All lessons

Module 5: Building the story · Lesson 5.1 · about 12 min

Story structure: situation, complication, resolution

Every good data story has a shape. The situation, complication, resolution pattern (SCR) for presentations and reports, with a worked Northbay story and practice.

Module 5 · about 12 minutes · read first: 1.3. You’ll be able to shape any analysis into a short story with a beginning, a tension and an answer.

1. Why this matters

A list of findings is hard to remember; a story is easy. Stories have a shape our brains expect: things were like this, then something happened, so here’s what we do. Using that shape for data makes your presentations easier to follow, and much more likely to lead to action.

2. The idea in one picture

Situation, complication, resolution

The shape of a data story

  1. SituationWhat the audience already knows and agrees with."2025 sales are up 29 % on 2024."
  2. ComplicationThe tension: what changed, what's at risk, what's surprising."But most of that is the new store. Like-for-like growth is 14 %, and February fell below last year."
  3. ResolutionWhat you recommend, and what you need from them."Report like-for-like monthly, and look into February before we set the 2026 targets."
Barbara Minto's SCR pattern. Lead with the resolution when your audience is senior and short of time (Lesson 5.3).

3. The SCR pattern

  1. Situation: the context the audience already knows and agrees with. One or two sentences. “2025 sales are up 29 %.”
  2. Complication: what changed, what’s surprising, what’s at risk. This is why they should listen. “But most of that is the new store; the older stores grew 14 %, and February fell below last year.”
  3. Resolution: what you recommend, and what you need from them. “Report like-for-like growth monthly and review February before setting 2026 targets.”

Each part gets one or two charts at most. The complication usually needs the strongest chart.

Order: for a curious or junior audience, S → C → R builds understanding. For a senior, busy audience, R first: state the recommendation, then the situation and complication as the reasons (Barbara Minto’s pyramid principle).

Principle

Principle: tension holds attention. A story with no complication is a status report; nobody needs to act. Find what changed, what’s off-plan or what’s surprising, and build around it.

Analogy: every film has the same skeleton: normal life, then a problem, then how it’s solved. Your audience follows a data story the same way.

4. Worked example

The Northbay 2025 review, in three slides:

  1. Situation: “2025 sales reached $262k, 29 % more than 2024 and 6.6 % over target.” Chart: monthly sales 2025 vs 2024.
  2. Complication: “Forks Market accounts for over half of that growth. Like-for-like, the four older stores grew 14 %, and February was below last year.” Chart: headline vs like-for-like bars, February highlighted on the trend.
  3. Resolution: “Report like-for-like monthly from January; investigate February’s dip before setting 2026 targets. Decision needed: approve the new monthly report.” Chart: a mock-up of the new KPI card.

5. Practice

  1. Write a situation and complication for: weekends bring over a third of sales, but staffing is the same every day.
  2. What’s missing from: “Sales grew 29 %. Margins were steady. Forks Market opened in March.”?
  3. Your manager says “skip to the point”. Rearrange the Northbay story.
Answers
  1. Situation: “We staff every store evenly across the week.” Complication: “But Saturdays and Sundays bring over a third of sales in two days, so weekend queues are likely costing sales.”
  2. A complication and a resolution: it’s a list of facts with no tension or ask.
  3. “I recommend we report like-for-like growth monthly. Here’s why: headline growth of 29 % is mostly the new store; the older stores grew 14 %, and February was below last year.”

Next, Lesson 5.2: turning a dashboard into slides.

Check yourself

1In the SCR pattern, what is the complication?
2When should you lead with the resolution (your recommendation)?
3What should the situation contain?

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Northbay Goods is a made-up shop and its numbers are generated. The writing checks are simple rules run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere or kept.