: how long the light was on its way, times c. Simple to say, but not a distance you could lay a ruler along at any one time.
- Comoving distance, 11 billion light-years: how far it is now, on today's stretched map. The best answer to "how far away is it?"
- Luminosity distance, 22 billion light-years: the distance its faintness suggests if you use the inverse square law.
- Angular-diameter distance, 5.5 billion light-years: the distance its apparent size suggests, from size = distance × angle.
- dC
- comoving distance: add up the small bits of light's path, each stretched to today's size. E(z) = H(z)/H0 comes from the Friedmann equation
- dL
- luminosity distance: one factor (1 + z) because each photon arrives stretched with less energy, another because they arrive more slowly; flux = L/(4πdL²)
- dA
- angular-diameter distance: the galaxy's size is fixed, but the light left when everything was 1 + z times closer
- Physical meaning
- They agree for nearby galaxies (z much less than 1) and part company as z grows. Using the wrong one is a classic mistake.
2. Bigger far away
Look at the angular-diameter curve. It rises, peaks near z ≈ 1.6 and then falls. A galaxy at z = 10 looks larger on the sky than the same galaxy at z = 2. The light left it when the universe was 11 times smaller and the galaxy was much closer to us; the light then took a long time to reach us through growing space. The farthest galaxies James Webb sees are tiny, but mainly because young galaxies were small.
3. Which distance when
- Brightness of a supernova or a quasar: luminosity distance (this is how dark energy was found).
- Sizes of galaxies or of spots in the microwave background: angular-diameter distance.
- “How far away is it now?” or maps of galaxies: comoving distance.
- “How long ago?”: lookback time, not a distance at all.
One rule ties them together. In 1933 the mathematician Ivor Etherington showed that in any expanding universe the luminosity and angular-diameter distances are linked by dL = (1 + z)² dA. Testing this “distance duality” with real data is a check that photons are not lost or created on the way.
“A galaxy 13 billion light-years away.” News reports usually mean the light-travel distance: the light took 13 billion years. The galaxy itself is now around 30 billion light-years away. Both are true answers to different questions.
- Light-travel distance = c × lookback time; comoving distance = distance now on the stretched map.
- Luminosity distance dL = (1 + z) dC for brightness; angular-diameter distance dA = dC / (1 + z) for sizes.
- They agree nearby and split far away; dA peaks near z ≈ 1.6, so very distant galaxies look bigger again.
- dL = (1 + z)² dA in any expanding universe (Etherington, 1933).
Convert any redshift into all these distances with the [[cosmology-calculator]].
Check yourself
Sources
- D. W. Hogg (1999), Distance measures in cosmology https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9905116
- I. M. H. Etherington (1933), On the definition of distance in general relativity, Philosophical Magazine 15, 761 https://doi.org/10.1080/14786443309462220
- Planck Collaboration (2020), Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, A&A 641, A6 https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201833910
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.