Module 10: Co-founders and equity · Lesson 10.5 · about 12 min
When a co-founder leaves
What happens when a co-founder leaves or the founders fall out: good and bad leaver terms, buying back shares, handing over work and accounts, resigning as director, tax on the buy-back, mediation and arbitration, deadlock, and how to part without killing the company.
Module 10 · about 12 minutes. You’ll handle a co-founder’s exit by the agreement, protect the company, and keep a dispute out of court.
1. Leaving by the agreement
If you signed vesting and leaver terms (Lessons 10.1 and 10.3), most of the hard questions are already answered: how many shares the leaver keeps, at what price the rest come back, and by when. Without them, the leaver keeps every share and every right a shareholder has, and the remaining founders work for them.
2. The exit checklist
When a co-founder leaves
- Agree the date and whether they are a good or bad leaver under the agreement; put it in a short separation letter.
- Buy back or transfer unvested shares at the agreed price; update the share register and cap table.
- Resign as director and file the change (India: DIR-11 and DIR-12 within 30 days; Canada: notice of change within 15 days federally; USA: board minutes and the next state report).
- Hand over passwords, domain, code repositories, bank signing rights and customer relationships.
- Remind them of their confidentiality, IP assignment and non-solicitation duties; collect equipment.
- Tell the team and key customers together, with one simple message.
3. Tax on the buy-back
The leaver may have a capital gain or loss on shares sold back. In India a company buy-back is taxed as a deemed dividend in the shareholder’s hands since October 2024; in Canada a redemption above paid-up capital is a deemed dividend; in the USA a repurchase of unvested stock at cost usually has no gain. Small amounts at the original price rarely create tax, but check before agreeing a higher price.
4. When founders fall out
- Talk early with a neutral person: a mentor, an investor, a coach.
- Follow the agreement’s deadlock route: mediation, then arbitration (India’s Arbitration and Conciliation Act; provincial arbitration acts; the US Federal Arbitration Act).
- As a last resort, one founder buys the other out, or the company is sold or closed (Lesson 12.5). Courts can step in for oppression of a minority shareholder, but it is slow and costly.
Key idea: Separate the business from the friendship. The agreement handles the shares; your job is to keep customers served and the team calm while it is done.
- Good leaver
- leaves for an accepted reason; keeps vested shares
- Bad leaver
- leaves in breach; may lose vested shares at a low price
- Buy-back
- the company or founders buy the leaver’s shares
- Mediation
- a neutral person helps the founders agree
- Arbitration
- a private decision-maker gives a binding ruling
- What it means for you
- Follow the exit checklist the week someone leaves: shares, director filings, passwords, customers, and one clear message to the team.
5. Worked example
Made-up founders. After 20 months Ben leaves Asha’s Pune startup to move abroad, a good leaver. He keeps 187,500 vested shares; the other 262,500 go to Asha and the option pool at the original ₹10 a share under the SHA. He resigns as director (DIR-11, DIR-12), hands over the AWS account, and stays as an adviser for three months. The investors see a clean cap table at the next round.
“A founder who leaves loses their shares automatically.” Only if an agreement says so. Without vesting and leaver terms, a departed founder keeps every share and every shareholder right.
6. Practice
- What protects the company if a leaver joins a competitor?
- Which filings record a director’s resignation in India?
- Why keep the leaver as a shareholder rather than forcing them out entirely?
Answers
- Bad-leaver terms (if joining a competitor is listed), confidentiality and non-solicitation clauses; non-competes are often unenforceable.
- DIR-11 (by the director) and DIR-12 (by the company).
- Vested shares were earned; taking them would breach the agreement and invite a dispute.
- Leaver terms decide what a departing founder keeps: vested shares for a good leaver, often nothing for a bad leaver.
- Update the share register and cap table; file the director’s resignation (India DIR-11/DIR-12, Canada notice of change).
- Hand over passwords, domains, code, bank rights and customer relationships the same week.
- A buy-back can be taxed (India: deemed dividend since October 2024): check before agreeing a price.
- Use mediation and arbitration before court.
Next: Module 11 starts with Intellectual property.
New words: good / bad leaver, buy-back, share register, separation letter, mediation, arbitration, oppression remedy.
Rules as of November 2026. Not legal or tax advice.
Check yourself
Sources
- Ministry of Corporate Affairs, director resignation (DIR-11, DIR-12): https://www.mca.gov.in
- Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (India): https://www.indiacode.nic.in
- Corporations Canada, notice of change of directors: https://ised-isde.canada.ca/site/corporations-canada/en
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.