Home / Learn / Exam prep / LSAT prep / Lesson 4.2
All lessons

Module 4: Describing arguments · Lesson 4.2 · about 16 min

Method of reasoning

Method questions ask how an argument makes its case: by analogy, by counterexample, by eliminating alternatives, by pointing out a consequence, and so on. Describe the steps, then match the abstract answer.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 4 · about 16 minutes · read first: 2.3. By the end you will describe how any argument makes its case and match that description to the abstract answer choices.

Method questions ask for a description of the argument's strategy, not its topic. Strip away the subject matter and describe the moves: "it gives an example that contradicts a general claim", "it shows two cases are alike".

1. Common methods

Counterexample. "Some say no film from that studio has made a profit. But its 2019 film did." One case refutes an "all" or "no".
Analogy. "Requiring a licence to drive is sensible; flying a large drone is just as risky, so it should need a licence too."
Eliminating alternatives. "The leak is not from the roof or the windows, so it must be from the pipes."
Unacceptable consequence. "If we accept your rule, then no one could ever borrow a book, which is absurd." (Also called reductio.)
Questioning the evidence. "The survey supporting your view only asked people already using the service."
General principle applied to a case. "Public money should fund only public goods. This stadium benefits one private team. So it should not get public money."
Method
the strategy the argument uses, described without its topic
Abstract wording
"a general claim", "a particular case", "an analogous situation", "a consequence of the opponent's position"
Physical meaning
If you could swap "drones" for "boats" and "licence" for "permit" and the answer still fits, you are describing the method, not the topic.
Try it: a full question

“Dana: Our school should drop its uniform rule, because uniforms do not improve learning. Lee: Improving learning was never the point of the rule. It was adopted so students from poorer families would not feel singled out by their clothes, and it still does that.”

Lee responds to Dana by

(A) arguing that Dana has misidentified the purpose of the rule. (B) offering a counterexample to Dana’s claim about learning. (C) showing that Dana’s argument leads to an absurd consequence. (D) agreeing with Dana’s conclusion for a different reason. (E) questioning the evidence Dana gives about learning.

Answer: (A). Lee does not dispute whether uniforms improve learning; Lee says that was never the rule’s purpose. (B) and (E) would challenge the learning claim, which Lee leaves alone. (D) is wrong: Lee disagrees with dropping the rule.

“Most of the answer fits, so it’s right.” A method answer must fit completely. If one clause describes a move the argument does not make (say, “cites an expert”), the whole answer is wrong.

Practice set

Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.

  • Describe the argument’s moves, without the topic.
  • Know the common methods: counterexample, analogy, elimination, unacceptable consequence, questioning evidence, principle applied.
  • Check every clause of an answer against the passage.
  • Method answers are neutral: the argument may be good or flawed.

Check yourself

1"Not all birds fly: penguins are birds and cannot fly." What method is this?
2How is a method question different from a flaw question?
3What makes a method answer wrong even if it sounds right?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.