Home / Learn / Science / Cosmology A to Z / Lesson 5.5
All lessons

Module 5: The equations of the universe, gently · Lesson 5.5 · about 14 min

How matter, radiation and dark energy thin out

As the universe grows, matter thins as 1/a³, radiation as 1/a⁴ and dark energy not at all. Why, what it means for the three eras of cosmic history, and when matter took over from light and dark energy from matter.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 5 · about 14 minutes. Read first: 5.3 Critical density and Omega. The Friedmann equation needs to know the density at every moment. Each ingredient thins out at its own rate as the universe grows, and this lesson shows why. By the end you will be able to say which ingredient ruled the universe at any size.

Grow the universe and matter spreads out, light spreads out and loses energy, and dark energy stays exactly as it is. So light ruled the young universe, matter the middle years, and dark energy rules the future.

1. Three ways to thin out

  • Matter (atoms and dark matter): the same particles in a bigger box. Double the size and the volume is 8 times bigger, so the density is 8 times smaller: ρ ∝ 1/a³.
  • Radiation (light and fast neutrinos): photons spread out just like matter (1/a³), and each one is stretched to a longer wavelength and lower energy (another 1/a): ρ ∝ 1/a⁴.
  • Dark energy (a cosmological constant): an energy of empty space itself. More space, same energy in each cubic metre: ρ = constant.
ρr∝a−4,ρm∝a−3,ρΛ=constant
Power of a
how fast each ingredient fades as the universe grows: the higher the power, the faster it fades
Physical meaning
Run time backwards and radiation grows fastest, so it must have dominated early on. Run forwards and only dark energy is left. A universe's history is a hand-over between ingredients.
Density of each ingredient against the size of the universe, on log scales, with today's mix. The dots mark the hand-overs: matter took over from radiation when the universe was about 1/3,400 of today's size; dark energy took over from matter quite recently. Slide the size to read the shares.

2. Three eras

  • Radiation era (first ~50,000 years): light and neutrinos outweighed matter. The universe grew as a ∝ t1/2.
  • Matter era (50,000 years to about 10 billion years): matter ruled; a ∝ t2/3. This is when galaxies formed (Module 10).
  • Dark-energy era (the last ~4 billion years and the future): dark energy outweighs matter, and the expansion grows exponentially.

The moment matter overtook radiation is called matter-radiation equality. It happened at redshift about 3,400, around 50,000 years after the Big Bang (Lesson 6.8). Because radiation is 1/a⁴ and matter 1/a³, they were equal when a = Ωr / Ωm.

Worked example. Matter and dark energy were equal when Ωm/a³ = ΩΛ, so a = (0.31 / 0.69)1/3 = 0.77, a redshift of about 0.3, around 3.5 billion years ago. The Sun and Earth formed in the matter era; we live early in the dark-energy era.

Why we live at a special time. Dark energy and matter happen to be about equal right now, within a factor of two or three, although one is constant and the other has changed by huge factors. Physicists call this the “why now?” or coincidence problem. It may be chance, or a clue about dark energy (Module 9).

“If dark energy has constant density and the universe grows, energy is being created from nothing.” In an expanding universe, energy is not conserved in the everyday way: the light losing energy as it stretches is the other side of the same fact. General relativity has no single total energy for the whole universe.

  • Matter thins as 1/a³ (spreading), radiation as 1/a⁴ (spreading plus stretching), dark energy not at all.
  • So radiation ruled first, matter next (from about 50,000 years, z ≈ 3,400), and dark energy now (from about 3.5 billion years ago).
  • Radiation era a ∝ t1/2; matter era a ∝ t2/3; dark-energy era: exponential growth.
  • Matter and dark energy are close to equal today: the “why now?” puzzle.

Check yourself

1When the universe doubles in size, matter's density falls by:
2Why does radiation thin out faster than matter?
3Which order did the three ingredients rule the expansion in?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.