Home / Learn / Science / Cosmology A to Z / Lesson 9.4
All lessons

Module 9: Dark energy · Lesson 9.4 · about 15 min

Is dark energy changing? The equation of state w

One number, w = pressure ÷ energy density, says how an ingredient thins out and whether it speeds up the expansion. Plus w0 and wa for dark energy that changes.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 9 · about 15 minutes. Read first: 9.2 Einstein’s cosmological constant returns and 5.6 The acceleration equation. After the vacuum energy puzzle (Lesson 9.3), many physicists suspect dark energy is not a perfect constant but something that changes slowly. To test that, you need a way to describe “how constant”. By the end you will be able to use the number w to say how any ingredient thins out and whether it speeds the expansion up.

Divide an ingredient's pressure by its energy density and you get one number, w. It tells you how fast that ingredient thins out as space grows and whether its gravity pulls or pushes. Measuring w over cosmic time is how we test whether dark energy is Einstein's constant.

1. One number for each ingredient

w=pρc2
  • Matter, w = 0: slow particles have almost no pressure compared with their mass-energy.
  • Radiation, w = 1/3: light pushes on the walls of its box with a third of its energy density.
  • Cosmological constant, w = −1: a tension exactly equal to its energy density (Lesson 9.2).

Energy bookkeeping in a growing box (the same dE = −p dV as in Lesson 9.2) gives how each one thins out:

ρ∝a−3(1+w)
a
the scale factor, the size of the universe compared with today
−3(1 + w)
the power that sets how fast it fades: −3 for matter, −4 for radiation, 0 for Λ
Physical meaning
The "3" is spreading into a bigger volume. Positive pressure (light) makes the ingredient lose energy as the box grows, so it fades faster. Tension (w < 0) makes it gain energy, so it fades more slowly; at w = −1 it does not fade at all, and below −1 it actually gets denser.

This is the rule behind Lesson 5.5’s three slopes, now with any w you like.

2. The line at −1/3

In the acceleration equation, gravity’s source is ρ + 3p/c² = ρ(1 + 3w). That is negative, a push, only when w < −1/3. So “dark energy” means any smooth ingredient with w below −1/3 that fills space. For a whole universe, the deceleration parameter adds up each ingredient’s share:

q0=12∑iΩi(1+3wi)
Ωi
each ingredient's share of the critical density today
1 + 3wi
how hard it pulls: 1 for matter, 2 for light, −2 for a cosmological constant
Physical meaning
With matter (w = 0) and Λ (w = −1) this is q0 = Ωm/2 − ΩΛ, the formula from Lesson 5.6. With w = −0.5 instead of −1, the same 69% of dark energy pushes only a quarter as hard.

3. Dark energy that changes

If dark energy is not a constant, the simplest idea is a new field filling space, like the Higgs field, but extremely light. Picture a ball on an almost flat slope. While it barely moves, almost all its energy is the height (potential energy), which acts like a tension, and w is close to −1. As it starts to roll, its motion (kinetic energy) adds positive pressure and w rises towards 0. This kind of dark energy is called quintessence, after the fifth element of ancient philosophy. It always has w between −1 and +1.

Data cannot test every possible w(a), so cosmologists use two numbers, proposed by Michel Chevallier and David Polarski in 2001 and Eric Linder in 2003 (often called CPL):

w(a)=w0+wa(1−a)=w0+waz1+z
w0
today's value (a = 1)
wa
the change: when the universe was very small (a → 0), w was w0 + wa
Physical meaning
A cosmological constant is the single point w0 = −1, wa = 0. Any measured shift away from that point means dark energy is not Einstein's Λ.
Top: w against redshift for your choice of w₀ and wₐ. Bottom: the density of that dark energy as the universe grows (today = 1), against matter (dashed) and a cosmological constant (dotted). Try w₀ = −0.8, wₐ = −0.8: today it thins slowly, but long ago its density was lower and rising.

Things to try. Set w0 below −1: the dark energy gets denser as space grows. That is called phantom dark energy (Robert Caldwell, 2002). It is hard to make from any well-behaved field, and it leads to the Big Rip of Lesson 9.5. Set w0 above −1/3: the readout says the expansion stops speeding up.

4. What we measure

Assume w is constant and combine the CMB, galaxy maps and supernovae: the Planck team (2018) found w = −1.03 ± 0.03. A cosmological constant fits, to within a few per cent. Letting w change is harder, because w0 and wa trade off against each other. The newest maps of the universe have started to pull them away from (−1, 0): that is Lesson 9.6.

Rolling fields and phantoms.

  • 1988 Bharat Ratra and Jim Peebles, and separately Christof Wetterich, propose a slowly rolling field as a changing cosmological "constant".
  • 1998 Robert Caldwell, Rahul Dave and Paul Steinhardt name it quintessence and work out its imprint on the CMB and galaxies.
  • 2001-2003 Chevallier, Polarski and Linder introduce the w0-wa description, still the standard.
  • 2002 Caldwell explores phantom energy with w below −1.
  • 2018 Planck plus other data: w = −1.03 ± 0.03.

“w = −1 means dark energy has negative energy.” Its energy density is positive (ΩΛ ≈ +0.69). It is the pressure that is negative. Negative energy density would do the opposite: slow the expansion and could even make the universe recollapse.

  • The equation of state w = p/(ρc²): matter 0, radiation 1/3, cosmological constant −1.
  • Density thins as ρ ∝ a−3(1+w): w = −1 never thins; w < −1 (phantom) grows denser.
  • Gravity’s source is ρ(1 + 3w), so speeding up needs w < −1/3. In general q0 = ½ΣΩi(1 + 3wi).
  • Changing dark energy (quintessence: a slowly rolling field) is described by w(a) = w0 + wa(1 − a); Λ is (−1, 0).
  • Measured with constant w: −1.03 ± 0.03.

Check yourself

1What value of w does a cosmological constant have?
2Which kinds of stuff can make the expansion speed up?
3In the description w(a) = w0 + wa(1 − a), what does wa measure?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.