Module 2: Distances beyond the stars · Lesson 2.3 · about 15 min
Hubble proves Andromeda is another galaxy
In 1923 Edwin Hubble found a Cepheid star in the Andromeda nebula and used it to measure its distance. Follow his measurement step by step, and see why his answer was too small.
Module 2 · about 15 minutes. By the end you will be able to follow Hubble’s measurement of the distance to Andromeda, use a period-luminosity rule to find a galaxy’s distance yourself, and explain why the first answer was too small.
1. The star on plate H335H
On the night of 5-6 October 1923, Edwin Hubble took a long photograph of the Andromeda nebula with the 2.5-metre Hooker telescope on Mount Wilson, California. He marked three spots he thought were new stars (novae) with an “N”. Comparing with older plates, he found that one of them was not a nova at all: it brightened and faded again and again. He crossed out the “N” and wrote “VAR!”, for variable.
It was a Cepheid, a type of pulsing giant star. Henrietta Leavitt had discovered in 1912 that a Cepheid’s period reveals its true power. The physics of why Cepheids pulse and how Leavitt found her law is in the Astronomy course. Here we follow how Hubble used it.
2. The measurement, step by step
Watch the star. Night after night, measure how bright it looks. A Cepheid brightens quickly, then fades slowly, over and over. (The curve here is made up, but shaped like a real Cepheid's.)
Time one cycle. From peak to peak takes about 31 days. Hubble's star had a period of 31.4 days.
Use Leavitt's law. Slower Cepheids are more powerful. A 31-day Cepheid has an absolute magnitude of about −5.3: about 10,000 times the Sun's power.
Compare. It looks like magnitude 19.2, very faint. The difference m − M ≈ 24.5 means it is about 790,000 parsecs, or 2.6 million light-years away. (Hubble's own calibration gave about 900,000 light-years; see section 3.)
- P
- the pulse period in days
- log₁₀ P
- the power of ten of the period: 1 for 10 days, 2 for 100 days
- M
- the true brightness as an absolute magnitude (more negative is more powerful)
- −2.4
- the slope: each tenfold longer period makes the star 2.4 magnitudes (about 9 times) more powerful
This is a rounded modern version of the rule in visible light. The real calibration is one of the most carefully studied numbers in astronomy, because the whole distance scale of the universe hangs on it.
3. Why the first answer was too small
Hubble announced his result on 1 January 1925: Andromeda was about 900,000 light-years away, far beyond Shapley’s giant Milky Way. The Great Debate (Lesson 1.7) was over.
But his number was too small by more than half. In 1952 Walter Baade, using the new 5-metre Palomar telescope, found that there are two types of Cepheids. The ones used to calibrate Leavitt’s law (in star clusters of our own galaxy) are a fainter type than the ones in Andromeda’s spiral arms. Correcting for this made Andromeda, and every other galaxy, about twice as far away. Overnight, the universe doubled in size.
Systematic errors. Hubble’s measurement was careful; his random errors were small. His mistake was a systematic error: something wrong with the method itself that shifts every answer the same way. Systematic errors are the cosmologist’s worst enemy, because repeating the measurement doesn’t reveal them. Lesson 12.2 shows that the biggest argument in cosmology today, the Hubble tension, may be partly about exactly this.
Henrietta Swan Leavitt (1868-1921) worked as a “computer” at Harvard College Observatory, measuring stars on photographic plates for 30 cents an hour. Studying 1,777 variable stars in the Magellanic Clouds, she noticed that brighter Cepheids pulsed more slowly. Because all the stars in each Cloud are at about the same distance, brighter-looking meant truly more powerful. Her law became the first great yardstick of the universe. Hubble said she deserved a Nobel Prize; she died before she could be nominated.
“Andromeda is moving away like other galaxies.” It is one of the few galaxies moving towards us, at about 110 km/s, because it and the Milky Way are bound together by gravity. They are expected to merge in several billion years (recent studies give it roughly even odds within 10 billion years).
- In 1923 Hubble found a Cepheid in the Andromeda nebula on a photographic plate.
- Its period (31.4 days) gave its true power through Leavitt’s law; comparing with its faintness gave the distance.
- His 1925 result, about 900,000 light-years, proved Andromeda is a separate galaxy.
- A systematic error (two types of Cepheids, found in 1952) meant the true distance is about 2.5 million light-years.
Check yourself
Sources
- E. P. Hubble (1925), Cepheids in spiral nebulae, Publications of the American Astronomical Society 5, 261
- H. S. Leavitt and E. C. Pickering (1912), Periods of 25 variable stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud, Harvard College Observatory Circular 173
- W. Baade (1956), The period-luminosity relation of the Cepheids, PASP 68, 5
- Astronomy course on fibub: variable stars and Leavitt's law https://fibub.com/learn/courses/astronomy/variable-stars/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.