Phase transitions and critical phenomena
Statistical physics · 83 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Phase transitions.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
In Ehrenfest’s classification, a first-order phase transition is one in which- the Gibbs energy itself jumps
- first derivatives of the Gibbs energy, such as and , jump
- only the second derivatives, such as , jump
- nothing measurable changes
Answer and solution
Answer: B
is continuous across any transition (the phases coexist with equal ). In a first-order transition and jump, giving a latent heat and a volume change: melting, boiling. -
MCQWarm-up
Which feature marks a continuous (second-order) phase transition?- A large latent heat
- Coexistence of two phases with different densities
- No latent heat, with the order parameter growing continuously from zero below
- A jump in the volume
Answer and solution
Answer: C
In a continuous transition and are continuous (no latent heat), while response functions such as or jump or diverge. The order parameter rises smoothly from zero. -
MCQWarm-up
The natural order parameter for the ferromagnet-paramagnet transition is- the spontaneous magnetisation
- the susceptibility
- the temperature
- the heat capacity
Answer and solution
Answer: A
An order parameter is zero in the disordered (symmetric) phase and non-zero in the ordered phase: the spontaneous magnetisation at zero field. For liquid-gas it is ; for a superconductor the gap or pair amplitude. -
MCQWarm-up
By the Gibbs phase rule, how many intensive variables can be changed independently at the triple point of a pure substance?- 2
- 1
- 3
- 0
Answer and solution
Answer: D
. The triple point has a fixed and , which is why the triple point of water defined the kelvin for decades. -
MCQWarm-up
The Clausius-Clapeyron equation gives the slope of a coexistence curve asAnswer and solution
Answer: D
Equal chemical potentials along the curve: , so , with and per unit mass (or per mole) for the same change. -
MSQWarm-up
Which of these are continuous (second-order) transitions?- Iron losing its ferromagnetism at the Curie point in zero field
- Water passing through its liquid-gas critical point
- A metal becoming superconducting in zero magnetic field
- Ice melting at 273 K and 1 atm
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The first three have no latent heat and a growing order parameter or diverging response. Melting has a latent heat of 334 kJ/kg: first order. -
MCQWarm-up
Water and steam coexist at C and atm. Which molar quantity has the same value in both phases?- The molar Gibbs energy
- The molar entropy
- The molar volume
- The molar enthalpy
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Two phases coexist in equilibrium only if moving a molecule from one to the other does not change : their chemical potentials (molar Gibbs energies) are equal. Entropy, volume and enthalpy all jump; the jumps in and give the latent heat , and the jump in appears in the Clausius-Clapeyron equation.Why people get this wrong: At a first-order transition the first derivatives of jump while itself is continuous.
-
MCQStandard
In Landau theory with . Below the equilibrium order parameter isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
gives . The solution is a maximum below . -
MCQStandard
In mean-field (Landau) theory the order parameter vanishes as withAnswer and solution
Answer: C
, so . The exact 2D Ising value is and the 3D value is about : fluctuations, ignored by mean field, change the exponents. -
NATStandard
In Landau theory, is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 2 (±0.001)
: . -
MCQStandard
Above the Curie temperature, the susceptibility of a ferromagnet in mean-field theory followsAnswer and solution
Answer: D
The Weiss molecular field adds to the applied field: , giving with . So in mean field. ( describes antiferromagnets above .) -
NATStandard
For the Ising model () on a square lattice with meV, mean-field theory predicts . The predicted is ______ K.Answer and solution
Answer: 46.4 K (±0.5)
Each spin feels the mean field of neighbours, ; self-consistency has a non-zero solution below meV, i.e. K. (Onsager’s exact answer is 43% lower.) -
MCQStandard
The one-dimensional Ising model with nearest-neighbour coupling and no field- orders below
- has no phase transition at any
- orders below
- has a first-order transition
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A single domain wall costs only but can sit at any of places, gaining entropy ; at any walls appear and destroy long-range order. The exact solution confirms . Mean field wrongly predicts . -
NATStandard
Ice melts at K with J/kg. The specific volumes are m/kg (ice) and m/kg (water). The slope of the melting curve is ______ MPa/K.Answer and solution
Answer: -13.4 MPa/K (±0.15)
Pa/K. Negative because ice is less dense than water: pressure lowers the melting point, by about 0.0075 K per atmosphere. -
MCQStandard
In an Ehrenfest second-order transition, which quantities are discontinuous?- and
- , the thermal expansivity and the compressibility
- The Gibbs energy
- The latent heat and the volume
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Second derivatives of jump: , , . , and are continuous. -
MCQStandard
At the magnetisation responds to a small field as . In mean-field theory is- 1
- 2
- 15
- 3
Answer and solution
Answer: D
At the quadratic term vanishes: , so and . (2D Ising: .) -
MCQStandard
Near , with , the standard critical exponents are defined by- , , ,
- , , ,
- , , ,
- only above
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Positive exponents describe the divergence of , and and the vanishing of . Mean field: (a jump), , , , . -
NATStandard
At the critical temperature of a mean-field magnet, the field is increased 8 times. The magnetisation increases by a factor of ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 2 (±0.001)
: . -
MSQStandard
Which statements about spontaneous symmetry breaking at a ferromagnetic transition are correct?- The Hamiltonian is symmetric under reversing all spins, but the low-temperature state is not
- Below the system picks one of the equivalent ordered states
- In zero field the average magnetisation of a finite system, over infinite time, is zero
- The symmetry is broken by the Hamiltonian itself
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The ordered state has lower symmetry than . In the thermodynamic limit the time to flip between and becomes infinite, so the system stays in one; a finite system eventually samples both and averages to zero. The Hamiltonian stays symmetric. -
MSQStandard
Which statements about coexistence curves on a - phase diagram are correct?- The melting curve of water has a negative slope
- The boiling curve of every substance has a positive slope
- Along a coexistence curve the two phases have equal chemical potential
- The slope of a coexistence curve is zero at the triple point
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Clapeyron: slope . Water expands on freezing, so its melting slope is negative. Vaporisation always has and , so a positive slope. Coexistence means . At the triple point three curves meet with finite, different slopes. -
NATStandard
kg of water is held in a rigid m vessel at C, where liquid and vapour coexist (specific volumes and m/kg). The fraction of the mass that is vapour is ______ (three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.299 (±0.002)
With vapour fraction , the specific volume is , so (the lever rule). Although only 30% of the mass is vapour, it fills almost all of the volume.Why people get this wrong: The vapour fills over of the volume; the question asks for its share of the mass.
-
MCQStandard
Pure water can be cooled several degrees below C without freezing, but a ferromagnet cooled through its Curie point in zero field cannot stay non-magnetic. The reason is that- water has a much larger heat capacity than iron
- the Curie point depends on pressure, the freezing point does not
- magnetic forces act faster than the forces between water molecules
- a first-order transition has a free-energy barrier (a new phase must nucleate), while at a continuous transition the old state becomes unstable at once
Answer and solution
Answer: D
At a first-order transition the two phases are separate minima of the free energy; below the melting point the liquid is still a local minimum, and forming ice requires a nucleus whose surface energy creates a barrier. So the liquid can persist (supercooling). At a continuous transition the single minimum at splits: below the old state is a maximum, so fluctuations destroy it immediately. Hysteresis and metastability are marks of first-order transitions.Why people get this wrong: Supercooling is not about how fast heat is removed; it needs a barrier, which only first-order transitions have.
-
NATExam level
A system has Landau free energy density with J mK, J m and K. The jump in heat capacity per unit volume at is ______ J Km.Answer and solution
Answer: 500 J K⁻¹ m⁻³ (±3)
Below , and . below, 0 above (beyond ). Jump J Km; the ordered side is higher. -
MCQExam level
In mean-field theory of the Ising model ( neighbours, coupling , zero field) the magnetisation per spin satisfiesAnswer and solution
Answer: A
Replace the neighbours by their average : each spin sees an effective field , so . Graphically, a non-zero crossing exists only when the slope at the origin exceeds 1: . (The Langevin form belongs to classical vector spins.) -
NATExam level
Solve the mean-field equation at . The spontaneous magnetisation is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.957 (±0.002)
Iterate from : converging to . Already 96% saturated at half of . -
MCQExam level
The Rushbrooke scaling relation is . Which set of exponents satisfies it?- (mean field)
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Mean field: . 2D Ising () also works: . The others give 3, 1.25 and 2.5. -
NATExam level
For the 2D Ising model and . Using the Widom relation , is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 15
. -
NATExam level
For the 3D Ising universality class and . From the Rushbrooke relation, is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.111 (±0.002)
: a weak divergence of the heat capacity, seen in fluids near their critical point. -
MCQExam level
Onsager’s exact result for the square-lattice Ising model is . Compared with mean-field theory, this is- higher, because mean field overestimates fluctuations
- lower, because mean field ignores the fluctuations that oppose ordering
- the same
- lower, because mean field counts too few neighbours
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Mean field gives . Real fluctuations (local disorder) make ordering harder, so the true is lower: of the mean-field value. -
MSQExam level
A Landau expansion () contains a cubic term. Which statements are correct?- The transition becomes first order
- It occurs above
- The order parameter jumps at the transition
- A cubic term is allowed only if and are physically equivalent
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The cubic term makes a second minimum at that reaches the height of while is still positive, so jumps from 0 at some : first order. A cubic term is forbidden when is a symmetry (as for a ferromagnet); it appears for, e.g., the nematic liquid crystal or the 3-state Potts model.