Home / Money / Insurance / Car and bike / Claim or pay for the repair yourself?Tool #T831 (formerly #1957)

Claim or pay for the repair yourself? No-claim discount calculator

Work out whether a small car repair is worth claiming, by comparing what the claim pays with the extra premiums from losing your no-claim discount.

Keep it one tap away for everyday use.

Bookmark Claim or pay for the repair yourself??

Press Ctrl + D now. Your browser opens its own bookmark box, where you choose the name and folder.

  1. Policy
  2. Discount
  3. Extra cost
  4. Verdict
Nothing is uploadedWorks offline once open

Educational, not financial or insurance advice. fibub doesn't sell insurance, name insurers or pass on your details: it only works out the numbers you type. Check your policy wording and the official source before you decide.

Your policy

Example numbers: change them to yours.

India: 0, 20, 25, 35, 45, 50% after 0 to 5 claim-free years; a claim sends you back to 0. Source: India Motor Tariff GR.27, checked 2026-11-10, check the official source.

The claim pays you
Extra premiums if you claim
Their value today
Claiming leaves you

Year by year

YearIf you claimIf you pay yourselfExtra

How it is worked out: each future year has a chance of a claim; the model follows how likely you are to be at each discount level and adds up the premium. "Claim" starts from the level after a claim, "pay yourself" from the level after a claim-free year. Extra premiums are discounted at your rate to give today's value. It looks at the own-damage premium only and ignores price changes and any other reason you may need to claim. Nothing you type leaves this page.

What it does

After a minor accident you can claim, or pay the repair yourself and keep your no-claim discount. A claim pays you the repair minus your deductible, but your discount drops, so you pay more at the next renewals. This tool adds up those extra premiums and sets them against what the claim pays.

It follows the chance of future claims too, so a discount you may lose again is counted. Before choosing a deductible, see car insurance deductible chooser; to see what your car is insured for, use IDV and NCB calculator (India).

How to use it

  1. Choose India, or “My insurer’s table” and type your insurer’s discount levels and the levels lost per claim.
  2. Enter the premium before any discount, your level now, the repair cost and your deductible. The numbers shown are examples: change them to yours.
  3. Set the chance of a claim in later years, how many years to look ahead and a discount rate.

What each setting does

  • Premium before any discount: the full price, so each level can take its percentage off.
  • Chance of another claim: yearly chance, 0 if you do not expect one.
  • Discount rate: money later is worth less than money now. 0 treats them the same.
  • Levels lost: how far a claim sends you down the table.

Worked example

Premium 10,000 before discount, India table, level 5 (50%), no future claims, 3 years. If you claim you pay 10,000, 8,000 and 7,500; if you do not, you pay 5,000 each year. Extra premiums are 10,500. A repair of 8,000 with a deductible of 1,000 pays you 7,000, so paying yourself costs less.

FAQs

Does a claim always reset the discount? In the India table yes. Some insurers elsewhere drop you only a few levels, or offer discount protection.

Does it count premium rises from your claims history? No, only the discount table you give it.

Are my numbers stored? No, nothing leaves this page.

How it’s worked out: for each year, premium = base × (1 − discount at your level), averaged over the levels you may be at; extra = premium after a claim − premium without; present value = sum of extra ÷ (1 + rate)^year.

Where the numbers come from

  • India: no-claim bonus ladder 0, 20, 25, 35, 45, 50% after 0 to 5 claim-free years, a claim resets it to 0 (India Motor Tariff GR.27, still used by insurers after detariffing). Checked 2026-11-10, check the official source.
  • Canada, the US and the UK: insurers publish their own discount tables, so use 'My insurer's table' and copy yours.

Standard scientific values, such as constants, atomic weights and melting points, are facts found in every textbook; we name where ours were checked. If you are an author or publisher and want a value, a credit or a table changed or removed, tell us and we will act quickly.

Last updated 2026-11-10.

Change log for Claim or pay for the repair yourself?

  1. Insurance tools take the next free codes, #T824 to #T835 Details on GitHub
  2. Insurance tools: cross-links between the 12 tools and their share images Details on GitHub
  3. Add claim-or-pay tool Details on GitHub

Every change to fibub

Related tools