Module 6: The first three minutes and after · Lesson 6.9 · about 16 min
Recombination: the universe becomes transparent
For 380,000 years the universe was a glowing fog of free electrons. At about 3,000 K electrons joined nuclei to make atoms, the fog cleared and light flew free: the cosmic microwave background. Why it waited until 0.3 eV, not 13.6 eV.
Module 6 · about 16 minutes. Read first: 6.3 Hotter in the past and 6.8 When matter took over from light. After the first minutes the universe was a hot plasma of nuclei, electrons and light. Here it cools enough for atoms to form, and the light we now see as the cosmic microwave background sets off. By the end you will be able to explain why the universe was opaque, why atoms formed at 3,000 K rather than at the 150,000 K you might expect, and when the light last scattered.
1. A glowing fog
Light bounces off free electrons (this is Thomson scattering). In the young universe every hydrogen and helium nucleus had lost its electrons, so a photon could travel only a short way before being knocked in a new direction. The universe was opaque, like the inside of a cloud or the Sun: bright everywhere, but you cannot see through it.
A few thousand light-years between bounces sounds far, but light had by then been travelling for hundreds of thousands of years, zig-zagging the whole time. Once electrons are captured into atoms, there is almost nothing left to bounce off: neutral hydrogen barely affects light of these wavelengths.
2. Why not at 13.6 eV?
Hydrogen needs 13.6 eV to lose its electron. That is kT at about 158,000 K, so you might expect atoms from about then. They had to wait until about 3,000 K, fifty times cooler. The reason is the same crowd as in the deuterium bottleneck (Lesson 6.6): there are about 1.6 billion photons for every atom. A blackbody always has a tail of photons far more energetic than kT, and with so many photons, even a tiny fraction above 13.6 eV is enough to break every atom that forms.
The balance between atoms forming and breaking is given by the Saha equation, worked out by the Indian astrophysicist Meghnad Saha in 1920 to read the spectra of stars. Written with η, the number of atoms per photon, it says:
- x
- the fraction of hydrogen still ionised (free electrons per hydrogen nucleus)
- η
- atoms per photon, 6.1 × 10−10 (Lesson 6.6): the tiny number that holds recombination back
- mec²
- the electron's mass energy, 511,000 eV
- e13.6 eV/kT
- the Boltzmann factor: how strongly cooling favours bound atoms
- Physical meaning
- The right side is tiny (η and (kT/mec²)3/2 are both small) unless the exponential is huge. Half the atoms form (x = 1/2) only when kT ≈ 0.32 eV, about 3,700 K, z ≈ 1,380.
The real universe is a little slower than Saha’s balance. An electron dropping straight into the lowest level gives out a photon of 13.6 eV or more, which promptly ionises another atom; one dropping to the lowest level from the next one up gives out a Lyman-alpha photon that is quickly absorbed again by another atom. Atoms mostly get to their ground state the slow way, by a rare two-photon decay or by the stretching of space moving a Lyman-alpha photon out of reach. Jim Peebles, and independently Yakov Zel’dovich, Vladimir Kurt and Rashid Sunyaev, worked this out in 1968.
3. Last scattering
Planck measures last scattering at z = 1,089.9, or 377,700 years after the start, with the light at about 2,970 K, about as hot as the surface of a cool red dwarf star. (The rounded model in these figures gives 372,000 years.) Since then its wavelength has stretched about 1,090 times, from the near infrared to microwaves, and its temperature has fallen to 2.7255 K.
The place where this happened, seen from here, is a shell all around us at the edge of what light can show: the surface of last scattering. Whatever direction you look, you see the fog at the moment it cleared. That glowing wall, its discovery in 1965 and what its tiny ripples tell us, is Module 7, starting with Lesson 7.1.
A misleading name. “Recombination” suggests electrons and nuclei joining again, but they had never been joined: before this, the universe had always been too hot for atoms. The name was borrowed from laboratory plasma physics. The Saha equation came from Meghnad Saha, working in Calcutta and London, who in 1920 used it to explain why stars of different temperatures show different spectral lines (Astronomy: spectral lines). Half a century later the same equation set the moment the cosmic microwave background was released.
“The cosmic microwave background is the light given out by the first atoms as they formed.” Recombining atoms did give out some photons, but they were a tiny addition: there are 1.6 billion photons for every atom. The CMB is the light that had filled the universe since the first second, set free when the fog of electrons cleared. It is the leftover heat of the hot beginning.
- Free electrons scatter light (Thomson scattering): the young universe was an opaque, glowing fog.
- Hydrogen’s 13.6 eV would suggest atoms at about 158,000 K, but with 1.6 billion photons per atom they survive only below about 0.3 eV. Saha’s equation: half the atoms at about 3,700 K (z ≈ 1,380); the full calculation is slower.
- Last scattering: z ≈ 1,090, T ≈ 2,970 K, about 380,000 years after the start (Planck: 377,700).
- Helium went neutral first; a few electrons in 10,000 stay free afterwards.
- The released light, stretched 1,090 times, is the cosmic microwave background (Module 7).
Check yourself
Sources
- M. N. Saha (1920), Ionization in the solar chromosphere, Philosophical Magazine 40, 472 https://doi.org/10.1080/14786441008636148
- P. J. E. Peebles (1968), Recombination of the primeval plasma, ApJ 153, 1 https://doi.org/10.1086/149628
- Ya. B. Zel'dovich, V. G. Kurt and R. A. Sunyaev (1968), Recombination of hydrogen in the hot model of the universe, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 55, 278 (Soviet Physics JETP 28, 146, 1969)
- S. Seager, D. D. Sasselov and D. Scott (2000), How exactly did the universe become neutral?, ApJS 128, 407 https://doi.org/10.1086/313388
- Planck Collaboration (2020), Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, A&A 641, A6 https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201833910
- B. Ryden (2017), Introduction to Cosmology, 2nd edition, chapter 8, Cambridge University Press https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316651087
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.