Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / The variational method and WKB

The variational method and WKB

Quantum mechanics · 84 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: The variational method and WKB.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    For any normalisable trial state |ψ⟩ obeying the boundary conditions, the variational principle says
    1. ⟨ψ|H|ψ⟩⟨ψ|ψ⟩≥E0
    2. ⟨ψ|H|ψ⟩⟨ψ|ψ⟩≤E0
    3. ⟨ψ|H|ψ⟩=E0
    4. ⟨ψ|H|ψ⟩⟨ψ|ψ⟩≥E1, the first excited energy
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Expand |ψ⟩=∑cn|n⟩: ⟨H⟩=∑|cn|2En/∑|cn|2≥E0, because every En≥E0. Equality holds only if |ψ⟩ is the ground state. So any guess gives an upper bound on the ground-state energy.
  2. MCQWarm-up

    For a smooth potential well with two ordinary (soft) classical turning points, the WKB quantisation condition is
    1. ∮pdx=nh
    2. ∮pdx=(n+12)h
    3. ∮pdx=(n+1)h
    4. ∮pdx=(n+34)h
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Each soft turning point adds a phase of π/4 when the WKB wave is matched to the decaying solution outside (the connection formulas), so ∫abpdx=(n+12)πℏ, i.e. ∮pdx=(n+12)h, n=0,1,2,… The 12 is the zero-point term.
  3. MCQWarm-up

    The WKB approximation is reliable where
    1. the potential is exactly constant
    2. the energy is close to the top of the well
    3. the potential changes little over one local de Broglie wavelength
    4. the particle is classically forbidden
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    WKB treats the wave as locally plane with λ(x)=h/p(x). It needs |dλ/dx|≪1, i.e. the momentum changes by a small fraction over one wavelength. It fails near turning points, where p→0 and λ→∞; connection formulas bridge them. In a forbidden region it works too, with a decaying exponential, provided κ varies slowly.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    A trial function e−βx2 is used for the harmonic oscillator and ⟨H⟩ is minimised over β. The result is
    1. ℏω
    2. 0.707ℏω
    3. below 12ℏω
    4. exactly 12ℏω
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    ⟨H⟩=ℏ2β2m+mω28β, minimised at β=mω/2ℏ, giving 12ℏω. The family contains the true ground state, so the method is exact. It can never go below E0.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    If the trial state differs from the true ground state by a small admixture of size ϵ, the error in the variational energy is of order
    1. ϵ2
    2. ϵ
    3. ϵ
    4. ϵ3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    With |ψ⟩=|0⟩+ϵ|χ⟩ (χ⟂0), ⟨H⟩=E0+ϵ2⟨χ|H|χ⟩1+ϵ2=E0+ϵ2(⟨χ|H|χ⟩−E0)+… The ground state is a stationary point of ⟨H⟩, so a mediocre wavefunction still gives a good energy.
  6. MSQWarm-up

    Which statements about the variational method are correct?
    1. It gives an upper bound on the ground-state energy.
    2. It is exact if the trial family contains the true ground state.
    3. A trial function orthogonal to the ground state gives an upper bound on the first excited energy.
    4. It gives a lower bound on the ground-state energy.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    If c0=0, the expansion starts at E1, so ⟨H⟩≥E1; in practice orthogonality is often guaranteed by symmetry (an odd trial function in an even potential). The method never gives a lower bound.
  7. MCQWarm-up

    A student uses a trial function for the hydrogen ground state (exact energy −13.6 eV) and reports a minimised ⟨H⟩=−14.1 eV. The right conclusion is that
    1. the trial function is better than the exact one
    2. there is a mistake: the calculation is wrong or the trial function breaks the rules (not normalised, wrong boundary behaviour)
    3. the method has found an excited state
    4. nothing is wrong, since variational energies can lie on either side of the true value
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    For any acceptable normalised trial state, ⟨H⟩≥E0. A value below −13.6 eV is impossible, so something is wrong: a lost normalisation factor, an arithmetic slip, or a function that is not in the domain of H. Excited states lie higher, not lower.

    Why people get this wrong: The variational energy is one-sided: it can only be too high.

  8. NATStandard

    For an infinite well 0<x<a, the trial function ψ=x(a−x) gives ⟨H⟩=5ℏ2/ma2. The ratio of this to the exact ground-state energy is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.013 (±0.002)

    Exact E1=π2ℏ2/2ma2=4.935ℏ2/ma2. Ratio 5/4.935=10/π2=1.013: a 1.3% overestimate from a simple parabola. (Check of ⟨H⟩: ⟨ψ|ψ⟩=a5/30, ∫|ψ′|2=a3/3, so ⟨T⟩=ℏ22m⋅a3/3a5/30=5ℏ2/ma2.)
  9. NATStandard

    An electron meets a rectangular barrier that is 1.0 eV above its energy and 1.0 nm wide. In the WKB estimate T≈e−2κL, the exponent 2κL is ______ (to one decimal place). Use 2me⋅1 eV/ℏ=5.12 nm−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 10.2 (±0.1)

    κ=2m(V−E)/ℏ=5.12 nm−1, so 2κL=10.2 and T≈e−10.2≈3.6×10−5. Doubling the width squares T.
  10. MCQStandard

    Applied to the harmonic oscillator, the WKB rule ∮pdx=(n+12)h gives
    1. En=nℏω
    2. En=(n+12)ℏω, the exact result
    3. En=(n+12)ℏω only for large n
    4. En=(n+1)ℏω
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The orbit in phase space is an ellipse with semi-axes 2E/mω2 and 2mE, area 2πE/ω. Setting it to (n+12)h gives E=(n+12)ℏω for every n: an accident of the quadratic potential (WKB is also exact for the Coulomb potential with the Langer correction).
  11. MCQStandard

    For a well with infinitely hard walls at both ends (and any smooth floor between), the WKB condition is
    1. ∫abpdx=(n+12)πℏ
    2. ∫abpdx=(n−14)πℏ
    3. ∫abpdx=nπℏ, n=1,2,…
    4. ∫abpdx=2nπℏ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    At a hard wall the wavefunction must vanish, with no π/4 phase leak into a forbidden region. Two walls give ∫pdx=nπℏ; for a flat floor this reproduces the exact square-well levels n2π2ℏ2/2ma2.
  12. MCQStandard

    In a potential V=c|x|k, WKB predicts that at large n the levels grow as En∝n2k/(k+2). For the linear potential V=F|x| this is
    1. n2
    2. n
    3. n4/3
    4. n2/3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The turning point is x0∝E1/k and p∝E1/2, so ∫pdx∝E1/2+1/k=E(k+2)/2k∝n. For k=1: E∝n2/3. Checks: k=2 gives n (oscillator), k→∞ gives n2 (square well).
  13. MCQStandard

    For helium with trial function ψ∝e−ζ(r1+r2)/a0, one finds ⟨H⟩=(2ζ2−274ζ)×13.6 eV. The best effective charge ζ is
    1. 27/16
    2. 2
    3. 27/8
    4. 5/16
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    d⟨H⟩/dζ=4ζ−274=0, so ζ=2716=1.6875. Each electron partly screens the nucleus from the other: 2−516.
  14. MCQStandard

    Which requirement must a variational trial function satisfy?
    1. It must solve the Schrödinger equation.
    2. It must be normalisable and obey the boundary conditions of the problem.
    3. It must have the exact energy.
    4. It must be an eigenfunction of the kinetic energy.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The bound ⟨H⟩≥E0 needs only that the trial state lies in the space where H acts: normalisable, with the right boundary conditions (for example zero at hard walls) and finite kinetic energy. It need not satisfy any equation; it can even have kinks.
  15. MCQStandard

    For the attractive delta potential −αδ(x), a Gaussian trial function gives the best energy −mα2/πℏ2, while the exact energy is −mα2/2ℏ2. The ratio of variational to exact energy is
    1. 1
    2. π/2
    3. 2/π≈0.64
    4. 1/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    −mα2/πℏ2−mα2/2ℏ2=2π=0.64. The variational energy is higher (less negative), as it must be. A Gaussian is smooth at the origin, while the true e−κ|x| has a cusp there, so the guess is poor.

    Why people get this wrong: Thinking a ratio below 1 means the bound is violated: both energies are negative, and −0.64|E0| lies above −|E0|.

  16. MSQStandard

    Which statements about the WKB wavefunction ψ≈Cp(x)exp⁡(±iℏ∫pdx) are correct?
    1. Its amplitude diverges at a classical turning point.
    2. |ψ|2∝1/p matches the classical time spent in each dx.
    3. In a forbidden region it becomes a real growing or decaying exponential.
    4. It is exact for every potential.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    At p=0 the formula blows up; the true solution is an Airy function there. Away from turning points |ψ|2∝1/p∝1/v, the classical dwell time. Where E<V, p=iℏκ and the phase becomes e±∫κdx. It is exact only in special cases such as constant V.
  17. MCQStandard

    In the WKB approximation, the probability density in a classically allowed region varies as
    1. p(x)
    2. p(x)2
    3. a constant
    4. 1/p(x)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Conservation of probability current with a slowly varying amplitude gives |A|2p= const, so |ψ|2∝1/p (averaged over the fast oscillations). A slow particle spends more time in a region, just as in classical mechanics.
  18. NATStandard

    A harmonic oscillator has ℏω=0.40 eV. Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) quantisation, which is exact here, gives the number of states with energy at or below 5.0 eV (measured from the bottom of the well) as ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 13

    ∮pdx=2πE/ω=(n+12)h gives En=(n+12)ℏω. We need (n+12)×0.40≤5.0, i.e. n≤12. With n=0,1,…,12 there are 13 states. (Each state takes up an area h of phase space.)

    Why people get this wrong: 5.0/0.40=12.5 suggests 12; counting must start from n=0 and include the zero-point offset.

  19. MCQStandard

    In Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) quantisation for a one-dimensional bound particle, the phase-space area enclosed between the orbits of two neighbouring levels is
    1. ℏ
    2. h
    3. h/2
    4. 2πh
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    ∮pdx=(n+γ)h, so neighbouring orbits differ by exactly h in enclosed area. Each quantum state "occupies" an area h of phase space, the rule used to count states in statistical mechanics.

    Why people get this wrong: Mixing h and ℏ; the area is 2πℏ=h.

  20. NATExam level

    For hydrogen, a Gaussian trial function e−βr2 gives the best energy −83π Ry. With 1 Ry =13.6 eV, this is ______ eV (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -11.54 (±0.02)

    ⟨T⟩=3ℏ2β2m and ⟨V⟩=−e24πϵ0⋅22βπ. Minimising gives −83π Ry =−0.849×13.6=−11.54 eV, 15% above the true −13.6 eV: the Gaussian has no cusp at the nucleus and falls off too fast.
  21. NATExam level

    For the harmonic oscillator, take the trial function e−α|x| and minimise ⟨H⟩ over α. The result is kℏω with k= ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.707 (±0.002)

    Normalised, |ψ|2=αe−2α|x|: ⟨T⟩=ℏ2α2/2m (the kink contributes no extra term when computed as ∫|ψ′|2), and ⟨x2⟩=1/2α2, so ⟨V⟩=mω2/4α2. E(α)=Aα2+B/α2 has minimum 2AB=2ℏ22m⋅mω24=ℏω/2=0.707ℏω, above the exact 0.5ℏω.
  22. NATExam level

    A particle of mass m bounces on a hard floor under gravity (V=mgz for z>0). WKB with one hard wall and one soft turning point gives En=cn(12mg2ℏ2)1/3. The value of c1 (ground state) is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.32 (±0.004)

    Hard wall plus soft turning point: ∫0z0pdz=(n−14)πℏ. With p=2m(E−mgz): ∫0z0pdz=22mE3/23mg. So En=[3π2(n−14)]2/3(12mg2ℏ2)1/3 and c1=(3.534)2/3=2.320. The exact value (first zero of the Airy function) is 2.338.
  23. MCQExam level

    The helium ground-state energy is about −79.0 eV. Which estimate does the screened variational trial function (ζ=27/16) give?
    1. −77.5 eV
    2. −74.8 eV
    3. −108.8 eV
    4. −81.2 eV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    E=−2ζ2×13.6=−2(1.6875)2×13.6=−77.5 eV, above the true value as required. −108.8 eV ignores the repulsion; −74.8 eV is first-order perturbation theory with ζ=2 (−108.8+34.0). Any value below −79.0 eV (such as −81.2) would violate the variational bound.
  24. NATExam level

    A trial state c1ϕ1+c2ϕ2 is built from two orthonormal functions with ⟨ϕi|H|ϕj⟩=(−20.50.51) eV. The best variational estimate of the ground-state energy is ______ eV (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -2.081 (±0.002)

    Minimising over c1,c2 (Rayleigh-Ritz) means finding the lowest eigenvalue of the matrix: −2+12−(1+22)2+0.52=−0.5−2.5=−2.081 eV. It lies below −2 eV (the best single function) and above the true E0.
  25. NATExam level

    For V=F|x|, WKB gives En=cn(ℏ2F22m)1/3. The ground-state coefficient c0 is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.116 (±0.003)

    Two soft turning points at ±E/F: ∫pdx=2∫0E/F2m(E−Fx)dx=42mE3/23F=(n+12)πℏ. So En=[3π4(n+12)]2/3(ℏ2F22m)1/3 and c0=(3π/8)2/3=1.116 (exact 1.019; WKB is worst for the ground state).
  26. MSQExam level

    A Gaussian trial function e−βr2 is used for the hydrogen ground state. Which statements are correct?
    1. The result is an upper bound on −13.6 eV.
    2. It misses the cusp of the true wavefunction at r=0.
    3. Its tail falls off faster than the true e−r/a0.
    4. With the best β it gives exactly −13.6 eV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    The best Gaussian gives −11.5 eV, above −13.6 eV. The true 1s function has a cusp (ψ′/ψ=−1/a0 at the nucleus) and a simple exponential tail; a Gaussian has neither, so no β reaches the exact energy.
  27. MCQExam level

    For a potential with V(−x)=V(x), a trial function that is odd in x gives an upper bound on
    1. the ground-state energy only
    2. the first excited energy
    3. the second excited energy
    4. nothing useful, because odd functions are not allowed
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The ground state of a symmetric 1D potential is even, so an odd trial function has c0=0 automatically, and ⟨H⟩≥E1. The first excited state is odd, so the bound can be tight. (For the oscillator, xe−βx2 gives 32ℏω exactly.)
  28. MCQExam level

    A one-parameter trial family gives ⟨H⟩(b)=Ab2+Bb2 with A,B>0. The variational estimate is
    1. A+B
    2. AB
    3. 2AB
    4. 4AB
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    d⟨H⟩/db=−2A/b3+2Bb=0 gives b4=A/B. Then ⟨H⟩=AB/A+BA/B=2AB. At the minimum the two terms are equal: the kinetic and potential energies share the total equally, as the virial theorem for V∝x2 requires.
  29. MCQExam level

    In the WKB estimate T≈exp⁡(−2∫κdx), doubling the width of a rectangular barrier (same height) changes the transmission from T to approximately
    1. T/2
    2. T/4
    3. 2T
    4. T2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The exponent doubles: e−4κL=(e−2κL)2=T2. For T=10−5 this means 10−10. Exponential sensitivity is why tunnelling currents in a scanning tunnelling microscope respond so strongly to distance.

    Why people get this wrong: Thinking of an Ohmic resistor; tunnelling is exponential in width, not linear.

  30. MCQExam level

    A "half oscillator" has V=12mω2x2 for x>0 and an infinite wall at x=0. WKB with one hard wall and one soft turning point gives the levels
    1. (2n+32)ℏω
    2. (n+12)ℏω
    3. (2n+12)ℏω
    4. (n+34)ℏω
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    ∫0x0pdx is half the full-oscillator integral, πE2ω. Setting it to (n+34)πℏ gives E=(2n+32)ℏω=32,72,… in units of ℏω: exactly the odd oscillator levels, which vanish at x=0 as the wall demands.

← All topics · Timed mock test →