Heat capacity: Einstein and Debye
Solid state physics and devices · 87 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Heat capacity: Einstein and Debye.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATWarm-up
According to the law of Dulong and Petit, the molar heat capacity of a monatomic solid at high temperature is ______ J mol K (to two decimal places). Use J mol K.Answer and solution
Answer: 24.94 J/(mol K) (±0.03)
Each atom is a 3D oscillator with of energy by equipartition. Per mole and J mol K.Why people get this wrong: Counting only kinetic energy gives , the monatomic gas value.
-
MCQWarm-up
At very low temperatures the lattice heat capacity of a three-dimensional insulating crystal varies asAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Only long-wavelength acoustic phonons, with , are excited. Their number in 3D grows as (a sphere of radius in -space), each holding about , so and : the Debye law.Why people get this wrong: is the Einstein model's prediction, which falls too fast; is the electronic term in metals; belongs to ferromagnetic magnons.
-
MCQWarm-up
The Einstein model of a solid assumes that- the crystal is an elastic continuum with sound waves up to a cutoff frequency
- the electrons carry most of the heat
- every atom vibrates independently as a quantum oscillator with the same frequency
- atoms obey classical equipartition at all temperatures
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Einstein (1907) treated the vibrational degrees of freedom as identical quantum oscillators of one frequency . This explained why falls below at low , the first success of quantum theory in solids. The continuum with a cutoff is Debye's later model.Why people get this wrong: Classical equipartition is exactly what Einstein replaced.
-
MCQWarm-up
The Debye temperature is defined by- , with the Debye cutoff frequency
- the melting point of the crystal
- the temperature at which
Answer and solution
Answer: A
converts the highest phonon frequency of the Debye model into a temperature. Well above all modes are excited (classical limit, ); well below it only a few are ().Why people get this wrong: is the Fermi temperature, about a hundred times larger in metals.
-
MCQWarm-up
Classical equipartition fails for lattice vibrations at low temperature because- the atoms stop moving entirely at low
- modes with are rarely excited, since the energy comes in quanta
- the crystal expands
- the number of modes grows as falls
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A quantum oscillator has mean thermal energy , which is when but exponentially small when . High-frequency modes "freeze out" and no longer store heat.Why people get this wrong: Atoms keep their zero-point motion even at ; it just does not change with , so it adds nothing to .
-
MCQWarm-up
At high temperature, the lattice heat capacity of NaCl per mole of formula units, in J mol K, is closest to ( J mol K)- 24.9
- 74.8
- 49.9
- 12.5
Answer and solution
Answer: C
One mole of NaCl contains ions, each contributing : J mol K.Why people get this wrong: Using per mole of formula units forgets that each formula unit has two atoms.
-
MCQWarm-up
At room temperature, which of these metals has the largest specific heat capacity per kilogram?- Lead
- Copper
- Aluminium
- Lithium
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Near the Dulong-Petit limit every mole of atoms needs about J/K, whatever the element. Per kilogram that is , largest for the lightest atoms: lithium ( g/mol) gives about kJ kg K, against for lead. (Lithium's Debye temperature, about K, keeps it a little below , but it still wins easily.)Why people get this wrong: The law fixes the heat capacity per mole of atoms, not per kilogram.
-
MCQStandard
In the Einstein model, the heat capacity at , as a fraction of the Dulong-Petit value , is- 0.500
- 0.921
- 0.632
- 1.000
Answer and solution
Answer: B
with : . Even at the solid is within 8% of the classical value.Why people get this wrong: Expecting one half at the characteristic temperature; that happens near .
-
NATStandard
A monatomic solid has K. Using the Debye law , its molar heat capacity at K is ______ J mol K (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.072 J/(mol K) (±0.001)
J mol K. . J mol K, about 0.3% of .Why people get this wrong: Using leaves out the large factor .
-
MCQStandard
At temperatures well below , the Einstein model predicts a heat capacity that- falls exponentially, as , faster than experiment
- falls as , in agreement with experiment
- stays at
- rises as falls
Answer and solution
Answer: A
For , . A single frequency means there are no low-energy modes, so heat capacity dies exponentially. Real crystals have acoustic phonons down to zero frequency, which give the slower fall.Why people get this wrong: The law needs a spectrum reaching down to , which Einstein's model lacks.
-
MCQStandard
In the Debye model the cutoff frequency is chosen so that- at room temperature
- the total number of vibrational modes equals for atoms
- the phonon wavelength equals the crystal size
- equals the Einstein frequency
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Debye uses the continuum density of states (three polarisations) and cuts it off where the count reaches : , giving . This keeps the right high-temperature limit .Why people get this wrong: The cutoff is a property of the crystal, not of the temperature.
-
MCQStandard
Well below its Debye temperature, an insulating crystal is warmed from 10 K to 20 K. By what factor is its lattice heat capacity multiplied?- 2
- 4
- 16
- 8
Answer and solution
Answer: D
, so doubling multiplies by .Why people get this wrong: Using the of the energy gives 16.
-
MSQStandard
Which statements about the Debye model are correct?- At high temperature it gives .
- At low temperature it gives .
- It uses a phonon density of states up to a cutoff.
- Soft solids of heavy atoms have high Debye temperatures.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
With up to and modes, the high- limit is equipartition and the low- limit is . : soft, heavy solids (Pb, 105 K) have low ; stiff, light ones (diamond, 2230 K) have high .Why people get this wrong: Heavy and soft means slow sound, hence low and low .
-
NATStandard
A solid has Einstein temperature K. Its Einstein frequency is ______ THz (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 5 THz (±0.01)
, so Hz THz. (Rule of thumb: 1 THz 48 K.)Why people get this wrong: Using instead of gives the angular frequency , times larger.
-
MCQStandard
For a metal at a few kelvin, . A graph that gives and directly as a straight line is- against
- against
- against
- against
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Divide by : . Against this is a line with intercept (electrons) and slope (phonons, from which follows).Why people get this wrong: A log-log plot is curved here because two powers compete.
-
NATStandard
Diamond has K. Using the Debye law, its molar heat capacity at K is ______ J mol K (to four decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.0219 J/(mol K) (±0.0003)
. J mol K. Diamond is "cold" even at room temperature: its heat capacity there is only about a quarter of , the anomaly Einstein first explained.Why people get this wrong: Applying the law at room temperature for diamond: it holds only for .
-
MCQStandard
Which of these solids has the highest Debye temperature?- lead
- sodium
- copper
- diamond
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Approximate values: Pb 105 K, Na 158 K, Cu 343 K, diamond 2230 K. Light atoms held by stiff covalent bonds give fast sound and a high cutoff frequency.Why people get this wrong: Hardness and melting point are related but not the same; what matters is .
-
MSQStandard
Which statements about the heat capacity of solids as are correct?- It must vanish, as the third law of thermodynamics requires.
- It vanishes because oscillator energies are quantised.
- Classical equipartition predicts the same behaviour at low temperature.
- In metals the electronic part falls more slowly (linearly) than the lattice part.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
The entropy must stay finite as , so . Quantisation makes the excitation of each mode exponentially rare when . Classical physics predicts at all temperatures (statement 3 false). Electrons give , which beats at the lowest temperatures.Why people get this wrong: Dulong-Petit is a classical result and has no temperature dependence at all.
-
NATStandard
In the Einstein model, the molar heat capacity of a monatomic solid at is ______ J mol K (to two decimal places). Use J mol K.Answer and solution
Answer: 24.43 J/(mol K) (±0.03)
: . J mol K. (The high- expansion agrees.)Why people get this wrong: Using instead of .
-
MSQStandard
Which statements comparing the Einstein and Debye models are correct?- Both give per mole of atoms at high temperature.
- Both use quantised oscillators with Bose-Einstein occupation.
- Both predict the same low-temperature behaviour.
- Debye includes a spread of frequencies reaching down to zero; Einstein uses one frequency.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
Each model treats quantum oscillators with mean energy , so both reach equipartition at high . They differ in the spectrum: Einstein one frequency (exponential freeze-out), Debye a continuum from zero up to ( law). So their low- behaviour is very different.Why people get this wrong: Agreement at high says nothing about low , where the spectrum near decides everything.
-
MSQStandard
Low-temperature heat capacity data of a metal are plotted as against and fall on a straight line. Which statements are correct?- The intercept on the axis is the electronic coefficient .
- The slope gives , from which follows.
- A larger density of states at the Fermi level gives a larger intercept.
- The slope is proportional to .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
. The intercept is , so it grows with the density of states at (heavy-fermion metals have huge ). The slope is , inversely proportional to : stiff solids have small slopes.Why people get this wrong: The slope goes as , not .
-
NATStandard
Using the Dulong-Petit law, the specific heat capacity of copper ( g/mol) at high temperature is ______ J kg K ( J mol K).Answer and solution
Answer: 392.5 (±4)
Molar heat capacity J mol K. One kilogram is mol, so J kg K. The measured value at room temperature, , is slightly lower because K is not far above copper's Debye temperature ( K).Why people get this wrong: Dividing by instead of (grams instead of kilograms) gives .
-
NATStandard
A kg aluminium block ( J kg K) at C is dropped into kg of water ( J kg K) at C in an insulated container of negligible heat capacity. The final temperature is ______ C (one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 26.3 (±0.1)
Heat lost by the block equals heat gained by the water: , i.e. . So C. The water's heat capacity is over eleven times the block's, so the result sits close to C.Why people get this wrong: Averaging the two temperatures by mass ignores the very different specific heats.
-
NATExam level
A monatomic solid has atoms per m and an average sound speed of m/s. Its Debye temperature is ______ K (to the nearest kelvin).Answer and solution
Answer: 408 K (±2)
m. rad/s. K.Why people get this wrong: Using , the free-electron formula with spin, gives too small a value.
-
NATExam level
Low-temperature data for a monatomic metal give with mJ mol K. Using , the Debye temperature is ______ K (to the nearest kelvin).Answer and solution
Answer: 342 K (±1)
K, so K (copper).Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that was given in mJ: keep the units the same as J mol K.
-
NATExam level
For copper, mJ mol K and mJ mol K. The temperature at which the electronic and lattice heat capacities are equal is ______ K (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 3.79 K (±0.02)
K. Below this the electrons dominate; above it the phonons.Why people get this wrong: Setting (dropping a ) gives K.
-
MCQExam level
A crystal in which atoms vibrate only within a two-dimensional sheet (in-plane acoustic modes with linear dispersion) has, at low temperature, a lattice heat capacity proportional toAnswer and solution
Answer: C
In dimensions with , the number of modes below goes as , so . Then and : in 2D. (Out-of-plane flexural modes of real graphene have and behave differently.)Why people get this wrong: Applying the 3D law without thinking about the dimension.
-
NATExam level
One mole of a monatomic solid with K is heated from K to K. Using the law, the heat required is ______ J (to four decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.0778 J (±0.0005)
with J mol K. J.Why people get this wrong: Multiplying at one temperature by : changes 27-fold over this range.
-
NATExam level
In the Debye model, the zero-point vibrational energy of one mole of a monatomic solid is . For K this is ______ J/mol (to the nearest whole number).Answer and solution
Answer: 2806 J/mol (±3)
with : . Per mole: J/mol. It does not depend on , so it adds nothing to , but it does reduce the cohesive energy.Why people get this wrong: Using (as if every mode had the maximum frequency).
-
MCQExam level
Two models of the same solid are fitted to agree at high temperature, with . At ,- the Debye model gives a much larger heat capacity than the Einstein model
- the Einstein model gives a much larger heat capacity
- both give
- both give exactly zero
Answer and solution
Answer: A
At : Debye . Einstein: , . The Debye value is about ten thousand times larger, because low-frequency acoustic modes are still active.Why people get this wrong: Assuming similar characteristic temperatures mean similar low- behaviour.