All lessons

Module 9: Hiring and payroll · Lesson 9.1 · about 12 min

Employee or contractor

How to tell whether someone working for your startup is an employee or an independent contractor in India, Canada and the USA: the control, tools, profit and integration tests, California’s ABC test, what misclassification costs, and how to hire contractors safely, including abroad.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Rules for

Module 9 · about 12 minutes. You’ll know who must be on payroll, and how to work with contractors without getting a bill for back taxes later.

Whether someone is an employee depends on how the work really happens (who controls it, whose tools, who carries the risk), not on what the contract calls them.

1. Why it matters

An employee works in your business; you withhold their income tax, pay employer contributions, and give them minimum wage, holidays and notice. A contractor runs their own business and invoices you; they handle their own taxes. Calling an employee a contractor does not make them one, and getting it wrong means back payroll taxes, penalties and claims for holiday pay or severance.

Checker: employee or contractor?
Leans

The questions follow the tests used by the CRA (control, tools, chance of profit, integration), the IRS (behavioural, financial and relationship control) and Indian courts (control and integration), and California’s stricter ABC test. No single answer decides; the whole relationship does, whatever the contract calls it. When unsure, the CRA (form CPT1) and IRS (Form SS-8) will rule for you.

2. The tests

  • Control: do you decide when, where and how the work is done?
  • Tools and equipment: whose laptop, software, vehicle?
  • Chance of profit or risk of loss: fixed-price jobs, their own costs, the ability to hire helpers.
  • Integration: is the work part of your core business, done alongside your staff, or a separate service?
  • Independence: other clients, a business name, website, insurance, invoices.

Indian courts look mainly at control and integration. A long-term “consultant” who works only for you, on your schedule, can be found an employee for PF, ESI, gratuity and the labour codes. Contractors are paid against invoices with TDS under 194J (10 %) or 194C (1 % or 2 %); employees’ tax is deducted under section 192.

The CRA (and Revenu Québec) apply the four-factor test from the courts; provinces apply their own tests for employment standards. You or the worker can ask the CRA for a ruling (form CPT1). Contractors over $30,000 a year charge you GST/HST.

The IRS looks at behavioural control, financial control and the relationship; the Department of Labor uses an “economic reality” test for minimum wage and overtime; and states such as California, Massachusetts and New Jersey use the stricter ABC test, under which a worker is an employee unless the work is outside your usual business. Contractors give you a W-9 and get a 1099-NEC if paid $2,000 or more in 2026.

3. Hiring contractors safely

Working with a contractor

  1. Write a contract for a defined project or service, with deliverables, price and an IP assignment (Lesson 11.3).
  2. Let them choose how and when to work, use their own equipment and invoice you.
  3. Collect their tax details: PAN (India), GST/HST number if registered (Canada), Form W-9 (USA) or W-8BEN for someone abroad.
  4. Pay against invoices; deduct TDS where Indian law requires it.
  5. Review every 6 months: if they now look like staff, offer employment.

Key idea: Contractors are ideal for short, specialised or uncertain work. For a full-time role at the core of your business that you direct day to day, hire an employee or use an employer of record.

4. Hiring someone in another country

You usually cannot simply put a foreign resident on your payroll. Options: a contractor agreement (if they are genuinely independent), an employer of record (EOR) that employs them locally for a fee, or setting up a local entity once you have several people there. Remote employees can also create a tax presence for your company abroad.

Employee
works in your business under your direction; on payroll
Independent contractor
runs their own business and invoices you
Control test
who decides when, where and how the work is done
ABC test
a stricter US state test: an employee unless the work is outside your usual business, among other conditions
Employer of record
a company that legally employs your worker abroad for a fee
What it means for you
Use contractors for defined projects; put people who work for you full-time, under your direction, on payroll from the start.

5. Worked example

Made-up founder. Ana’s Vancouver startup has paid a developer $6,000 a month for a year. He works 9 to 5 on her team’s sprints, uses a company laptop and has no other clients. The checker says employee. She puts him on payroll from next month (CPP, EI, income tax and vacation pay) and asks her accountant about the past year.

“If they sign a contractor agreement and send invoices, they are a contractor.” Tax and labour authorities look at reality. A full-time “contractor” on your schedule, using your laptop and working only for you, is usually an employee, and you owe the missed payroll taxes.

6. Practice

  1. Name two signs that a person is in business for themselves.
  2. Why is the ABC test stricter?
  3. What can you use to hire a full-time person in another country without opening an entity there?
Answers
  1. Other clients; sets own prices; own tools and insurance; can hire helpers; can make a loss.
  2. The worker must also do work outside your usual business, which few full-time workers do.
  3. An employer of record.
  • The label does not decide; control, tools, chance of profit, integration and independence do.
  • Misclassification brings back payroll taxes, penalties and claims for holiday pay or notice.
  • India: long-term exclusive “consultants” can be employees for PF, ESI and gratuity; Canada: CRA four-factor test and CPT1 rulings; USA: IRS test plus the ABC test in some states.
  • Contractors need a written contract with IP assignment and their tax details (PAN, GST/HST number, W-9 or W-8BEN).
  • For full-time people abroad, use an employer of record or a local entity.

Next: India: payroll, PF, ESI and the labour codes, Canada payroll or US payroll.

New words: employee, independent contractor, misclassification, ABC test, employer of record, 1099-NEC, W-9.

Rules as of November 2026. Not legal or tax advice.

Check yourself

1Your contract calls someone a "consultant". Does that settle it?
2Which sign points most to a genuine contractor?
3In Canada, what can happen if the CRA decides your contractor was an employee?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.