Structure and function
Reading Comprehension · 22 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Structure and function questions.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQExam level
Courts in common-law countries decide new cases partly by reasoning from old ones. A judge facing an unfamiliar dispute asks which earlier decisions it most resembles, and applies the principle those decisions established. This method, called reasoning by precedent, gives the law stability: people can predict how courts will rule by looking at how they have ruled before.
New technologies strain the method because they rarely resemble anything exactly. When telephones spread in the early twentieth century, courts had to decide whether listening in on a call was like opening a letter, which required a warrant, or like overhearing a conversation in a public street, which did not. Different courts chose different analogies, and for decades the answer depended on where one lived.
Some legal scholars conclude that precedent is simply the wrong tool for technological change and that legislatures, which can write rules from scratch, should take the lead. But this conclusion overlooks what the telephone cases eventually achieved. The competing analogies forced judges to say what, exactly, made a letter private: not the envelope itself, but the sender's reasonable expectation that no one else would read it. Once that principle was stated, it applied to telephones, and later to email, without any need for new analogies. Precedent, in other words, is slow to adapt, but the very struggle to find the right comparison can uncover principles general enough to outlast the technology that prompted them.
The second paragraph functions primarily to
- reject the view stated in the first paragraph
- give an example of the difficulty that new technology creates for reasoning by precedent
- present the author's main conclusion
- argue that legislatures should regulate telephones
- explain why precedent gives the law stability
Answer and solution
Answer: B
"New technologies strain the method" is the claim, and the telephone story illustrates it. The author's conclusion comes in paragraph 3.
-
MCQExam level
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
The first paragraph functions primarily to
- describe the results of studies of pension plans
- explain why defaults are unavoidable
- argue that employees should be required to opt in
- state a theoretical prediction that the rest of the passage shows to be mistaken in an important case
- present the author’s main conclusion
Answer and solution
Answer: D
P1 sets out standard theory’s prediction that defaults "should be a mere formality"; P2 says the evidence "contradicts this prediction sharply". D.
-
MCQExam level
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
The sentence "Only the default had." serves mainly to
- suggest that employers changed the plans’ benefits
- introduce an objection to automatic enrolment
- show that participation fell after the change
- summarise the explanations given in the third paragraph
- emphasise that the rise in participation cannot be explained by changes in the plans’ costs or benefits
Answer and solution
Answer: E
It follows "Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed", isolating the default as the cause. E.
-
MCQExam level
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
The third paragraph functions primarily to
- describe the chemistry of red ochre
- present the surprising results of the method
- argue that stylistic dating should be preferred
- introduce the radiocarbon method
- explain the limits of the dating method and how researchers try to reduce one source of error
Answer and solution
Answer: E
P3: the method dates the crust, not the paint (a minimum age), and uranium can wash out, which multi-layer sampling checks. E. Results come in P4.
-
MCQExam level
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
According to the passage, mineral pigments such as red ochre cannot be dated by radiocarbon because they
- contain no carbon
- are covered by crusts
- contain uranium
- were applied too recently
- wash away in water
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Paragraph 1: they "contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method". A.
-
MCQExam level
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
The first paragraph functions primarily to
- present a hypothetical case that shows a problem the class action is meant to solve
- describe a real lawsuit against a company
- state the critics’ main objection
- argue that small-claims courts should be abolished
- give the author’s final recommendation
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The overcharging example shows a wrong that individual suits cannot fix; P2 says the class action "was designed for exactly this situation". A.
-
MCQExam level
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Companies always settle weak claims.
- Class actions should be judged mainly by how well they deter wrongdoing, and reforms should strengthen rather than weaken that effect.
- Class actions mainly enrich lawyers and should be restricted.
- Every class member should receive full compensation.
- Small-claims courts are the best remedy for small losses.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The author says critics use "the wrong measure"; the purpose is "to make the wrong unprofitable", and reforms should "improve deterrence". B. C is the critics’ view.
-
MCQHard
Courts in common-law countries decide new cases partly by reasoning from old ones. A judge facing an unfamiliar dispute asks which earlier decisions it most resembles, and applies the principle those decisions established. This method, called reasoning by precedent, gives the law stability: people can predict how courts will rule by looking at how they have ruled before.
New technologies strain the method because they rarely resemble anything exactly. When telephones spread in the early twentieth century, courts had to decide whether listening in on a call was like opening a letter, which required a warrant, or like overhearing a conversation in a public street, which did not. Different courts chose different analogies, and for decades the answer depended on where one lived.
Some legal scholars conclude that precedent is simply the wrong tool for technological change and that legislatures, which can write rules from scratch, should take the lead. But this conclusion overlooks what the telephone cases eventually achieved. The competing analogies forced judges to say what, exactly, made a letter private: not the envelope itself, but the sender's reasonable expectation that no one else would read it. Once that principle was stated, it applied to telephones, and later to email, without any need for new analogies. Precedent, in other words, is slow to adapt, but the very struggle to find the right comparison can uncover principles general enough to outlast the technology that prompted them.
The author mentions email in the third paragraph most likely in order to
- suggest that courts still disagree about email
- show that analogies to letters are always wrong
- show that a principle drawn from the telephone cases applied to later technology as well
- argue that email is less private than letters
- give an example of a technology that legislatures regulated
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The principle ("reasonable expectation that no one else would read it") "applied to telephones, and later to email, without any need for new analogies". Email shows the principle outlasting the technology that produced it.
-
MCQHard
Courts in common-law countries decide new cases partly by reasoning from old ones. A judge facing an unfamiliar dispute asks which earlier decisions it most resembles, and applies the principle those decisions established. This method, called reasoning by precedent, gives the law stability: people can predict how courts will rule by looking at how they have ruled before.
New technologies strain the method because they rarely resemble anything exactly. When telephones spread in the early twentieth century, courts had to decide whether listening in on a call was like opening a letter, which required a warrant, or like overhearing a conversation in a public street, which did not. Different courts chose different analogies, and for decades the answer depended on where one lived.
Some legal scholars conclude that precedent is simply the wrong tool for technological change and that legislatures, which can write rules from scratch, should take the lead. But this conclusion overlooks what the telephone cases eventually achieved. The competing analogies forced judges to say what, exactly, made a letter private: not the envelope itself, but the sender's reasonable expectation that no one else would read it. Once that principle was stated, it applied to telephones, and later to email, without any need for new analogies. Precedent, in other words, is slow to adapt, but the very struggle to find the right comparison can uncover principles general enough to outlast the technology that prompted them.
Which one of the following best describes the structure of the third paragraph?
- It compares two technologies and concludes that they are alike.
- It summarises the first two paragraphs without adding anything new.
- It presents two opposing views and declines to choose between them.
- It reports a conclusion some scholars draw, then argues that the conclusion overlooks a benefit of the method they criticise.
- It states a principle and then lists exceptions to it.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
"Some legal scholars conclude..." then "But this conclusion overlooks..." and the telephone cases' hidden benefit. The author does choose a side.
-
MCQHard
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
Which one of the following best describes the organisation of the passage?
- A prediction is stated, evidence against it is given, explanations are offered, a drawback is noted, and a recommendation follows.
- Two policies are compared and the first is found superior.
- A problem is described and several solutions are rejected.
- A theory is defended against a series of objections.
- A historical narrative is followed by a prediction about future policy.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
P1 prediction; P2 evidence; P3 explanations; P4 the "less comfortable side"; P5 recommendation. A.
-
MCQHard
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
Which one of the following is NOT offered in the passage as an explanation of the effect of defaults?
- Staying with the status quo feels safer.
- Employees distrust their employers’ recommendations.
- Choosing a savings plan takes effort and can be confusing.
- People postpone tasks whose rewards are far in the future.
- A default carries an implied recommendation.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Paragraph 3 gives the other four. B is the opposite of the implied-recommendation explanation, which assumes employees trust the employer’s choice.
Why people get this wrong: Not noticing the EXCEPT/NOT wording.
-
MCQHard
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
If a crust over a painting is dated to 40,000 years ago, which one of the following can be concluded from the passage?
- The painting’s style must be very old.
- The painting is at least about 40,000 years old, assuming the crust has not been disturbed.
- The painting is exactly 40,000 years old.
- The painting is less than 40,000 years old.
- The painting was made with charcoal.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A crust "can form only on top of a painting that already exists", so its age is a minimum. B. The painting "could be much older", so C and D fail.
-
MCQHard
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
The author mentions that ages should increase steadily from outer to inner layers in order to
- argue that the method gives the exact age of paint
- show that stylistic dating is unreliable
- describe a check researchers use to detect crusts disturbed by water
- show that the outer layers are older than the inner ones
- explain why red ochre contains no carbon
Answer and solution
Answer: C
"A sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed." C. D reverses the order.
-
MCQHard
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
The phrase "four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life" serves primarily to
- argue that lawyers’ fees are too high
- suggest that the company should not have to return the money
- support the claim that compensating individuals is not the class action’s main purpose
- show that the overcharge did no harm
- criticise customers for not filing claim forms
Answer and solution
Answer: C
It follows "Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole". The tiny individual stake shows compensation was never the point. C. The author still calls it "a real ... loss", so D is wrong.
-
MCQHard
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
Which one of the following is mentioned in the passage as a criticism of class actions?
- Judges lack the power to review settlements.
- Plaintiffs must pay lawyers in advance.
- Class actions cannot be brought for small losses.
- The threat of a large judgement can pressure companies to settle weak claims.
- Class actions take too long to reach trial.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Paragraph 3 lists D. A contradicts paragraph 4 ("courts have responded by scrutinising settlements").
-
MCQTop rank
Courts in common-law countries decide new cases partly by reasoning from old ones. A judge facing an unfamiliar dispute asks which earlier decisions it most resembles, and applies the principle those decisions established. This method, called reasoning by precedent, gives the law stability: people can predict how courts will rule by looking at how they have ruled before.
New technologies strain the method because they rarely resemble anything exactly. When telephones spread in the early twentieth century, courts had to decide whether listening in on a call was like opening a letter, which required a warrant, or like overhearing a conversation in a public street, which did not. Different courts chose different analogies, and for decades the answer depended on where one lived.
Some legal scholars conclude that precedent is simply the wrong tool for technological change and that legislatures, which can write rules from scratch, should take the lead. But this conclusion overlooks what the telephone cases eventually achieved. The competing analogies forced judges to say what, exactly, made a letter private: not the envelope itself, but the sender's reasonable expectation that no one else would read it. Once that principle was stated, it applied to telephones, and later to email, without any need for new analogies. Precedent, in other words, is slow to adapt, but the very struggle to find the right comparison can uncover principles general enough to outlast the technology that prompted them.
Which one of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?
- Courts should stop reasoning by precedent when deciding cases about new technology.
- Telephone calls deserve the same privacy as letters.
- Legislatures are better than courts at protecting privacy.
- Precedent makes the law stable and predictable.
- Although reasoning by precedent adapts slowly to new technology, the search for apt comparisons can produce principles general enough to cover later technologies.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
The final sentence sums up the passage: slow, but able to uncover lasting principles. The last option is true according to paragraph 1 but is background, not the main point.
-
MCQTop rank
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
The author mentions early programmes with a low default rate primarily in order to
- explain why standard economic theory is correct
- suggest that employees prefer low contribution rates
- illustrate how inertia can hold people at a default that is worse than what they would have chosen
- show that automatic enrolment does not raise participation
- argue that defaults should be abolished
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The example shows many workers "who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years", the "less comfortable side". C. E is denied in the last paragraph.
-
MCQTop rank
Standard economic theory assumes that people choose the option that best serves their interests, given what they know. On this assumption, the way a choice is presented should matter little: whether a retirement savings plan requires employees to sign up or enrols them automatically unless they decline, an employee who wants to save will save and one who does not will not. The default, the outcome that occurs if a person does nothing, should be a mere formality.
Evidence from workplace pension plans contradicts this prediction sharply. When some employers switched from requiring workers to opt in to enrolling them automatically, with the freedom to opt out at any time, participation among new employees rose dramatically, in some studies from well under half to more than four in five. Nothing about the plans’ costs or benefits had changed. Only the default had.
Several explanations have been offered. Choosing a savings rate and investment mix takes effort and can be confusing, and people tend to postpone tasks whose rewards lie far in the future. A default also carries an implied recommendation: employees may reason that the employer chose it because it suits most people. And for many people, simply staying with the status quo feels safer than making an active change.
The finding has been widely embraced by policymakers, and automatic enrolment has spread in several countries. But it has a less comfortable side. The same inertia that keeps employees enrolled also keeps them at whatever contribution rate and investment the default specifies. In some early programmes, the default rate was low, and many workers who would have chosen to save more on their own stayed at the low figure for years. A default, in other words, does not merely nudge people toward saving; it shapes how much they save and where the money goes. Designing one is therefore not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made.
This does not argue against defaults, which are unavoidable: every plan must specify what happens to those who do nothing. It argues for choosing them with the same care as any other policy, and for revisiting them as evidence accumulates.
The author would most likely agree with which one of the following?
- Most employees carefully review their default contribution rate.
- The choice of default rarely matters once employees are enrolled.
- Policymakers have been too slow to adopt automatic enrolment.
- The people who design a default bear responsibility for its effects on those who never actively choose.
- Automatic enrolment should be replaced by required opt-in.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Designing a default "is not a neutral administrative task but a decision with large consequences for people who may never notice it was made". D.
-
MCQTop rank
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
The author’s attitude toward the new findings in the last paragraph is best described as
- dismissive, because the method has limits
- indifferent to their significance
- convinced they show the exact age of the earliest paintings
- interested in their implications while cautious about how precisely they date the art
- certain that they prove cave art began in one region
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The findings "unsettled" an older view and "suggest" art is older and more widespread, "though ... how much older remains an open question". D.
-
MCQTop rank
Paintings on the walls of caves and rock shelters are among the oldest surviving works of human art, but determining their age has proved stubbornly difficult. Many were made with mineral pigments such as red ochre, which contain no carbon and so cannot be dated by the radiocarbon method that archaeologists use for bone, charcoal and wood. For a long time, the ages assigned to such paintings rested largely on style: images that resembled others of known age were assumed to be roughly contemporary with them.
Stylistic dating has obvious weaknesses. Styles can persist for long periods or be revived, and two images that look alike to modern eyes may have been made thousands of years apart. A more direct approach became possible when researchers began to exploit thin mineral crusts that form over some paintings as water seeps across the rock. These crusts, made largely of calcite, contain tiny amounts of uranium, which decays at a known rate into thorium. Because the crust starts with almost no thorium, the ratio of the two elements indicates how long ago the crust formed.
The method has an important limitation that its results must be read with: it dates the crust, not the paint. Since a crust can form only on top of a painting that already exists, its age gives a minimum age for the painting beneath it. The painting could be much older; the method cannot say by how much. A further complication is that water can wash uranium out of a crust after it forms, which would make the crust appear older than it is. Researchers try to guard against this by sampling several layers of a crust, expecting the ages to increase steadily from the outer layers to the inner ones; a sequence that does not do so suggests the crust has been disturbed.
Applied carefully, the method has produced surprising results. Some paintings once assumed, on stylistic grounds, to be relatively recent have proved to lie beneath crusts many tens of thousands of years old. These findings have unsettled the view that sophisticated cave art arose first in one region and spread outward. They suggest instead that the practice of painting on stone may be older and more widespread than was once believed, though, given the method’s limits, how much older remains an open question.
Which one of the following, if true, would most undermine a conclusion drawn from a crust’s uranium-thorium date?
- The painting beneath the crust resembles paintings found elsewhere.
- The painting was made with red ochre.
- The crust is made largely of calcite.
- The cave also contains charcoal that can be radiocarbon dated.
- Samples from that crust gave ages that were older in the outer layers than in the inner layers.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Ages should increase toward the inner layers; a reversed sequence "suggests the crust has been disturbed", so the date is unreliable. E.
-
MCQTop rank
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
The author would most likely favour which one of the following reforms?
- Requiring each class member to prove their own loss in a separate hearing
- Banning lawyers from being paid a share of the recovery
- Raising the minimum loss needed to join a class action
- Abolishing class actions for claims under one hundred dollars
- Requiring unclaimed settlement money to go to a consumer-protection fund rather than back to the company
Answer and solution
Answer: E
The author names "directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant". E. The others make class actions harder to bring, which the author opposes.
-
MCQTop rank
Suppose a company overcharges each of its two million customers by four dollars. Every customer has suffered a real, if tiny, loss, and the company has gained eight million dollars it was not entitled to. Yet no customer has any reason to sue. The cost of a lawyer, or even of a day spent in small-claims court, would exceed the four dollars many times over. Left to individual lawsuits, the wrong goes uncorrected, and the company keeps the money.
The class action was designed for exactly this situation. It allows one or a few plaintiffs to sue on behalf of everyone who suffered the same harm, so that thousands of small claims are combined into one large enough to be worth bringing. The lawyers who bring the case are typically paid a share of any recovery, which gives them a reason to take on cases that no individual client could afford.
Critics argue that this arrangement serves lawyers better than the people it claims to represent. In many settlements, individual class members receive a few dollars or a coupon, often after filling out a claim form that most never return, while the lawyers collect fees in the millions. Some critics add that the mere threat of a large class action pressures companies to settle even weak claims, since the cost of losing would be so great.
These criticisms identify real abuses, and courts have responded by scrutinising settlements and fees more closely. But they evaluate the class action by the wrong measure. Its main purpose is not to make each class member whole; four dollars per customer was never going to change anyone’s life. Its purpose is to make the wrong unprofitable. A company that knows it may be forced to return its eight million dollars has little reason to overcharge in the first place, and the customers of every company in the industry benefit from that deterrence, whether or not they ever file a claim form.
Seen this way, the low payments to individuals are not evidence that the class action has failed, and the reforms worth pursuing are those that improve deterrence, such as directing unclaimed money to purposes related to the harm rather than returning it to the defendant. Reforms that would simply make class actions harder to bring would leave the company in the opening example with its eight million dollars, and its customers with no remedy at all.
Which one of the following best describes the structure of the passage?
- A problem is illustrated, an institution designed to solve it is described, criticisms are reported, and the author answers them by redefining the institution’s purpose.
- An institution is described, criticised and finally rejected.
- Two remedies for a problem are compared and both found inadequate.
- A legal history is recounted in chronological order.
- A principle is stated and then applied to several unrelated cases.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
P1 problem; P2 class action; P3 critics; P4-5 author’s reply: judge by deterrence. A.