Necessary assumption
Assumption family · 10 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Necessary assumptions.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
Coach: Jonah had the highest batting average on our team this season. So Jonah will be named the team's most valuable player.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Jonah was the most valuable player last season as well.
- Batting average is the only thing considered when the most valuable player is chosen.
- Every player on the team has a lower batting average than Jonah had last season.
- Jonah also hit more home runs than anyone else on the team.
- Batting average is at least one of the things considered when the most valuable player is chosen.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Negation test on E: "Batting average plays no part at all in choosing the most valuable player." Then Jonah's average gives no reason to expect the award, and the argument collapses, so E is required. B would be enough to prove the conclusion, but it is not required: the award could weigh other things too and still go to Jonah.
Why people get this wrong: Choosing the strong answer (B) that would prove the conclusion, when the question asks what the argument cannot do without.
-
MCQStandard
The company should move its office to the suburbs, since rents there are lower than downtown.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Moving to the suburbs would not create other costs that outweigh the savings on rent.
- All of the company’s employees live in the suburbs.
- Rents downtown will rise next year.
- The company owns its current building.
- Other companies have moved to the suburbs.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Negate A: if the move creates costs larger than the rent savings, the reason to move collapses. So the argument depends on A. B is far more than the argument needs.
Why people get this wrong: Choosing an answer stronger than necessary.
-
MCQExam level
Coffee chain spokesperson: Our new paper cups break down in garden compost within twelve weeks. So switching to them will greatly reduce the number of our cups that end up in landfills.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- A significant share of the new cups will actually be composted rather than thrown in the trash.
- Garden compost breaks down most materials within twelve weeks.
- Customers prefer paper cups to plastic ones.
- Other coffee chains will soon switch to compostable cups.
- Paper cups are more expensive than plastic ones.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
A cup that can break down in compost still goes to a landfill if people throw it in the trash. Negate A: "Almost none of the cups will be composted." Then the switch would hardly change what ends up in landfills, and the argument fails. That makes A necessary.
Why people get this wrong: Confusing "could be composted" with "will be composted".
-
MCQExam level
Since the town installed speed cameras on Main Street, the number of collisions there has fallen by forty percent. The cameras, therefore, are responsible for the drop in collisions.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Speed cameras are more effective than police patrols.
- No other change that would reduce collisions on Main Street happened at about the same time.
- Most drivers on Main Street were speeding before the cameras were installed.
- The cameras have also reduced collisions on nearby streets.
- Collisions on Main Street had been rising before the cameras were installed.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The argument goes from "came after" to "caused". It must assume nothing else explains the drop. Negate B: "A new traffic light and a lower speed limit came in the same month." Then the cameras may not be responsible, so the argument depends on B.
Why people get this wrong: Answers like C sound helpful but are not required: the cameras could cut collisions even if only some drivers were speeding.
-
MCQExam level
Critic: The new film adaptation changes the novel’s ending. So the film cannot be a faithful adaptation of the novel.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- The novel’s author disliked the film.
- A faithful adaptation keeps the ending of the work it adapts.
- The novel’s ending is its best part.
- Most film adaptations change details.
- The film was popular with audiences.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The conclusion follows only if changing the ending rules out faithfulness. Negate B: if a faithful adaptation may change the ending, the argument fails.
-
MCQHard
Museum director: Attendance at our ancient art galleries fell last year while attendance at our modern art galleries rose. To bring visitors back, we should move the most famous ancient pieces into the modern wing for a joint show.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Attendance at the modern galleries will keep rising next year.
- Modern art is more popular than ancient art with most visitors.
- Visitors to the modern wing would be at least somewhat interested in seeing famous ancient pieces.
- The museum's ancient art collection is larger than its modern collection.
- No other museum has ever held a joint show of ancient and modern art.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The plan works only if people who visit the modern wing will pay attention to the ancient pieces placed there. Negate C: "Modern-wing visitors have no interest at all in the ancient pieces." Then moving them would not bring anyone back, so the plan fails. B is not required: the plan could work even if modern art is not more popular overall.
-
MCQHard
Sleep researcher: In our study, people who slept less than six hours a night were twice as likely to catch a cold after exposure to the virus as people who slept seven hours or more. Thus getting more sleep would make people less likely to catch colds.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- People who sleep more than nine hours a night catch the fewest colds.
- The study included people of many different ages.
- Most people sleep less than seven hours a night.
- The people who slept less were not more likely to catch colds for some other reason, such as greater stress, that also caused their short sleep.
- Sleep is the most important factor in avoiding colds.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The argument moves from a link (short sleep goes with more colds) to a cause (more sleep would help). It must assume a third factor is not behind both. Negate D: stress causes both short sleep and colds. Then sleeping more would not help, and the conclusion fails. E is far too strong to be required.
Why people get this wrong: Necessary assumptions are often modest. "Most important factor" is more than the argument needs.
-
MCQHard
To reduce traffic on the bridge, the city plans to charge a toll during rush hour. Drivers who wish to avoid the toll will cross at other times, so rush-hour traffic will fall.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Traffic outside rush hour is very light.
- The city will spend the toll money on road repairs.
- At least some drivers who now cross at rush hour are able to change when they cross.
- Every driver who crosses at rush hour will pay the toll.
- The toll will be higher than any other toll in the region.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
If no rush-hour driver can change their timing, the toll will not shift anyone. The argument needs C. D would undermine the argument.
-
MCQTop rank
Only students who complete the research methods course may enroll in the senior thesis seminar. Ravi has enrolled in the senior thesis seminar, so he must have taken a statistics class, since the research methods course includes a statistics unit.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- The senior thesis seminar requires a statistics project.
- Ravi enjoyed the statistics unit more than the rest of the course.
- Students may not take the research methods course more than once.
- Every student who takes the research methods course passes it.
- Completing the statistics unit of the research methods course counts as taking a statistics class.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
From the rule, Ravi completed research methods, so he completed its statistics unit. The conclusion, though, is about a "statistics class". The argument needs the unit to count as one. Negate E: "The unit does not count as a statistics class." Then the conclusion no longer follows. This is a gap in terms: the conclusion uses a word the premises never connect to.
Why people get this wrong: Look for a new term in the conclusion ("statistics class") that the premises do not mention.
-
MCQTop rank
Nutritionist: People who eat breakfast tend to weigh less than people who skip it. Hence, encouraging people who skip breakfast to start eating it will help them weigh less.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
- Breakfast should be the largest meal of the day.
- People who skip breakfast eat more at lunch.
- Most people prefer to eat breakfast.
- Eating breakfast is not merely a sign of other habits that are the real cause of lower weight.
- Everyone who eats breakfast weighs less than everyone who skips it.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The argument moves from a correlation to a cause. Negate D: if breakfast is only a marker of other healthy habits, getting people to eat it will not help. B might support the argument but is not required.