Comparative passages
Reading Comprehension · 22 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Comparative passages.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
Museums in former colonial powers hold thousands of objects taken from other countries during periods of conquest. Requests to return these objects are often met with the argument that the museums preserve them better and make them available to a global audience. That argument confuses custody with ownership. A borrowed book does not become the borrower's because it is kept on a clean shelf. Where an object was taken by force or under clear duress, the default should be return, and the burden should fall on the museum to show why it should keep what it never fairly acquired.
Passage B
Calls to return museum objects to their countries of origin rest on a simple picture: an object was taken from a people, and justice requires giving it back. Real cases are rarely so simple. Many objects changed hands several times, sometimes through sales that were legal at the time; the modern state that requests an object may not represent the community that made it; and some communities of origin have asked museums to keep objects they cannot yet house safely. None of this means that museums should keep everything. It means that each claim must be judged on its own history, by a process both sides trust, rather than settled by a general rule.
The authors of the two passages would be most likely to disagree about whether
- some objects should be returned to their countries of origin
- the history of an object matters at all
- there should be a general presumption in favour of returning objects taken by force
- some museum objects were taken during conquest
- museums sometimes preserve objects well
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Passage A wants a default of return, with the burden on museums. Passage B rejects any general rule in favour of case-by-case judgment. Both accept that some objects should go back ("None of this means that museums should keep everything").
Why people get this wrong: Choosing a point both authors accept.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
Both authors would most likely agree with which one of the following?
- Planting targets alone are an adequate heat policy.
- Reflective roofing works better than trees.
- Most newly planted street trees survive.
- Urban heat is not a public health concern.
- Mature trees can cool city streets.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
A cites studies of cooler tree-lined streets; B says a tree cools "when its canopy is large" and calls trees not "a poor investment". E. B rejects A.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
Which one of the following best describes the relationship between the two passages?
- Passage B accepts the value of trees that Passage A argues for but warns that planting programmes often fail to deliver it without long-term care.
- Passage B rejects tree planting as useless.
- Passage A answers objections that Passage B raises.
- The passages discuss entirely different problems.
- Passage B provides the evidence for Passage A’s statistics.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
B agrees trees are worthwhile but says planting without care "is closer to a gesture than a policy". A. Passage A does not respond to B, so C is wrong.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
The central question on which the two passages take different positions is whether
- a poem’s meaning is limited to what its author intended
- poems should be read at all
- readers ever disagree about poems
- a poet’s private letters are useful
- love poems are better than hymns
Answer and solution
Answer: A
A says the standard is "the author’s intention"; B says readings can go "beyond intention" and still be valid. A.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
Both authors would most likely agree that
- intentions cannot be inferred from a text
- some readings of a poem are better than others
- the author’s private letters settle disputes
- any reading of a poem is as good as any other
- poems cannot outlast their circumstances
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A wants a standard so one reading "can be better than another"; B says a reading that ignores the words "fails" and one that illuminates them "succeeds". B. Both reject D.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
Which one of the following best describes the relationship between the passages?
- The passages agree on every point.
- Passage A argues for ranked-choice voting, and Passage B grants some of its benefits while arguing that its guarantees are overstated.
- Passage B argues that ranked-choice voting should be banned.
- Both passages argue for plurality voting.
- Passage A criticises ranked-choice voting, and Passage B defends it.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
B: "it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees." B. B never calls for a ban.
-
MCQExam level
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
Both authors would most likely agree that plurality voting
- eliminates strategic voting
- is used only rarely
- has flaws when three or more candidates run
- is the fairest system available
- always produces a majority winner
Answer and solution
Answer: C
A describes its flaws; B calls ranked-choice "a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections" that "does reduce some of them". C.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
Museums in former colonial powers hold thousands of objects taken from other countries during periods of conquest. Requests to return these objects are often met with the argument that the museums preserve them better and make them available to a global audience. That argument confuses custody with ownership. A borrowed book does not become the borrower's because it is kept on a clean shelf. Where an object was taken by force or under clear duress, the default should be return, and the burden should fall on the museum to show why it should keep what it never fairly acquired.
Passage B
Calls to return museum objects to their countries of origin rest on a simple picture: an object was taken from a people, and justice requires giving it back. Real cases are rarely so simple. Many objects changed hands several times, sometimes through sales that were legal at the time; the modern state that requests an object may not represent the community that made it; and some communities of origin have asked museums to keep objects they cannot yet house safely. None of this means that museums should keep everything. It means that each claim must be judged on its own history, by a process both sides trust, rather than settled by a general rule.
Both passages express which one of the following views?
- Good preservation gives a museum the right to keep an object.
- Modern states always represent the communities that made the objects.
- Sales of objects were always illegal.
- Museums should not simply keep every object whose return is requested.
- Every object taken during colonial periods should be returned at once.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Passage A puts the burden on museums to justify keeping objects; Passage B says "None of this means that museums should keep everything". So both reject keeping everything by default.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
Museums in former colonial powers hold thousands of objects taken from other countries during periods of conquest. Requests to return these objects are often met with the argument that the museums preserve them better and make them available to a global audience. That argument confuses custody with ownership. A borrowed book does not become the borrower's because it is kept on a clean shelf. Where an object was taken by force or under clear duress, the default should be return, and the burden should fall on the museum to show why it should keep what it never fairly acquired.
Passage B
Calls to return museum objects to their countries of origin rest on a simple picture: an object was taken from a people, and justice requires giving it back. Real cases are rarely so simple. Many objects changed hands several times, sometimes through sales that were legal at the time; the modern state that requests an object may not represent the community that made it; and some communities of origin have asked museums to keep objects they cannot yet house safely. None of this means that museums should keep everything. It means that each claim must be judged on its own history, by a process both sides trust, rather than settled by a general rule.
Which one of the following best describes how Passage B relates to the argument in Passage A?
- Passage B gives further evidence for the default that Passage A proposes.
- Passage B argues that the analogy in Passage A is accurate.
- Passage B rejects the idea that any object was taken unfairly.
- Passage B restates Passage A's conclusion in different words.
- Passage B raises complications that count against settling claims by a general rule such as the one Passage A proposes.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Passage B lists complications (several owners, legal sales, states versus communities, communities asking museums to keep objects) and concludes that claims need case-by-case judgment, which works against a general default.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
The authors would most likely disagree about whether
- heat waves are a public health problem
- setting a tree-canopy target is, by itself, a sound response to urban heat
- cities are hotter than the countryside
- poorer neighbourhoods often face the most heat
- trees cool the air through evaporation
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A recommends "ambitious targets for tree canopy"; B says a target without care funding is "closer to a gesture". B. Both accept or do not dispute the others.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
Passage B mentions which one of the following that Passage A does not?
- Heat is a public health risk.
- Poor neighbourhoods often have few trees.
- Many newly planted trees die within their first several years.
- Pavement absorbs sunlight during the day.
- Tree-lined streets can be cooler.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Only B discusses young-tree mortality. C. The rest are in A.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
The author of Passage B would most likely respond to Passage A’s claim that without intention "nothing is left to make our readings answerable" by saying that
- readers should consult the poet’s letters
- later readers always misunderstand poems
- readings can be held answerable to the text itself
- readings need not be answerable to anything
- the author’s intention is the only possible standard
Answer and solution
Answer: C
B: a reading "can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure ...". That is an alternative standard. C.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
Passage A states that intentions are shown
- through interviews with the poet
- only to readers of the same century
- in the readings of later centuries
- in the work itself: its words, form and context
- only in the poet’s private letters
Answer and solution
Answer: D
"Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context." D. A explicitly says we need not read private letters.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
The authors would most likely disagree about whether
- the last-place candidate is eliminated in each round
- plurality voting can produce a winner most voters opposed
- every voting method has some flaws
- ranked-choice voting ensures that the winner has majority support among voters
- voters can rank candidates under ranked-choice voting
Answer and solution
Answer: D
A says the winner "can claim the support ... of a majority"; B says that majority is only of remaining ballots and "may still fall short of a majority of all voters". D.
-
MCQHard
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
Which one of the following claims appears in Passage A but not in Passage B?
- Ballots that rank only eliminated candidates are set aside.
- A voter can sometimes help a candidate by ranking that candidate lower.
- Every voting method has flaws.
- The method can eliminate a candidate who would win head-to-head contests.
- Campaigns become less negative under ranked-choice voting.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Only A reports less negative campaigns. A through D are B’s points.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
Museums in former colonial powers hold thousands of objects taken from other countries during periods of conquest. Requests to return these objects are often met with the argument that the museums preserve them better and make them available to a global audience. That argument confuses custody with ownership. A borrowed book does not become the borrower's because it is kept on a clean shelf. Where an object was taken by force or under clear duress, the default should be return, and the burden should fall on the museum to show why it should keep what it never fairly acquired.
Passage B
Calls to return museum objects to their countries of origin rest on a simple picture: an object was taken from a people, and justice requires giving it back. Real cases are rarely so simple. Many objects changed hands several times, sometimes through sales that were legal at the time; the modern state that requests an object may not represent the community that made it; and some communities of origin have asked museums to keep objects they cannot yet house safely. None of this means that museums should keep everything. It means that each claim must be judged on its own history, by a process both sides trust, rather than settled by a general rule.
The author of Passage A uses the example of a borrowed book primarily to
- illustrate the claim that keeping something well does not make it yours
- show that museums are like libraries
- argue that museums should lend objects to other museums
- suggest that colonial powers paid for most objects
- show that preservation is unimportant
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The book example follows "That argument confuses custody with ownership" and illustrates it: good care (a clean shelf) does not transfer ownership.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
Which one of the following city programmes would the author of Passage B most likely praise?
- A programme that plants trees only in wealthy districts
- A programme that replaces all trees with reflective roofing
- A programme that stops all tree planting
- A programme that plants fewer trees but funds watering and care for ten years, while installing shaded bus stops in the hottest districts
- A programme that plants a million trees in a year and reports the number planted
Answer and solution
Answer: D
B wants long-term care and immediate measures "such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops" where heat is worst. D. E is the planted-count approach B criticises.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
Cities are hotter than the countryside around them, sometimes by several degrees on a summer evening, because pavement and buildings absorb sunlight during the day and release it at night. As heat waves grow more frequent, this difference has become a matter of public health: heat kills more people in many wealthy countries than any other kind of weather event. Trees offer one of the most effective remedies available. A mature street tree shades the pavement beneath it and cools the air through the evaporation of water from its leaves. Studies comparing neighbourhoods have found that streets with dense tree cover can be markedly cooler at street level than nearby streets without it. City governments should therefore set ambitious targets for tree canopy, and they should begin with the neighbourhoods that have the least, which are very often the poorest and the hottest.
Passage B
Planting trees has become the favourite answer to urban heat, and it is easy to see why: trees are popular, visible and cheap to plant. But planting is the cheap part. A young tree in a city street faces compacted soil, little water, road salt and damage from vehicles, and in many programmes a large share of newly planted trees die within their first several years. A tree delivers most of its cooling only when its canopy is large, which can take decades. Programmes that count trees planted rather than trees surviving can therefore report success while delivering little shade. None of this means trees are a poor investment. It means that a planting target without long-term funding for watering, soil improvement and care is closer to a gesture than a policy. Cities would also do well to pair trees with measures that work immediately, such as reflective roofing and shaded bus stops, in the neighbourhoods where heat is most dangerous.
The attitude of the author of Passage B toward tree planting is best described as
- hostile to planting trees in cities
- enthusiastic and uncritical
- indifferent to urban heat
- uncertain whether trees provide shade
- supportive of trees but critical of how planting programmes are often run
Answer and solution
Answer: E
"None of this means trees are a poor investment" plus sustained criticism of count-based programmes. E.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
In Passage B, the examples of a love lyric becoming a poem about exile serve mainly to
- show that love poems are often misread
- support Passage A’s position
- show that hymns are better than lyrics
- argue that authors hid secret meanings in their poems
- illustrate meanings later readers find that authors could not have foreseen
Answer and solution
Answer: E
They illustrate "meanings their authors could not have foreseen". E.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
When readers disagree about what a poem means, there must be some standard by which one reading can be better than another; otherwise interpretation is merely the expression of preference. The most defensible standard is the author’s intention. A poem is an act of communication, and to understand any communication is to grasp what the speaker meant by it. This does not require that we read the poet’s private letters or ask what was on the poet’s mind at a given moment. Intentions are shown in the work itself, in its words, form and context, and we infer them as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark. But if we abandon the idea that we are trying to recover what someone meant, nothing is left to make our readings answerable to anything outside ourselves.
Passage B
The view that a poem means what its author intended has an appealing simplicity, but it fails to describe how literature actually lives. Poems routinely outlast the circumstances of their making, and readers in later centuries find in them meanings their authors could not have foreseen: a love lyric becomes a poem about exile, a hymn about a harvest becomes a meditation on mortality. To call these readings mistakes because the author did not intend them is to treat the poem as a message whose delivery is either correct or failed. Yet a reading need not be arbitrary simply because it goes beyond intention. It can be tested against the text: does it account for the poem’s images, its structure, its turns of phrase? A reading that ignores half the words fails, whatever its source; a reading that illuminates them succeeds, whatever the author had in mind.
Passage A’s view of interpretation is most closely analogous to which one of the following?
- Working out what a friend meant by a remark from the words used and the situation
- Choosing the reading of a song one likes best
- Translating a poem word by word without regard to sense
- Finding new uses for an old tool
- Judging a painting only by its colours
Answer and solution
Answer: A
A says we infer intentions "as we infer the meaning of a friend’s remark". A. D resembles Passage B’s view.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
Passage A’s phrase "a majority of the ballots still counting at the end" is most relevant to which point in Passage B?
- The winner may fall short of a majority of all voters because some ballots are set aside.
- Voters can help a favoured candidate by ranking it lower.
- A candidate with few first choices may be eliminated early.
- Every voting method has flaws.
- Plurality elections reward long-shot candidates.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
A’s careful wording concedes the very point B presses: the majority is of remaining ballots, not of all voters. A.
-
MCQTop rank
Passage A
In most elections for a single office, each voter marks one candidate and whoever receives the most votes wins, even if that is well short of a majority. When three or more candidates run, this system can produce a winner most voters opposed, and it punishes voters who prefer a candidate unlikely to win: by voting sincerely, they may help elect the candidate they like least. Ranked-choice voting addresses both problems. Voters rank the candidates in order of preference; if no one has a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots move to their next choice, until one candidate has a majority. Voters can support a long-shot candidate first without wasting their vote, and the winner can claim the support, at least as a later preference, of a majority of the ballots still counting at the end. Jurisdictions that have adopted the system report that voters understand it and that campaigns become less negative, since candidates seek to be others’ second choice.
Passage B
Ranked-choice voting is often presented as a remedy for the flaws of plurality elections, and it does reduce some of them. But its advocates tend to overstate what it guarantees. The "majority" it produces is a majority of the ballots remaining in the final round; ballots that ranked only eliminated candidates are set aside, so the winner may still fall short of a majority of all voters. More importantly, the method can eliminate early a candidate whom most voters would have preferred to each rival in a head-to-head contest, if that candidate has few first choices. And it is not immune to the strategic voting it claims to end: in some circumstances, a voter can help a favoured candidate by ranking that candidate lower. None of these problems is decisive, since every voting method has flaws of some kind. The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for.
The author of Passage B would most likely advise a city considering ranked-choice voting to
- let candidates choose the voting method
- weigh its specific trade-offs against the kinds of elections the city holds
- reject it because it is not perfect
- adopt it because it ends strategic voting
- keep plurality voting because it has no flaws
Answer and solution
Answer: B
"The question for a jurisdiction is not whether ranked-choice voting is perfect but whether its particular trade-offs suit the elections it will be used for." B.