Module 6: Astrophotography · Lesson 6.2 · about 25 min
Exposure, noise and signal-to-noise
Every image is signal plus noise. Photon counts have a natural randomness, the square root of the count, so the signal-to-noise ratio grows only as the square root of exposure time. Dark skies and low read noise help.
Module 6 · about 25 minutes · read first: 6.1 Cameras, pixels and image scale, 1.7 How bright is it? The magnitude scale · maths: square roots. You’ll be able to name the sources of noise in an astronomical image, compute signal-to-noise, and work out how exposure, sky and camera affect it.
1. Why this matters
Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is the single most important number in observational astronomy. It decides whether a faint galaxy shows up, how precise a brightness measurement is (Astronomy 5.1) and how long a professional telescope proposal asks for. Once you think in SNR, every choice in imaging becomes a trade you can calculate.
2. Where noise comes from
- Shot noise: photons arrive at random. If you expect on average, you’ll get give or take (Poisson statistics). This affects the star and the sky glow behind it.
- Dark current: heat in the sensor knocks loose electrons even in darkness. Cooling the camera reduces it. It too has shot noise.
- Read noise: each time the camera reads a pixel it adds a few electrons of random error, once per frame.
Things to notice:
- At short exposures read noise matters; once the sky signal per frame is large, the curve follows √t.
- Raise the sky glow and the same star needs much longer for the same SNR.
Watch signal and noise grow during an exposure:
Maths and principle
The CCD equation (simplified). A star gives electrons per second over pixels; sky gives per second per pixel; dark current per second per pixel; read noise per pixel per frame; exposure :
Sky-limited case (sky term dominates): , so SNR grows as and falls as .
Try it: a star giving 50 e⁻/s, with 20 pixels of sky at 5 e⁻/s each, no read noise, 60 s: .
3. What helps
- Longer total exposure (one long or many short; Lesson 6.4).
- Darker sky: a sky 2.5 times darker (1 mag/arcsec²) is worth about 2.5 times the exposure time in the sky-limited case.
- Bigger aperture: more signal per second from the same star.
- Narrowband filters: passing only the light of glowing gas (such as hydrogen-alpha) cuts the sky glow enormously, which is why city imagers love them for emission nebulae.
- Cooling the camera to cut dark current.
- √N
- Shot noise: random spread of a count of N photons.
- SNR = St / √(St + n(B + D)t + nR²)
- The CCD equation: star, sky, dark and read noise.
- SNR ∝ √t
- In the sky-limited case, four times the time doubles the SNR.
- Physical meaning
- Catching photons is like counting raindrops in a cup: the number in any minute varies by chance. The variation grows more slowly than the count, so the longer you collect, the smaller the chance part is compared with the total.
“Subtracting the sky removes its noise.” Subtracting removes the sky’s average level but not its random flicker. That noise stays in your image, which is why dark skies make such a difference to faint targets.
4. Worked example
How long for SNR 50 on a faint star? Star 10 e⁻/s, sky 20 pixels × 3 e⁻/s each = 60 e⁻/s, read noise ignored (long frames).
so and s, about 29 minutes. With a sky four times darker (15 e⁻/s): , so s, about 10 minutes. The darker site saves two-thirds of the time.
5. Practice
More practice (answers below):
- You expect 400 photons. What is the shot noise?
- An image has SNR 20 after 10 minutes, sky-limited. How long for SNR 40?
- Why does subtracting a constant sky level not remove light pollution’s harm?
Answers
- photons.
- 4 times longer: 40 minutes.
- The sky’s random fluctuations (shot noise) stay; only its average is removed.
- Photon (shot) noise is √N.
- SNR = St / √(St + n(B + D)t + nR²).
- Sky-limited: SNR grows as √t and falls as 1/√B.
- Magnitude error ≈ 1.086 / SNR.
Try it with real numbers: plan exposure lengths for your sky and camera with the sub-exposure calculator.
New words: signal-to-noise ratio, shot noise, Poisson statistics, dark current, read noise, sky-limited, narrowband filter.
Check yourself
Sources
- Howell, S. B. (2006), Handbook of CCD Astronomy, 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press (the CCD equation, calibration frames)
- Berry, R. and Burnell, J. (2005), The Handbook of Astronomical Image Processing, 2nd ed., Willmann-Bell
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers in the examples are made up to show the idea unless a source is given. Simulations run in your browser on made-up data; nothing you type is sent anywhere. Astronomy only: nothing here is astrology.