Author's attitude
Reading Comprehension · 22 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Author's attitude and viewpoints.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQExam level
Art historians have long described the nineteenth-century landscape painter Teodora Vass as self-taught, a label that has done much to shape her reputation. Vass, the story goes, learned to paint alone in a remote mountain village, and the strange flatness of her skies and the absence of conventional perspective in her valleys are the marks of a gifted outsider who never absorbed the rules of the academy.
This account is not exactly false, but it is badly incomplete. Letters recently found in a regional archive show that Vass spent two winters in the capital copying paintings in the national gallery, and that she corresponded for a decade with a teacher at the academy who sent her prints and detailed criticism. Her "outsider" flatness, seen in this light, looks less like ignorance than choice. Several of her letters discuss Japanese woodblock prints, then newly fashionable among academy painters, and praise exactly the qualities critics later treated as her limitations.
None of this diminishes Vass's achievement; if anything, it enlarges it. A painter who breaks rules she has never learned shows talent, but a painter who learns the rules and then sets them aside for a purpose shows judgment. The self-taught label, for all its romance, has made Vass seem a happy accident rather than an artist making deliberate decisions. It is time historians described her as what the letters show she was: a well-informed painter who knew the conventions of her day and chose, with care, which of them to keep.
The author's attitude toward the description of Vass as "self-taught" is best described as
- indifferent to whether it is accurate
- convinced that it was invented deliberately to harm Vass
- uncertain whether the letters bear on it
- critical of it as misleadingly incomplete, though not entirely false
- fully supportive of it
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The author says the account "is not exactly false, but it is badly incomplete". That is criticism with a concession. Nothing suggests the label was made up to harm her.
-
MCQExam level
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
The author’s attitude toward microcredit itself is best described as
- measured approval of it as a useful service, combined with rejection of the larger claims made for it
- unqualified enthusiasm for its power to end poverty
- firm conviction that it has failed
- deep suspicion that lenders exploit borrowers
- indifference to whether it helps anyone
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The author calls it "a useful financial service" and lists real benefits, but says the "story told about it" (a cure for poverty) is undermined. A. C is the commentators’ reading the author calls "too quick".
Why people get this wrong: Taking the reported "failure" verdict as the author’s.
-
MCQExam level
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Moneylenders are more useful to the poor than microcredit lenders.
- Careful evaluations showed microcredit to be a useful service rather than the cure for poverty it was claimed to be, and that kind of testing is itself valuable.
- Microcredit should be replaced by grants to poor households.
- Randomised evaluations are too expensive to use in development economics.
- Microcredit greatly improved children’s schooling and health.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The last paragraph: the evidence undermines "the story", not the service, and "a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution". B. E contradicts paragraph 2.
-
MCQExam level
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
The author’s attitude toward the critics described in the second paragraph is best described as
- grateful that they changed how jazz is taught
- sympathetic to their concern but convinced that they exaggerate it
- in complete agreement with them
- contemptuous of their knowledge of jazz
- uncertain whether their argument is relevant
Answer and solution
Answer: B
"The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated." B captures both parts.
-
MCQExam level
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Young players should stop transcribing famous solos.
- Historians should not rely on recordings to study jazz.
- Recordings did not turn jazz improvisation into mere imitation; they gave the tradition a memory that improvisers can build on.
- Recordings have destroyed the spontaneity of jazz.
- Early jazz musicians never repeated their solos.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The author rejects the pessimistic view and ends: recordings "gave the music a memory". C. D is the critics’ view; E is contradicted in paragraph 3.
-
MCQExam level
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
The author’s attitude toward de-extinction research is best described as
- neutral, with no view on its value
- confident that it will soon restore lost ecosystems
- respectful of the science but sceptical that it should be a conservation priority
- enthusiastic support for making it the main goal of conservation
- complete opposition to any further research
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The author calls the science "genuinely impressive" and says research need not stop, but concludes it should be "a scientific curiosity rather than ... a conservation priority". C. E is denied: "None of this means de-extinction research should stop."
Why people get this wrong: Overstating scepticism as total opposition.
-
MCQExam level
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Every extinction in history was caused by habitat loss.
- De-extinction research should be banned.
- Revived animals would always learn the behaviours of their extinct relatives.
- Because the claims behind de-extinction are doubtful and living species can be saved more cheaply, reviving lost species should not be a conservation priority for now.
- Genetic engineering will never produce an animal resembling an extinct species.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The passage examines three claims and ends with the author’s recommendation. D. C contradicts paragraph 2.
-
MCQHard
Art historians have long described the nineteenth-century landscape painter Teodora Vass as self-taught, a label that has done much to shape her reputation. Vass, the story goes, learned to paint alone in a remote mountain village, and the strange flatness of her skies and the absence of conventional perspective in her valleys are the marks of a gifted outsider who never absorbed the rules of the academy.
This account is not exactly false, but it is badly incomplete. Letters recently found in a regional archive show that Vass spent two winters in the capital copying paintings in the national gallery, and that she corresponded for a decade with a teacher at the academy who sent her prints and detailed criticism. Her "outsider" flatness, seen in this light, looks less like ignorance than choice. Several of her letters discuss Japanese woodblock prints, then newly fashionable among academy painters, and praise exactly the qualities critics later treated as her limitations.
None of this diminishes Vass's achievement; if anything, it enlarges it. A painter who breaks rules she has never learned shows talent, but a painter who learns the rules and then sets them aside for a purpose shows judgment. The self-taught label, for all its romance, has made Vass seem a happy accident rather than an artist making deliberate decisions. It is time historians described her as what the letters show she was: a well-informed painter who knew the conventions of her day and chose, with care, which of them to keep.
The author's attitude toward Vass's work can most accurately be described as
- disappointed that she was not truly self-taught
- neutral, avoiding any judgment of her painting
- sceptical that her paintings have any lasting value
- amused by the flatness of her skies
- admiring, with the view that the new evidence makes her achievement greater
Answer and solution
Answer: E
"None of this diminishes Vass's achievement; if anything, it enlarges it." The author admires her and thinks the letters raise her standing.
-
MCQHard
Art historians have long described the nineteenth-century landscape painter Teodora Vass as self-taught, a label that has done much to shape her reputation. Vass, the story goes, learned to paint alone in a remote mountain village, and the strange flatness of her skies and the absence of conventional perspective in her valleys are the marks of a gifted outsider who never absorbed the rules of the academy.
This account is not exactly false, but it is badly incomplete. Letters recently found in a regional archive show that Vass spent two winters in the capital copying paintings in the national gallery, and that she corresponded for a decade with a teacher at the academy who sent her prints and detailed criticism. Her "outsider" flatness, seen in this light, looks less like ignorance than choice. Several of her letters discuss Japanese woodblock prints, then newly fashionable among academy painters, and praise exactly the qualities critics later treated as her limitations.
None of this diminishes Vass's achievement; if anything, it enlarges it. A painter who breaks rules she has never learned shows talent, but a painter who learns the rules and then sets them aside for a purpose shows judgment. The self-taught label, for all its romance, has made Vass seem a happy accident rather than an artist making deliberate decisions. It is time historians described her as what the letters show she was: a well-informed painter who knew the conventions of her day and chose, with care, which of them to keep.
In the third paragraph, the author contrasts "talent" with "judgment" primarily in order to
- explain why deliberate rule-breaking deserves more credit than rule-breaking from ignorance
- argue that talent cannot be taught
- suggest that academy painters lacked talent
- show that Vass never broke any rules
- claim that judgment is a form of talent
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The contrast supports the claim that the letters "enlarge" Vass's achievement: a painter who knows the rules and sets them aside for a purpose shows something more than one who never learned them.
-
MCQHard
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
According to the passage, the randomised evaluations found that access to microcredit
- reduced children’s school attendance
- made borrowers more dependent on moneylenders
- led some households to start or expand businesses but did not raise average household income much
- raised household income sharply in every country studied
- had no effect on any household
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Paragraph 2 reports exactly C. E ignores the business and flexibility effects; nothing supports A or B.
-
MCQHard
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
The author mentions moneylenders "charging ruinous interest" primarily in order to
- explain why randomised evaluations were difficult to run
- show that borrowers used loans mostly for emergencies
- criticise lenders for charging high interest on microloans
- suggest that microcredit may be better than the alternative borrowers had, even if it does not end poverty
- argue that moneylenders should be banned
Answer and solution
Answer: D
It is the last of three reasons the "failure" reading is too quick: credit "may still be preferable to the moneylenders". D.
-
MCQHard
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
According to the passage, players of the early recording era often
- never played the same phrase twice
- learned their solos from transcriptions
- improvised without any learned material
- worked out solos in advance and repeated favourite ideas from night to night
- refused to be recorded
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Paragraph 3 states D. A and C describe the idealised picture the author denies.
-
MCQHard
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
The author would most likely agree that a music teacher who has students memorise a famous solo
- is destroying the students’ ability to improvise
- should instead forbid students from listening to recordings
- is teaching a written composition rather than jazz
- is following the practice of all early jazz players
- is acting reasonably if the students then use the solo as material for their own improvising
Answer and solution
Answer: E
The danger "lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material". Memorising is fine if the solo becomes vocabulary. E.
-
MCQHard
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
The passage mentions migration routes as an example of
- a trait that genetic editing can easily reproduce
- a reason extinct animals were hunted
- a habitat that has been built over
- evidence that revived animals would thrive
- behaviour that was learned rather than inherited and so could not be restored by editing genes
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Migration routes "once passed from parent to young" are given as "learned rather than inherited". E.
-
MCQHard
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
Which one of the following can most reasonably be inferred from the third paragraph?
- A revived species released where its habitat has disappeared would probably die out again.
- Hunting played no part in any extinction.
- Farmland can easily be returned to forest.
- De-extinction projects always choose species whose habitat survives.
- Wetlands are more important than grasslands.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Releasing animals into land "that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction." A. B contradicts "not only by hunting".
-
MCQTop rank
Art historians have long described the nineteenth-century landscape painter Teodora Vass as self-taught, a label that has done much to shape her reputation. Vass, the story goes, learned to paint alone in a remote mountain village, and the strange flatness of her skies and the absence of conventional perspective in her valleys are the marks of a gifted outsider who never absorbed the rules of the academy.
This account is not exactly false, but it is badly incomplete. Letters recently found in a regional archive show that Vass spent two winters in the capital copying paintings in the national gallery, and that she corresponded for a decade with a teacher at the academy who sent her prints and detailed criticism. Her "outsider" flatness, seen in this light, looks less like ignorance than choice. Several of her letters discuss Japanese woodblock prints, then newly fashionable among academy painters, and praise exactly the qualities critics later treated as her limitations.
None of this diminishes Vass's achievement; if anything, it enlarges it. A painter who breaks rules she has never learned shows talent, but a painter who learns the rules and then sets them aside for a purpose shows judgment. The self-taught label, for all its romance, has made Vass seem a happy accident rather than an artist making deliberate decisions. It is time historians described her as what the letters show she was: a well-informed painter who knew the conventions of her day and chose, with care, which of them to keep.
Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the author's view of Vass?
- Some critics still praise the flatness of Vass's skies.
- An early painting by Vass, made before her winters in the capital, uses conventional perspective that her later paintings abandon.
- Many other nineteenth-century painters were self-taught.
- Vass's letters were written in an unusual dialect.
- Japanese woodblock prints were difficult to obtain in the mountains.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
If Vass once painted conventional perspective and later dropped it, her flatness was a choice, not a lack of skill, exactly the author's claim. The other facts do not bear on whether her style was deliberate.
-
MCQTop rank
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
It can be inferred that the author believes the commentators who called microcredit a failure
- relied on studies that were badly designed
- were right that microcredit should be abandoned
- had never supported microcredit in the first place
- were mainly concerned with interest rates
- paid too little attention to what averages can hide and to benefits other than income
Answer and solution
Answer: E
The author answers them by noting "averages can hide a great deal" and that smoothing spending "is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income". E. The author praises the studies, so A is wrong.
-
MCQTop rank
Few ideas in development economics have enjoyed as much enthusiasm as microcredit, the practice of lending very small sums to poor people, often women, who lack the collateral that banks require. In its early years, supporters described it in sweeping terms. A loan of a few hundred dollars, they said, would let a borrower start a business, raise her family’s income and climb out of poverty; repeated across millions of borrowers, microcredit could transform whole economies.
The evidence that eventually arrived was more modest, and it arrived through a method that had rarely been used to judge such programmes: randomised evaluation. Researchers worked with lenders who were opening branches in new areas, and compared neighbourhoods chosen at random to receive access to loans with similar neighbourhoods that did not yet have it. Across several countries, the results were strikingly consistent. Access to credit did lead some households to start or expand small businesses, and it gave many families more flexibility in timing large purchases. But on average it did not raise household income by much, and it did not noticeably improve measures such as children’s schooling or health.
It would be easy to read these findings as a verdict that microcredit failed, and some commentators did. That reading is too quick. The studies measured averages, and averages can hide a great deal: a minority of borrowers with existing businesses appeared to benefit substantially, while many others used loans for consumption or emergencies. Smoothing a family’s spending through a bad harvest or an illness is not nothing, even if it does not show up as higher income. And credit that does not lift people out of poverty may still be preferable to the moneylenders, charging ruinous interest, on whom borrowers previously relied.
What the evidence undermines is not microcredit but the story told about it. A useful financial service was sold as a cure for poverty, and when it turned out to be only a useful financial service, disappointment was inevitable. The lasting lesson may concern the method more than the loans: grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution, not a defeat.
Which one of the following principles is most strongly suggested by the last paragraph?
- A claim about the effects of a policy should be tested before it is accepted, even if the test may show the claim to be exaggerated.
- A policy that does not end poverty should not be funded.
- Development programmes should never be described in hopeful terms.
- Only policies that raise average income are worth pursuing.
- Financial services are less important than health and education.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
"Grand claims about development deserve to be tested before they are believed, and a careful test that deflates a claim is a contribution." A. B and D conflict with the author’s defence of microcredit as useful.
-
MCQTop rank
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
The third paragraph functions primarily to
- challenge an assumption on which the critics’ argument depends
- provide further support for the critics’ argument
- describe how recordings are made
- introduce a new problem unrelated to the critics’ view
- summarise the history of jazz education
Answer and solution
Answer: A
It opens: "It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely ... In fact ..." It attacks the critics’ assumption. A.
-
MCQTop rank
Improvised music presents historians with an odd problem. A jazz solo, in the traditional understanding, is made up in the moment and never played the same way twice; its value lies partly in that unrepeatability. Yet almost everything we know about the history of jazz comes from recordings, which fix one performance permanently and allow it to be heard thousands of times. The music’s history, it seems, is written in a medium that contradicts the music’s nature.
Some critics have drawn a pessimistic conclusion from this. A recording, they argue, turns an event into an object. Listeners memorise a famous solo note for note; younger players transcribe it and practise it until they can reproduce it exactly; and the solo, which was once a single unrepeatable response to a particular evening, becomes a fixed text, studied like a written composition. On this view, recording has quietly converted an art of spontaneity into an art of imitation.
The worry is understandable but, I think, overstated. It assumes that the musicians of the early recording era improvised freely each night and that recording alone changed this. In fact, players of that time often worked out their solos in advance and repeated their best ideas from night to night; audiences came to expect a favourite phrase, and players supplied it. Improvisation was never pure invention from nothing. It was, and remains, a practice of recombining learned material in new ways, and transcription is simply a newer and more efficient means of acquiring that material.
Nor does the record of a solo freeze the music in the way the critics fear. A young player who learns a famous solo exactly does not thereby lose the ability to improvise; the solo becomes part of a vocabulary, to be broken apart and reassembled. The danger, where it exists, lies not in recordings but in teaching that treats a transcription as the goal rather than as raw material. Recordings did change jazz, as every new technology changes the art made with it. But they gave the music a memory, and a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon.
In the final sentence, the author’s claim that "a tradition without a memory has little to improvise upon" is best understood as expressing
- a prediction that jazz will stop changing
- the view that improvisation depends on a stock of remembered material
- regret that recordings were invented
- doubt that improvisation is possible at all
- the critics’ central objection
Answer and solution
Answer: B
It echoes paragraph 3’s point that improvisation is "recombining learned material"; recordings supply that memory. B.
-
MCQTop rank
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
The author mentions that de-extinction research "may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations" primarily in order to
- cast doubt on the impressiveness of the science
- acknowledge a possible benefit that justifies continuing the research
- show that de-extinction is the most efficient way to save living species
- explain why habitat protection is expensive
- argue that inbred populations should be allowed to die out
Answer and solution
Answer: B
It follows "None of this means de-extinction research should stop", giving a reason to continue it. B. The author still says living species are best saved by familiar tools, so C is wrong.
-
MCQTop rank
Advances in genetics have made a once-fanciful idea seem within reach: reviving species that have gone extinct. By editing the genome of a living relative so that it carries traits of the lost animal, scientists hope to produce creatures that look and behave much like the originals. Supporters of these projects, often called de-extinction, speak of correcting past mistakes and restoring ecosystems that lost key species through human action.
Such goals deserve to be taken seriously, and the science involved is genuinely impressive. Yet the enthusiasm that surrounds de-extinction rests on several claims that merit more scrutiny than they usually receive. The first is that the revived animal would be the species that was lost. An edited relative might resemble its extinct cousin in size, coat or shape while differing in behaviours that were learned rather than inherited, such as migration routes once passed from parent to young. With no surviving adults to teach them, the new animals would have to invent their own ways of living, and might fill a different ecological role than their predecessors.
The second claim is that the habitat the species needs still exists. Many extinctions were caused not only by hunting but by the loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands that have since been farmed or built over. Releasing animals into a landscape that can no longer support them would merely stage a second extinction.
The most troubling claim, however, is implicit: that reviving species is a sensible use of the limited money and attention available for conservation. Every species currently threatened with extinction can still be saved with familiar tools, protecting habitat and controlling hunting and invasive predators, at a fraction of the cost of genetic engineering. There is a risk, too, that the promise of revival will weaken the urgency of protecting species now; if extinction can be reversed, losing a species may come to seem less final. None of this means de-extinction research should stop. It may yield techniques useful for strengthening small, inbred populations of living species. But until the species we still have are secure, the revival of those we have lost should be treated as a scientific curiosity rather than as a conservation priority.
Which one of the following, if true, would most weaken the author’s argument in the last paragraph?
- Many people find extinct animals fascinating.
- Protecting habitat is sometimes politically difficult.
- De-extinction projects are funded entirely by donors who would otherwise give nothing to conservation.
- Genetic editing is becoming cheaper every year.
- Some revived animals might be kept in zoos.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The argument says revival competes with living species for "limited money and attention". If the money would never have gone to conservation anyway, that cost disappears: C.