Module 4: Describing arguments · Lesson 4.1 · about 18 min
Flaw questions
Flaw questions ask you to describe what is wrong with an argument. Spot the gap, name the flaw from the catalogue, then match it to the abstract answer that describes it exactly.
Module 4 · about 18 minutes · read first: 2.6. By the end you will describe the error in an argument and match it to the precise abstract wording of the right answer. Flaw questions are among the most common on the LSAT.
1. The question stem
“The reasoning in the argument is flawed because the argument…”, “…is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it…”, “Which one of the following identifies a reasoning error in the argument?”
2. Method
- Find premises and conclusion.
- Ask: why might the premises be true and the conclusion still false? That scenario is the flaw.
- Name it (use the catalogue in Lesson 2.6).
- Match: the right answer describes your flaw as it happens in this argument.
- "Presumes, without providing justification, that..."
- the argument assumes what follows; check that it really does assume it
- "Fails to consider the possibility that..."
- the argument ignores a scenario; check that the scenario would hurt the argument
- "Takes for granted"
- same as "presumes"
- Physical meaning
- Every right flaw answer passes two checks: the argument really does this, and doing it really is a problem here.
Try it: a full question
“Critics say the new stadium will cause traffic jams. But the critics include several people who live near the site and simply do not want a stadium next door. So their claim about traffic can be dismissed.”
The argument’s reasoning is flawed because it
(A) rejects a claim by attacking the motives of those who make it rather than the claim itself. (B) relies on a sample that is too small. (C) confuses a necessary condition with a sufficient one. (D) assumes that what is true of a group is true of each member. (E) uses the word “traffic” in two different senses.
Answer: (A). Whether the critics have a personal interest says nothing about whether the stadium will cause traffic jams. That is an attack on the person (ad hominem). The other answers name real flaws, but not flaws this argument commits.
“If an answer names a real flaw, it could be right.” It must be the flaw in this argument. The four wrong answers usually describe real flaws that simply do not happen here.
Practice set
Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.
- Premises are true; the flaw is how they are used.
- Imagine the premises true and the conclusion false: that scenario reveals the flaw.
- Name it in your own words, then match the abstract answer.
- Check each answer: does the argument do this, and is it a problem here?
Check yourself
Sources
- LSAC, Logical Reasoning questions (description) https://www.lsac.org/lsat/prepare/types-lsat-questions/logical-reasoning-questions
- fibub LSAT question bank (original arguments) https://fibub.com/learn/courses/lsat/flaw/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.