The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling
Modern physics · 48 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATExam level
An electron of energy eV meets a rectangular barrier of height eV and width nm. Using with and eV nm, the transmission probability is ______ (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 3.55 $10^{-5}$ (±0.05)
nm. . .Why people get this wrong: Using instead of in . And the exponent has , because is the square of the amplitude ratio.
-
MCQExam level
For a thick barrier () the transmission probability is . If the barrier width is doubled (everything else the same), the transmission becomes aboutAnswer and solution
Answer: D
(times a factor near 1). Doubling gives . If was , it becomes about .Why people get this wrong: Tunnelling falls exponentially with width, not in proportion to it. This is why the scanning tunnelling microscope is so sensitive to height.
-
MSQExam level
A particle in an infinite well is in the state . Which statements are correct?- The probability density oscillates in time with angular frequency .
- The expectation value of energy is .
- A single energy measurement can give .
- The state is not a stationary state.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
(real 's): it sloshes at , so the state is not stationary. Each measurement gives or , each with probability ; the average is , but that value itself never turns up.Why people get this wrong: The expectation value is an average over many measurements, not a possible result.
-
NATExam level
A particle in an infinite well is in the normalised state . Its expectation value of energy, in units of the ground-state energy , is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 3 $E_1$
.Why people get this wrong: Use the squares of the coefficients (probabilities), not the coefficients themselves.
-
MCQExam level
A particle moves in a potential symmetric about , , with bound states labelled from the ground state upwards. The third-lowest bound state is- even
- odd
- neither even nor odd
- even or odd depending on the depth of the well
Answer and solution
Answer: A
In a symmetric potential each non-degenerate bound state has definite parity, and they alternate starting with an even ground state (no nodes). Ground: even; second: odd (one node); third: even (two nodes).Why people get this wrong: Counting from or does not matter here: the third state up has two nodes and is even.
-
MCQExam level
A particle is in a bound stationary state whose wavefunction is real. Its expectation value of momentum is- positive or negative depending on the state
- zero
Answer and solution
Answer: D
for a real, normalisable . Physically, the particle is equally likely to move either way.Why people get this wrong: does not mean : the particle still has kinetic energy.
-
MCQExam level
For a particle in a cubic box, . How many different states have ?Answer and solution
Answer: C
only (check: cannot be written with any other three positive squares). The numbers can be given to in orders, so the level is 6-fold degenerate.Why people get this wrong: When the three quantum numbers are all different there are 6 arrangements; with two equal, 3; all equal, 1.
-
MSQExam level
A particle of energy meets a potential step of height (step from to infinity). Which statements are correct?- The reflection coefficient is exactly 1.
- is not zero just inside the step.
- The probability current inside the step is zero.
- Inside the step oscillates with wave number .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Inside, : nonzero but decaying, not oscillating. A real exponential (times a constant phase) carries no current, . So nothing is transmitted to infinity and everything is reflected: , even though the particle spends some time inside the step.Why people get this wrong: Penetrating the step is not the same as getting through it; for that you need a barrier of finite width.
-
NATExam level
An electron of energy meets a step eV higher than . With eV nm, the penetration depth (where falls to ) is ______ nm (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.276 nm (±0.003)
nm, so nm, about two atomic spacings.Why people get this wrong: The probability density falls to in half that distance, .
-
NATExam level
A beam of particles of energy meets an upward step of height . The fraction of the beam reflected is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.111 (±0.002)
, , so . .Why people get this wrong: The transmission coefficient is not but ; computing first and using avoids that slip.
-
MCQExam level
A particle moves in for with an impenetrable wall at ( for ). Its ground-state energy isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
For the Schrödinger equation is the oscillator's, and the wall demands . The oscillator states that vanish at the origin are the odd ones, , so the allowed energies are , spaced by . The ground state is .Why people get this wrong: The full oscillator's ground state is even and nonzero at , so the wall removes it.
-
NATExam level
An electron in an infinite well of width nm is in the state . Take eV nm and eV s. The period with which oscillates is ______ fs (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 3.67 fs (±0.02)
contains the cross term , so the period is . eV, eV, difference eV. s.Why people get this wrong: Using instead of gives , the inverse angular frequency.
-
MSQExam level
A constant is added to a potential everywhere. Which statements are correct?- The energy eigenfunctions are unchanged.
- Every energy eigenvalue rises by .
- For a superposition of two stationary states, is the same at all times as before.
- The frequencies of photons emitted in transitions between levels change.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
has the same solutions with every raised by . Each time factor gains the same phase , an overall phase that cancels in . Transition frequencies depend on differences , which do not change.Why people get this wrong: Only energy differences are physical; a common shift changes nothing measurable.
-
NATHard
An electron is in a finite square well of width nm and depth eV. With eV nm, the number of bound states is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 3
Define . The even and odd solutions appear one after another each time passes a multiple of , with the first (even) one always present. Number of bound states .Why people get this wrong: Using the full width in place of in doubles the count.
-
NATHard
For the ground state of an infinite well from to , . The position uncertainty is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.181 $L$ (±0.002)
. . . (With this gives , as it must.)Why people get this wrong: Forgetting to subtract .
-
NATHard
In the ground state of a harmonic oscillator, , where are the classical turning points at energy . The probability of finding the particle outside the classically allowed region is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.157 (±0.002)
With , . (Check the turning point: gives , and , so .)Why people get this wrong: Almost 16% of the time the particle is where classical physics says it can never be.
-
MCQHard
A particle of mass moves in the attractive potential with . Its bound states are- infinitely many, with
- exactly one, with
- exactly two, one even and one odd
- none, because the well has zero width
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Outside , . Integrating the Schrödinger equation across the origin gives a jump in slope: , i.e. , so and . An odd state would vanish at the origin, feel no delta function, and so cannot be bound. Exactly one bound state.Why people get this wrong: In one dimension any attractive well, however thin, binds at least one state.
-
MSQHard
Which statements are correct for a particle with Hamiltonian , with not depending on time?- .
- does not change with time for any state.
- .
- In a stationary state oscillates at angular frequency .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
First: canonical commutator. Second: and . Third: , giving (Ehrenfest). Fourth: false; in a stationary state every such expectation value is constant.Why people get this wrong: Only superpositions of different energies make expectation values move.
-
MCQHard
Particles of energy meet an upward step of height . The transmission coefficient is closest toAnswer and solution
Answer: C
. . Equivalently and .Why people get this wrong: is and is ; neither is the transmission coefficient.
-
MCQHard
For an infinite square well, the fractional gap for large- falls like , so the levels look continuous at high energy
- tends to
- grows like
- stays at
Answer and solution
Answer: A
. The absolute gap grows, but compared with the energy itself it shrinks, so at high the levels merge into the classical continuum (Bohr's correspondence principle).Why people get this wrong: The gap itself grows with ; the question asks about the ratio.
-
MCQHard
An electron and a proton with the same energy meet the same rectangular barrier (, width , with for both). Compared with the electron, the proton's transmission probability is- the same, because only and matter
- larger, because the proton is heavier
- larger by a factor
- far smaller, by roughly the factor
Answer and solution
Answer: D
. So and , which is tiny. Heavier particles tunnel far less.Why people get this wrong: Mass enters through , inside the exponential, so it has a huge effect.
-
NATHard
An electron is bound by the potential with eV nm. Using and eV nm, its binding energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 65.6 meV (±0.3)
Rewrite with the given constant: eV meV.Why people get this wrong: : the factor 4 is easy to get wrong.
-
MCQHard
A small delta-function bump is added at the centre of an infinite square well . Which energy levels change?- All of them, by the same amount
- Only the levels with even ()
- Only the levels with odd ()
- None, since a delta function has zero width
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The states are . At the centre is zero for even , so those states have a node there and simply do not feel the bump (they stay exact solutions). Odd- states have an antinode there and are pushed up (to first order by ).Why people get this wrong: Thinking a zero-width potential has no effect; its strength (energy times length) matters wherever .
-
MCQHard
A particle in an infinite well (ground-state energy ) is in the state at . Its probability density first returns to its starting shape after a timeAnswer and solution
Answer: A
. With , the cross term repeats when , i.e. .Why people get this wrong: Using instead of (missing ), or the period of one state's phase alone, which does not show in .
-
MCQHard
A particle of energy passes over a rectangular barrier of height and width . The transmission is exactly 1 when- is a whole number of half-wavelengths of the wave inside the barrier
- is an odd number of quarter-wavelengths of the wave inside the barrier
- never, since some reflection always happens at a step
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Inside the barrier , and the exact result is . when , i.e. , . The waves reflected at the two edges then cancel (the same idea as an anti-reflection condition, here a transmission resonance).Why people get this wrong: Saying a step always reflects; two steps can cancel each other's reflections exactly.
-
MSQHard
For bound states of a particle in one dimension with a potential that is finite except possibly at walls, which statements are correct?- A bound-state wavefunction must be complex and carry a non-zero probability current.
- Bound-state energies are non-degenerate.
- The -th bound state (counting the ground state as ) has nodes.
- Every bound-state energy lies above the minimum value of .
Answer and solution
Answer: B, C, D
B: two bound solutions with the same would have a constant Wronskian, which vanishes at infinity, so they are proportional. C is the node theorem. D: with and . A is false: bound-state wavefunctions can always be chosen real, and then the current is zero.Why people get this wrong: Thinking complex numbers are needed for every wavefunction; they appear in time dependence and travelling waves.
-
NATHard
Particles of kinetic energy move towards a downward potential step of depth (the potential energy drops by , so they speed up). The fraction reflected is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.111 (±0.002)
Before the step ; after it . Matching and gives . Classically nothing would come back; quantum waves reflect from any sudden change, up or down.Why people get this wrong: Answering zero because the particles are speeding up.
-
MCQHard
An electron is in a finite square well of depth eV and width nm. With eV nm, the number of bound states isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
Write . Bound states alternate even/odd and a new one appears each time passes a multiple of , so their number is the smallest integer above : six bound states (three even, three odd).Why people get this wrong: is , with no division by ; and rounding down forgets the ground state, which always exists.
-
MCQHard
A particle of mass moves in for , for and for . It has at least one bound state only if- , whatever its size
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The wall forces , so the solutions are exactly the odd states of a symmetric well of width and depth . The first odd state needs , i.e. . Unlike the symmetric 1D well, a too-shallow step binds nothing. This is the same condition as for an -wave bound state in a 3D spherical well of radius .Why people get this wrong: "Any attractive well binds in 1D" holds for symmetric wells without a wall; the wall kills the even ground state.
-
NATHard
Electrons of energy eV meet a thin barrier modelled as with eV nm. The transmission probability is . With eV nm, is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.938 (±0.003)
. So . The barrier is "transparent" at high energy ( as ) and reflects nearly everything at low energy.Why people get this wrong: Rewriting as , not : a factor of 4 is easy to lose.