Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling

The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling

Modern physics · 48 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. NATExam level

    An electron of energy 1.0 eV meets a rectangular barrier of height 5.0 eV and width 0.50 nm. Using T≈e−2κa with κ=2m(V0−E)/ℏ and ℏ2/(2me)=0.0381 eV nm2, the transmission probability is ______ ×10−5 (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3.55 $10^{-5}$ (±0.05)

    κ=(V0−E)/(ℏ2/2m)=4.0/0.0381=10.25 nm−1. 2κa=2(10.25)(0.50)=10.25. T≈e−10.25=3.55×10−5.

    Why people get this wrong: Using V0 instead of V0−E in κ. And the exponent has 2κa, because T is the square of the amplitude ratio.

  2. MCQExam level

    For a thick barrier (κa≫1) the transmission probability is T. If the barrier width is doubled (everything else the same), the transmission becomes about
    1. T/2
    2. T/4
    3. 2T
    4. T2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    T≈e−2κa (times a factor near 1). Doubling a gives e−4κa=(e−2κa)2=T2. If T was 10−5, it becomes about 10−10.

    Why people get this wrong: Tunnelling falls exponentially with width, not in proportion to it. This is why the scanning tunnelling microscope is so sensitive to height.

  3. MSQExam level

    A particle in an infinite well is in the state Ψ=12(ψ1e−iE1t/ℏ+ψ2e−iE2t/ℏ). Which statements are correct?
    1. The probability density oscillates in time with angular frequency (E2−E1)/ℏ.
    2. The expectation value of energy is (E1+E2)/2.
    3. A single energy measurement can give (E1+E2)/2.
    4. The state is not a stationary state.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    |Ψ|2=12[ψ12+ψ22+2ψ1ψ2cos⁡((E2−E1)t/ℏ)] (real ψ's): it sloshes at (E2−E1)/ℏ, so the state is not stationary. Each measurement gives E1 or E2, each with probability 12; the average is (E1+E2)/2, but that value itself never turns up.

    Why people get this wrong: The expectation value is an average over many measurements, not a possible result.

  4. NATExam level

    A particle in an infinite well is in the normalised state ψ=1/3ψ1+2/3ψ2. Its expectation value of energy, in units of the ground-state energy E1, is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3 $E_1$

    ⟨E⟩=|c1|2E1+|c2|2E2=13E1+23(4E1)=13E1+83E1=3E1.

    Why people get this wrong: Use the squares of the coefficients (probabilities), not the coefficients themselves.

  5. MCQExam level

    A particle moves in a potential symmetric about x=0, V(−x)=V(x), with bound states labelled from the ground state upwards. The third-lowest bound state is
    1. even
    2. odd
    3. neither even nor odd
    4. even or odd depending on the depth of the well
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    In a symmetric potential each non-degenerate bound state has definite parity, and they alternate starting with an even ground state (no nodes). Ground: even; second: odd (one node); third: even (two nodes).

    Why people get this wrong: Counting from n=0 or n=1 does not matter here: the third state up has two nodes and is even.

  6. MCQExam level

    A particle is in a bound stationary state whose wavefunction ψ(x) is real. Its expectation value of momentum is
    1. ℏk
    2. 2mE
    3. positive or negative depending on the state
    4. zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    ⟨p⟩=−iℏ∫ψψ′dx=−iℏ[ψ2/2]−∞∞=0 for a real, normalisable ψ. Physically, the particle is equally likely to move either way.

    Why people get this wrong: ⟨p⟩=0 does not mean ⟨p2⟩=0: the particle still has kinetic energy.

  7. MCQExam level

    For a particle in a cubic box, E=E0(nx2+ny2+nz2). How many different states have E=14E0?
    1. 3
    2. 1
    3. 6
    4. 4
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    14=1+4+9 only (check: 14 cannot be written with any other three positive squares). The numbers 1,2,3 can be given to x,y,z in 3!=6 orders, so the level is 6-fold degenerate.

    Why people get this wrong: When the three quantum numbers are all different there are 6 arrangements; with two equal, 3; all equal, 1.

  8. MSQExam level

    A particle of energy E meets a potential step of height V0>E (step from x=0 to infinity). Which statements are correct?
    1. The reflection coefficient is exactly 1.
    2. ψ is not zero just inside the step.
    3. The probability current inside the step is zero.
    4. Inside the step ψ oscillates with wave number 2m(V0−E)/ℏ.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Inside, ψ=Ce−κx: nonzero but decaying, not oscillating. A real exponential (times a constant phase) carries no current, j∝Im(ψ∗ψ′)=0. So nothing is transmitted to infinity and everything is reflected: R=1, even though the particle spends some time inside the step.

    Why people get this wrong: Penetrating the step is not the same as getting through it; for that you need a barrier of finite width.

  9. NATExam level

    An electron of energy E meets a step 0.50 eV higher than E. With ℏ2/(2me)=0.0381 eV nm2, the penetration depth 1/κ (where ψ falls to 1/e) is ______ nm (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.276 nm (±0.003)

    κ=(V0−E)/(ℏ2/2m)=0.50/0.0381=3.623 nm−1, so 1/κ=0.276 nm, about two atomic spacings.

    Why people get this wrong: The probability density |ψ|2 falls to 1/e in half that distance, 1/(2κ).

  10. NATExam level

    A beam of particles of energy E meets an upward step of height V0=34E. The fraction of the beam reflected is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.111 (±0.002)

    k1∝E, k2∝E−V0=E/4, so k2/k1=1/2. R=(k1−k2k1+k2)2=(1/23/2)2=19=0.111.

    Why people get this wrong: The transmission coefficient is not |C/A|2 but (k2/k1)|C/A|2; computing R first and using T=1−R avoids that slip.

  11. MCQExam level

    A particle moves in V(x)=12mω2x2 for x>0 with an impenetrable wall at x=0 (V=∞ for x≤0). Its ground-state energy is
    1. 12ℏω
    2. 32ℏω
    3. ℏω
    4. 14ℏω
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    For x>0 the Schrödinger equation is the oscillator's, and the wall demands ψ(0)=0. The oscillator states that vanish at the origin are the odd ones, n=1,3,5,…, so the allowed energies are 32ℏω,72ℏω,…, spaced by 2ℏω. The ground state is 32ℏω.

    Why people get this wrong: The full oscillator's ground state is even and nonzero at x=0, so the wall removes it.

  12. NATExam level

    An electron in an infinite well of width 1.0 nm is in the state (ψ1+ψ2)/2. Take h2/8me=0.376 eV nm2 and h=4.136×10−15 eV s. The period with which ⟨x⟩ oscillates is ______ fs (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3.67 fs (±0.02)

    ⟨x⟩ contains the cross term cos⁡[(E2−E1)t/ℏ], so the period is T=h/(E2−E1). E1=0.376 eV, E2=4E1=1.504 eV, difference 1.128 eV. T=4.136×10−15/1.128=3.67×10−15 s.

    Why people get this wrong: Using ℏ instead of h gives T/2π, the inverse angular frequency.

  13. MSQExam level

    A constant Vc is added to a potential V(x) everywhere. Which statements are correct?
    1. The energy eigenfunctions are unchanged.
    2. Every energy eigenvalue rises by Vc.
    3. For a superposition of two stationary states, |Ψ(x,t)|2 is the same at all times as before.
    4. The frequencies of photons emitted in transitions between levels change.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    [−ℏ22md2dx2+V+Vc]ψ=(E+Vc)ψ has the same solutions with every E raised by Vc. Each time factor gains the same phase e−iVct/ℏ, an overall phase that cancels in |Ψ|2. Transition frequencies depend on differences Em−En, which do not change.

    Why people get this wrong: Only energy differences are physical; a common shift changes nothing measurable.

  14. NATHard

    An electron is in a finite square well of width 1.0 nm and depth 3.0 eV. With ℏ2/(2me)=0.0381 eV nm2, the number of bound states is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    Define z0=(a/2)2mV0/ℏ=0.53.0/0.0381=0.5×8.87=4.44. The even and odd solutions appear one after another each time z0 passes a multiple of π/2, with the first (even) one always present. Number of bound states =1+⌊z0/(π/2)⌋=1+⌊2.83⌋=3.

    Why people get this wrong: Using the full width a in place of a/2 in z0 doubles the count.

  15. NATHard

    For the ground state of an infinite well from 0 to L, ⟨x2⟩=L2(13−12π2). The position uncertainty Δx is ______ L (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.181 $L$ (±0.002)

    ⟨x⟩=L/2. Δx2=⟨x2⟩−⟨x⟩2=L2(0.33333−0.05066−0.25)=0.03267L2. Δx=0.181L. (With Δp=πℏ/L this gives ΔxΔp=0.568ℏ>ℏ/2, as it must.)

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting to subtract ⟨x⟩2=L2/4.

  16. NATHard

    In the ground state of a harmonic oscillator, |ψ0|2∝e−x2/x02, where x=±x0 are the classical turning points at energy 12ℏω. The probability of finding the particle outside the classically allowed region is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.157 (±0.002)

    With u=x/x0, P(|x|>x0)=∫|u|>1e−u2du∫e−u2du=1−erf(1)=1−0.8427=0.157. (Check the turning point: 12mω2x02=12ℏω gives x02=ℏ/mω, and ψ0∝e−mωx2/2ℏ, so |ψ0|2∝e−x2/x02.)

    Why people get this wrong: Almost 16% of the time the particle is where classical physics says it can never be.

  17. MCQHard

    A particle of mass m moves in the attractive potential V(x)=−αδ(x) with α>0. Its bound states are
    1. infinitely many, with En∝−1/n2
    2. exactly one, with E=−mα2/(2ℏ2)
    3. exactly two, one even and one odd
    4. none, because the well has zero width
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Outside x=0, ψ=Ae−κ|x|. Integrating the Schrödinger equation across the origin gives a jump in slope: Δψ′=−(2mα/ℏ2)ψ(0), i.e. −2κ=−2mα/ℏ2, so κ=mα/ℏ2 and E=−ℏ2κ2/2m=−mα2/2ℏ2. An odd state would vanish at the origin, feel no delta function, and so cannot be bound. Exactly one bound state.

    Why people get this wrong: In one dimension any attractive well, however thin, binds at least one state.

  18. MSQHard

    Which statements are correct for a particle with Hamiltonian H=p2/2m+V(x), with V not depending on time?
    1. [x,p]=iℏ.
    2. ⟨H⟩ does not change with time for any state.
    3. d⟨x⟩/dt=⟨p⟩/m.
    4. In a stationary state ⟨x⟩ oscillates at angular frequency E/ℏ.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    First: canonical commutator. Second: d⟨A⟩/dt=(i/ℏ)⟨[H,A]⟩ and [H,H]=0. Third: [H,x]=−iℏp/m, giving d⟨x⟩/dt=⟨p⟩/m (Ehrenfest). Fourth: false; in a stationary state every such expectation value is constant.

    Why people get this wrong: Only superpositions of different energies make expectation values move.

  19. MCQHard

    Particles of energy E=2V0 meet an upward step of height V0. The transmission coefficient is closest to
    1. 0.50
    2. 0.71
    3. 0.97
    4. 0.03
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    k2/k1=(E−V0)/E=1/2=0.707. T=4k1k2/(k1+k2)2=4(0.707)/(1.707)2=2.828/2.914=0.971. Equivalently R=(0.293/1.707)2=0.029 and T=1−R.

    Why people get this wrong: 0.71 is k2/k1 and 0.50 is (k2/k1)2; neither is the transmission coefficient.

  20. MCQHard

    For an infinite square well, the fractional gap (En+1−En)/En for large n
    1. falls like 2/n, so the levels look continuous at high energy
    2. tends to 1
    3. grows like n
    4. stays at 3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    (En+1−En)/En=[(n+1)2−n2]/n2=(2n+1)/n2≈2/n. The absolute gap grows, but compared with the energy itself it shrinks, so at high n the levels merge into the classical continuum (Bohr's correspondence principle).

    Why people get this wrong: The gap En+1−En itself grows with n; the question asks about the ratio.

  21. MCQHard

    An electron and a proton with the same energy E meet the same rectangular barrier (V0>E, width a, with κa≫1 for both). Compared with the electron, the proton's transmission probability is
    1. the same, because only E and V0 matter
    2. larger, because the proton is heavier
    3. larger by a factor mp/me
    4. far smaller, by roughly the factor e−2κea(mp/me−1)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    κ=2m(V0−E)/ℏ∝m. So κp=43κe and Tp/Te≈e−2a(κp−κe)=e−2κea(mp/me−1), which is tiny. Heavier particles tunnel far less.

    Why people get this wrong: Mass enters through κ, inside the exponential, so it has a huge effect.

  22. NATHard

    An electron is bound by the potential V=−αδ(x) with α=0.10 eV nm. Using E=−mα2/(2ℏ2) and ℏ2/(2me)=0.0381 eV nm2, its binding energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 65.6 meV (±0.3)

    Rewrite with the given constant: mα2/(2ℏ2)=α2/(4⋅ℏ2/2m)=0.010/(4×0.0381)=0.0656 eV =65.6 meV.

    Why people get this wrong: m/(2ℏ2)=1/(4⋅ℏ2/2m): the factor 4 is easy to get wrong.

  23. MCQHard

    A small delta-function bump λδ(x−L/2) is added at the centre of an infinite square well 0<x<L. Which energy levels change?
    1. All of them, by the same amount
    2. Only the levels with even n (n=2,4,…)
    3. Only the levels with odd n (n=1,3,…)
    4. None, since a delta function has zero width
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The states are ψn=2/Lsin⁡(nπx/L). At the centre sin⁡(nπ/2) is zero for even n, so those states have a node there and simply do not feel the bump (they stay exact solutions). Odd-n states have an antinode there and are pushed up (to first order by 2λ/L).

    Why people get this wrong: Thinking a zero-width potential has no effect; its strength λ (energy times length) matters wherever ψ≠0.

  24. MCQHard

    A particle in an infinite well (ground-state energy E1) is in the state (ψ1+ψ3)/2 at t=0. Its probability density first returns to its starting shape after a time
    1. h8E1
    2. h2E1
    3. hE1
    4. ℏ8E1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    |Ψ|2=12[ψ12+ψ32+2ψ1ψ3cos⁡((E3−E1)t/ℏ)]. With E3=9E1, the cross term repeats when (8E1/ℏ)t=2π, i.e. t=2πℏ8E1=h8E1.

    Why people get this wrong: Using ℏ instead of h (missing 2π), or the period of one state's phase alone, which does not show in |Ψ|2.

  25. MCQHard

    A particle of energy E passes over a rectangular barrier of height V0<E and width a. The transmission is exactly 1 when
    1. E=2V0
    2. a is a whole number of half-wavelengths of the wave inside the barrier
    3. a is an odd number of quarter-wavelengths of the wave inside the barrier
    4. never, since some reflection always happens at a step
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Inside the barrier k2=2m(E−V0)/ℏ, and the exact result is T−1=1+V02sin2⁡(k2a)4E(E−V0). T=1 when sin⁡k2a=0, i.e. k2a=nπ, a=nλ2/2. The waves reflected at the two edges then cancel (the same idea as an anti-reflection condition, here a transmission resonance).

    Why people get this wrong: Saying a step always reflects; two steps can cancel each other's reflections exactly.

  26. MSQHard

    For bound states of a particle in one dimension with a potential V(x) that is finite except possibly at walls, which statements are correct?
    1. A bound-state wavefunction must be complex and carry a non-zero probability current.
    2. Bound-state energies are non-degenerate.
    3. The n-th bound state (counting the ground state as n=1) has n−1 nodes.
    4. Every bound-state energy lies above the minimum value of V.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B, C, D

    B: two bound solutions with the same E would have a constant Wronskian, which vanishes at infinity, so they are proportional. C is the node theorem. D: ⟨H⟩=⟨T⟩+⟨V⟩ with ⟨T⟩>0 and ⟨V⟩≥Vmin⁡. A is false: bound-state wavefunctions can always be chosen real, and then the current ℏmIm(ψ∗ψ′) is zero.

    Why people get this wrong: Thinking complex numbers are needed for every wavefunction; they appear in time dependence and travelling waves.

  27. NATHard

    Particles of kinetic energy E move towards a downward potential step of depth V0=3E (the potential energy drops by 3E, so they speed up). The fraction reflected is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.111 (±0.002)

    Before the step k1=2mE/ℏ; after it k2=2m(E+3E)/ℏ=2k1. Matching ψ and ψ′ gives R=(k1−k2k1+k2)2=(1−23)2=19=0.111. Classically nothing would come back; quantum waves reflect from any sudden change, up or down.

    Why people get this wrong: Answering zero because the particles are speeding up.

  28. MCQHard

    An electron is in a finite square well of depth 10 eV and width 1.0 nm. With ℏ2/2me=0.0381 eV nm2, the number of bound states is
    1. 5
    2. 7
    3. 16
    4. 6
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Write z0=a22meV0ℏ2=0.5×10/0.0381=0.5×16.20=8.10. Bound states alternate even/odd and a new one appears each time z0 passes a multiple of π/2, so their number is the smallest integer above 2z0/π=5.16: six bound states (three even, three odd).

    Why people get this wrong: 16 is 2z0, with no division by π; and rounding 5.16 down forgets the ground state, which always exists.

  29. MCQHard

    A particle of mass m moves in V=∞ for x<0, V=0 for 0<x<a and V=V0 for x>a. It has at least one bound state only if
    1. V0>0, whatever its size
    2. V0>π2ℏ2/2ma2
    3. V0>π2ℏ2/8ma2
    4. V0>ℏ2/2ma2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The wall forces ψ(0)=0, so the solutions are exactly the odd states of a symmetric well of width 2a and depth V0. The first odd state needs z0=a2mV0/ℏ>π/2, i.e. V0>π2ℏ2/8ma2. Unlike the symmetric 1D well, a too-shallow step binds nothing. This is the same condition as for an s-wave bound state in a 3D spherical well of radius a.

    Why people get this wrong: "Any attractive well binds in 1D" holds for symmetric wells without a wall; the wall kills the even ground state.

  30. NATHard

    Electrons of energy 1.0 eV meet a thin barrier modelled as V(x)=αδ(x) with α=0.10 eV nm. The transmission probability is T=[1+mα22ℏ2E]−1. With ℏ2/2me=0.0381 eV nm2, T is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.938 (±0.003)

    mα22ℏ2E=α24(ℏ2/2m)E=0.014×0.0381×1.0=0.0656. So T=1/1.0656=0.938. The barrier is "transparent" at high energy (T→1 as E→∞) and reflects nearly everything at low energy.

    Why people get this wrong: Rewriting m/2ℏ2 as 1/(4⋅ℏ2/2m), not 1/(ℏ2/2m): a factor of 4 is easy to lose.

← All topics · Timed mock test →