Module 10: Nuclear and particle physics · Lesson 10.3 · about 45 min
The collective model and nuclear deformation
When nucleons move together: the evidence for deformed nuclei, the deformation parameter β and the intrinsic quadrupole moment, the spectroscopic quadrupole moment Q = Q₀[3K² − I(I+1)]/[(I+1)(2I+3)], rotational bands E = (ħ²/2𝓘)I(I+1) with gamma-ray ladders and K bands in odd-A nuclei, the moment of inertia between rigid and irrotational values, quadrupole vibrations and phonon multiplets, and the ratio E(4⁺)/E(2⁺) that tells a rotor from a vibrator.
Module 10 · about 45 minutes. The shell model treats each nucleon as moving alone in an average potential. It works superbly near magic numbers, and fails between them: rare-earth and actinide nuclei have quadrupole moments 20 times larger than one proton could give, and their low levels form ladders with energies that go like . The collective model of Bohr and Mottelson explains both. The nucleus as a whole takes a deformed shape, and that shape can rotate and vibrate.
1. Describing the shape
Write the nuclear surface as a multipole expansion and keep the quadrupole term for an axially symmetric shape:
- `$\beta > 0$`
- prolate (cigar), the usual case in rare earths and actinides, `$\beta \approx 0.2$` to `$0.35$`
- `$\beta < 0$`
- oblate (disc)
- `$Q_0$`
- intrinsic quadrupole moment, measured in the body frame: `$Q_0 = \int\rho(3z'^2 - r^2)\,d\tau/e$`
- `$\gamma$`
- a second parameter for non-axial (triaxial) shapes; `$\gamma = 0$` is axial
Worked example. Take , , . fm, fm². fm² = 7.2 b. One proton in an orbit of radius gives at most about b, so 7 b is a clear sign of many nucleons moving together.
What the lab measures
The lab sees the intrinsic shape averaged over the rotation. For a state of spin in a band with projection on the symmetry axis:
I = 0 or ½. Q = 0 always: no direction in space to measure. Every even-even ground state has Q = 0, deformed or not.
First 2⁺ in a K = 0 band. Q = Q₀(0 − 6)/(3 × 7) = −(2/7)Q₀: negative for a prolate nucleus, because the rotation axis is perpendicular to the long axis.
Odd-A band head, I = K. Q = Q₀ I(2I − 1)/[(I + 1)(2I + 3)], always smaller than Q₀ and approaching it only for large I.
B(E2). The reduced transition rate 2⁺ → 0⁺ is B(E2) = (5/16π)e²Q₀², often 100 to 300 single-particle (Weisskopf) units in deformed nuclei: the cleanest measure of collectivity.
Worked example. An odd-A nucleus with b and ground state : b.
2. Rotational bands
A rigid symmetric top with moment of inertia about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis has plus intrinsic energy (see rotational spectra for the same physics in molecules). A quantum system cannot rotate about its own symmetry axis collectively, so comes from the intrinsic (single-particle) motion.
- Ratios in a K = 0 band
- `$E_4/E_2 = 20/6 = 3.33$`, `$E_6/E_2 = 7$`, `$E_8/E_2 = 12$`
- E2 gamma rays
- `$I \to I - 2$` has `$E_\gamma = (\hbar^2/2\mathcal I)(4I - 2)$`: 6, 14, 22, 30, ... units, rising in equal steps of `$8\hbar^2/2\mathcal I$`
- Only even I for K = 0
- the intrinsic state is symmetric under a 180° turn about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis, which removes the odd spins
- K = ½ bands
- Coriolis coupling adds a decoupling term `$a(-1)^{I+1/2}(I + \tfrac12)$`, which staggers the levels
Worked example. A deformed nucleus has its 2⁺ at 80 keV. Then keV and the band should run 4⁺ 267, 6⁺ 560, 8⁺ 960 keV, with gamma rays of 80, 187, 293, 400 keV. In ¹⁶⁶Er the measured levels are 81, 265, 545 and 911 keV: close, and slightly low at high spin. That is centrifugal stretching: the faster rotation deforms the nucleus a little more, raising . A two-term fit with captures it.
How big is 𝓘?
Two classical limits bracket the measured value.
For , fm: keV (6.4 keV with the factor), while the irrotational value with is about 13 times smaller in (so about 85 keV). The measured 13 keV sits in between: about half the rigid value. Pairing makes the nucleus partly superfluid, so not all nucleons follow the rotation. At high spin, pairs break (the Coriolis force aligns a pair of high- nucleons) and jumps up: backbending.
3. Vibrations of a spherical nucleus
Near closed shells the nucleus stays spherical on average but its surface can oscillate. The lowest mode is quadrupole (, the mode would move the centre of mass). Each quantum, a phonon, carries :
One phonon. A 2⁺ state at ħω (typically 0.5 to 1.5 MeV).
Two phonons. Two identical bosons of spin 2 couple only to symmetric states: total I = 0, 2, 4 (not 1 or 3), all at 2ħω.
Three phonons. I = 0, 2, 3, 4, 6 at 3ħω.
Ratio. E(4⁺)/E(2⁺) = 2. Real vibrational nuclei (Cd, Te isotopes) show a triplet near 2ħω, split by anharmonic terms. Octupole (3⁻) phonons appear higher, near 2 to 3 MeV.
Telling them apart in an exam. Look at, in order: the energy of the first 2⁺ (low, below 100 keV, means deformed); (3.33 rotor, 2.0 vibrator, around 2.5 in between, -soft); the existence of a 0⁺, 2⁺, 4⁺ triplet near ; large B(E2) values. Nuclei between the limits are described by the interacting boson model, which interpolates with symmetry labels.
4. Deformed single-particle levels
In a deformed well the -fold degeneracy of each shell-model level splits by , the projection of on the symmetry axis, each pair twofold (the Nilsson model). For prolate shapes, low orbits (which lie along the long axis) go down in energy. The odd nucleon’s becomes the band’s , and its parity the band’s parity. This explains the ground-state spins of odd-A deformed nuclei, which the spherical shell model often gets wrong.
“A nucleus with Q = 0 in its ground state must be spherical.” Every even-even ground state is and has in the lab, even ¹⁶⁶Er with b. Deformation shows up in the low 2⁺ energy, the band, the large B(E2), and the measured . The same averaging is why odd-A nuclei with never show a quadrupole moment.
- Shape: ; ; prolate .
- Lab moment : zero for ; for the 2⁺ of a K = 0 band.
- K = 0 band: , even I, ; gamma rays ; odd-A: with .
- ; pairing; centrifugal stretching; backbending.
- Vibrator: 2⁺ phonons; two-phonon 0⁺, 2⁺, 4⁺ at ; three-phonon 0, 2, 3, 4, 6; .
- B(E2) measures collectivity; Nilsson levels labelled by give K.
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Next: lesson 10.4 goes inside the nucleon: isospin, strangeness and the quark model. For coupling angular momenta in these bands, see LS and jj coupling; for the nuclear radius and binding used here, see the JAM lesson on nuclei and radioactivity.
Check yourself
Sources
- A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure, vol. II (1975), chapters 4 and 6
- K. S. Krane, Introductory Nuclear Physics (1988), chapter 5
- K. Heyde, Basic Ideas and Concepts in Nuclear Physics, 3rd ed. (2004), chapters 12 and 13
- CSIR-UGC NET Physical Sciences syllabus, Part C nuclear and particle physics, published by the National Testing Agency
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with CSIR, UGC or the National Testing Agency. Check the official CSIR NET website for the current pattern. All questions are original.