Identical particles
Quantum mechanics · 14 questions and templates for IIT JAM Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
The total wavefunction (space and spin) of a system of two identical fermions must be- antisymmetric under exchange of the two particles
- symmetric under exchange
- symmetric in space and antisymmetric in spin, always
- unchanged in magnitude only, with any phase
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Exchange commutes with for identical particles and , so states have . Nature chooses: for fermions (half-integer spin), for bosons (integer spin). For fermions the space part can be symmetric if the spin part is antisymmetric, or the other way round; only the product must be antisymmetric.Why people get this wrong: The third option is only one of the two possibilities (the singlet case).
-
MCQWarm-up
Which of these behaves as a boson?- An electron
- A neutral He atom
- A neutral He atom
- A proton
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Count the fermions inside: He has 2 protons, 2 neutrons and 2 electrons, 6 fermions, so its total spin is an integer and it is a boson (hence superfluid He). He has 5 fermions: a fermion. Electrons and protons are spin- fermions. -
MCQWarm-up
Two non-interacting electrons (spin ) are in a 1D infinite well whose single-particle levels are . The ground-state energy of the pair isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Both can occupy if their spins form the antisymmetric singlet, so . For spinless fermions (or electrons forced into a triplet) one must go to : . -
MCQWarm-up
The Pauli exclusion principle follows from antisymmetry because- fermions repel each other electrically
- fermions have spin
- bosons occupy only even states
- an antisymmetric product of two identical one-particle states, , is zero
Answer and solution
Answer: D
If both particles had the same one-particle state (space and spin), the antisymmetrised wavefunction would vanish identically. So no two identical fermions share a complete set of quantum numbers. It has nothing to do with charge: neutrons obey it too. -
MCQWarm-up
Which of these is a fermion?- a neutral He atom
- a neutral He atom
- a deuteron
- a neutral H atom
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Count the spin- constituents: an odd number makes a fermion. He: 2 protons + 1 neutron + 2 electrons = 5, odd: fermion. He: 6, deuteron: 2, H: 2 (proton + electron), all even: bosons.Why people get this wrong: Count electrons too for neutral atoms; a hydrogen atom is a boson although the proton and electron are fermions.
-
MCQStandard
The spin-statistics connection states that- all particles with spin are fermions
- bosons have half-integer spin
- statistics depends on the temperature
- particles with integer spin are bosons and particles with half-integer spin are fermions
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Photons (spin 1), pions (0) and He atoms are bosons; electrons, protons, neutrons and He atoms are fermions. Within non-relativistic quantum mechanics it is a postulate; relativistic quantum field theory proves it. -
MCQStandard
Two electrons occupy the same spatial orbital (as in the helium ground state). Their spin state must be- the singlet
- one of the triplet states
- either a singlet or a triplet
- any product state such as
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The spatial part is symmetric under exchange. The total state must be antisymmetric, so the spin part must be antisymmetric: the singlet . This is the Pauli rule "two electrons per orbital, with opposite spins".Why people get this wrong: is a triplet state; it would need an antisymmetric spatial part, impossible with one orbital.
-
MSQStandard
Which of these are acceptable wavefunctions (up to normalisation) for two identical spinless bosons, with ?Answer and solution
Answer: A, B
Spinless bosons need . The symmetrised sum and the doubly occupied product are symmetric. The difference is antisymmetric (fermions), and the plain product is neither: it labels which particle is in which state.Why people get this wrong: A product of two different orbitals is not symmetric unless it is symmetrised.
-
MSQExam level
Which of these composite objects behave as bosons?- A neutral He atom
- A Cooper pair of electrons
- A deuteron
- A neutral He atom
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Count the spin- constituents: even means boson. He atom: 2 protons, 2 neutrons, 2 electrons = 6 (boson). Cooper pair: 2 electrons (boson). Deuteron: proton + neutron (boson, spin 1). He atom: 2 protons, 1 neutron, 2 electrons = 5 (fermion), which is why liquid He behaves so differently from He.Why people get this wrong: Counting only the nucleons of the He atom (3) gives the right answer here, but forgetting electrons fails for ions and other atoms.