Module 5: Drawing conclusions · Lesson 5.3 · about 14 min
Resolve the paradox
Paradox questions present two facts that seem to clash and ask which new fact explains how both can be true. Name the clash, then pick the answer that makes both facts make sense together.
Module 5 · about 14 minutes · read first: 3.3. By the end you will explain how two clashing facts can both be true.
1. The question stem
“Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?”, “…explain…”, “…reconcile…”
2. Name the clash first
- Discrepancy
- two facts that seem to conflict
- Resolution
- a new fact that shows how both can be true
- Physical meaning
- Paradoxes on the LSAT are never real contradictions. Something changed, or two groups differ, in a way the passage did not tell you. Find that hidden difference.
3. Wrong answers
- Explains only one fact. “Lower limits make drivers more careful” deepens the puzzle.
- Makes it worse. Adds a reason the second fact should not have happened.
- Irrelevant. About a different road, time or group.
Try it: a full question
“A supermarket chain cut the price of its own-brand bread by 20%, yet its total bread revenue rose.”
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy?
(A) The cheaper bread drew so many new buyers that far more loaves were sold. (B) The chain’s competitors also sell bread. (C) Bread is one of the chain’s least profitable products. (D) Some customers prefer more expensive bread. (E) The chain also cut the price of milk.
Answer: (A). Lower price per loaf, but many more loaves: revenue can rise. (B) and (E) do not explain the rise. (C) is about profit, not revenue. (D) suggests people might buy less of the cheaper bread, which makes the puzzle worse.
“The answer should show one of the facts is wrong.” Both facts are given as true. The answer explains them; it never disputes them.
Practice set
Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.
- Name the two facts and why they seem to clash.
- The right answer is a new fact that lets both be true, often a hidden difference or change.
- Eliminate answers that explain only one side, deepen the puzzle, or are off topic.
Check yourself
Sources
- LSAC, Logical Reasoning questions (description) https://www.lsac.org/lsat/prepare/types-lsat-questions/logical-reasoning-questions
- fibub LSAT question bank (original arguments) https://fibub.com/learn/courses/lsat/paradox/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.