Photons: the photoelectric and Compton effects
Modern physics · 32 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATWarm-up
Using J s, kg and m/s, the Compton wavelength of the electron, , is ______ pm (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.42 pm (±0.02)
m pm. (With the exact constants it is pm.)Why people get this wrong: This is not the wavelength of any electron; it is a length scale that sets the size of the Compton shift.
-
MSQStandard
For Compton scattering of photons by free electrons at rest, which statements are correct?- The shift does not depend on the incident wavelength.
- The shift is largest for photons scattered straight back ().
- At the same angle, the shift for scattering from free protons is larger than from electrons.
- There is no shift for photons that carry on forward ().
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
. It contains only and the target mass, not : first true. is largest () at : second true. A proton is times heavier, so and the shift are times smaller: third false. At the factor is : fourth true.Why people get this wrong: The shift is the same for all wavelengths, but the fractional shift is large only for short (X-ray, gamma) wavelengths.
-
NATStandard
X-rays of wavelength pm are scattered by free electrons. Take pm. The wavelength of the X-rays scattered at is ______ pm (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 11.213 pm (±0.003)
pm. So pm.Why people get this wrong: Using or alone in place of .
-
NATExam level
A keV gamma photon is scattered straight back () by a free electron at rest. With keV, the kinetic energy given to the electron is ______ keV (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 28.1 keV (±0.1)
Compton formula in energy form: keV. Energy conservation: the electron gets keV.Why people get this wrong: The photon does not hand over all its energy even when it bounces straight back; a free electron cannot absorb a photon completely.
-
MCQExam level
A photon whose energy equals the electron rest energy, keV, is Compton-scattered through by a free electron at rest. The scattered photon's energy is- keV
- keV
- keV
- keV
Answer and solution
Answer: D
keV, so about keV: exactly half.Why people get this wrong: keV () is the back-scattered energy at .
-
MCQExam level
At what scattering angle is the Compton shift of photons scattered by free electrons equal to half the electron's Compton wavelength?Answer and solution
Answer: A
gives , so .Why people get this wrong: Setting is right; setting (giving ) is the usual slip.
-
MSQExam level
In Compton scattering of a photon by a free electron initially at rest, which statements are correct?- Total relativistic energy is conserved.
- Total momentum is conserved.
- For every scattering angle the scattered photon has a longer wavelength.
- A free electron can absorb the photon completely if the photon has enough energy.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
It is an elastic collision of two particles, so energy and momentum are both conserved. The electron recoils and takes some energy for any , so the photon leaves with less energy and longer wavelength. Complete absorption by a free electron is impossible at any energy: in the frame where the final electron is at rest it would have to turn a photon (energy and momentum) into rest energy alone with zero momentum, which conservation forbids.Why people get this wrong: In the photoelectric effect the electron is bound, and the rest of the metal takes up the momentum. That is why absorption works there.
-
MCQExam level
An X-ray photon is Compton-scattered through by a free electron at rest and then through again by a second free electron. Another photon of the same starting wavelength is scattered once through . Comparing the final wavelengths,- the two scatterings give the larger shift
- the single scattering gives the larger shift
- which one is larger depends on the starting wavelength
- both photons end with the same wavelength
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The Compton shift does not depend on the wavelength before scattering. Two scatterings give ; one scattering gives . The final wavelengths are equal for any starting wavelength.Why people get this wrong: Shifts in wavelength simply add; it is the energies that change in a way that depends on the starting value.
-
NATExam level
X-rays of wavelength pm are scattered through by free electrons at rest. With pm and keV pm, the kinetic energy of a recoil electron is ______ keV (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 6.71 keV (±0.03)
At the shift is pm, so pm. Energy conservation gives the electron the difference: keV.Why people get this wrong: Using gives the energy of a photon of wavelength pm (511 keV), not the energy difference.
-
NATExam level
Sunlight of intensity W/m falls on a flat, perfectly reflecting sail at to the sail's normal. With m/s, the radiation pressure on the sail (force per unit area of sail, along the normal) is ______ Pa (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.27 μPa (±0.02)
Two factors of appear. First, a sail area intercepts only the beam area , so the photon momentum arriving per second is . Second, reflection reverses only the normal part of each photon's momentum, a change of . So Pa.Why people get this wrong: Keeping only one factor of gives Pa.
-
NATHard
A photon of energy keV () is scattered through by a free electron at rest. The recoiling electron moves at an angle to the incident photon direction, on the other side. Find in degrees (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 26.6 degrees (±0.2)
Scattered energy keV (pho-022). Momentum along the beam: . Across: . Divide: , so . (The general result is , which gives .)Why people get this wrong: The electron does not go off at to the photon; it is always thrown forward, at less than to the incident beam.
-
NATHard
Gamma rays of energy keV fall on a detector. Taking keV, the largest kinetic energy a Compton-scattered electron can receive (the Compton edge) is ______ keV (to the nearest keV).Answer and solution
Answer: 796 keV (±1.5)
The electron gets the most when the photon is back-scattered (): keV. So , about keV. Formula: with .Why people get this wrong: The edge is not at the full photon energy; that peak (the photopeak) comes from photoelectric absorption.
-
MSQHard
Monochromatic X-rays are scattered by a block of carbon and the scattered spectrum is examined at a fixed angle . Two peaks are seen. Which statements are correct?- The unshifted peak comes from scattering by tightly bound electrons, where in effect the whole atom recoils.
- The position of the shifted peak depends on which element the block is made of.
- The separation of the two peaks grows as increases from to .
- For a block of a light element the shifted peak is relatively stronger than for a heavy element.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C, D
First: if the electron is held firmly, the recoiling mass is the whole atom, thousands of times heavier, so its shift is negligible. Second: false; the shifted peak sits at , the same for any element (loosely bound electrons act as free). Third: true, rises from to . Fourth: true; a light atom has a larger share of loosely bound electrons, so more scattering is shifted.Why people get this wrong: The shift depends on the target mass, and for the unshifted line the target is the whole atom.
-
MCQHard
A photon of wavelength pm is Compton-scattered by a free electron through ; the scattered photon then hits a second free electron and is scattered through a further . Taking pm, its final wavelength is closest to- pm
- pm
- pm
- pm
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Each scattering adds its own shift, whatever the wavelength before it. First: pm. Second: pm. Total pm, so pm.Why people get this wrong: Adding the angles () happens to give the same total here (), but only because . In general you must add the shifts.
-
MCQHard
A photon cannot be completely absorbed by a free electron at rest (the photoelectric effect needs a bound electron). The reason is that- the electron's charge is too small to couple to the photon
- energy and momentum cannot both be conserved in such an absorption
- the photon's spin cannot be absorbed by the electron
- a free electron has no work function to overcome
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Suppose photon () + electron at rest → electron alone. Momentum: the electron ends with . Energy: . Squaring: , so . No real photon can do it. In an atom the nucleus takes up the spare momentum.Why people get this wrong: Thinking the work function is the issue; without a third body the process is forbidden by kinematics alone.
-
MCQHard
An atom of mass at rest drops from an excited state to its ground state, the two levels being apart (). The emitted photon has energy close to- exactly
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Momentum conservation: the atom recoils with momentum and kinetic energy . Energy: , so . For nuclear gamma rays this recoil shift exceeds the line width, which is why resonant absorption needs the Mössbauer effect (a recoil-free crystal).Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the recoil (exactly ), or giving the photon more energy than the transition.
-
MSQHard
For Compton scattering by free electrons at rest, . Which statements are correct?- The shift is larger for heavier target particles.
- The shift does not depend on the incident wavelength.
- The fractional shift is larger for shorter incident wavelengths.
- The largest possible shift is , at .
Answer and solution
Answer: B, C, D
B, D follow straight from the formula: it has no in it, and is at most 2. C: the same is a bigger fraction of a small , which is why X-rays and gamma rays show it and light does not. A is false: is smaller for heavier targets.Why people get this wrong: Thinking a heavier target gives a bigger kick and so a bigger shift; heavier targets recoil less.
-
MCQHard
In a photocell the emitter has work function eV and the collector, a different metal, has work function eV. Light of photon energy eV falls on the emitter. The retarding voltage that must be applied between the two terminals to stop the current just is- V
- V
- V
- V
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The fastest electrons leave the emitter with eV. But when the two metals are wired together their Fermi levels line up, and the vacuum level just outside the collector is eV above that outside the emitter (the contact potential). An electron therefore already climbs eV with no applied voltage, and the applied voltage only has to supply the remaining eV. In general : the measured stopping voltage depends on the collector's work function, not the emitter's.Why people get this wrong: eV is the electrons' energy, but the contact potential between unlike metals does part of the stopping.
-
NATHard
A keV gamma photon is back-scattered () by a free electron at rest, then the scattered photon is back-scattered by another free electron, and so on. With keV, the smallest number of back-scatterings after which its energy is below keV is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 5
For one scattering, , so each back-scattering adds keV to . After of them, . We need : , so . Check: gives keV, gives keV. Answer: .Why people get this wrong: Working with energies directly instead of their reciprocals: it is that rises by a fixed step.
-
NATTop rank
A photon of energy keV () is Compton-scattered by a free electron at rest. At what scattering angle does the scattered photon carry exactly as much energy as the recoiling electron? Answer in degrees.Answer and solution
Answer: 60 degrees (±0.5)
Equal shares means . With : requires , so and .Why people get this wrong: For a keV photon the same condition gives ; the answer depends on the photon energy.
-
MSQTop rank
Which statements are correct?- A free electron at rest cannot absorb a photon completely, because energy and momentum cannot both be conserved.
- In the photoelectric effect the leftover momentum is taken up by the rest of the metal (the lattice).
- The Compton formula follows from photon momentum together with relativistic energy and momentum conservation.
- A classical electromagnetic wave scattered by a free charge (Thomson scattering) shows the same angle-dependent wavelength shift.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
First: if the electron absorbed the photon, with ; squaring gives , impossible. Second: true, which is why only bound electrons show the photoelectric effect. Third: true, that is exactly Compton's derivation. Fourth: false; in Thomson scattering the charge oscillates at the wave's frequency and re-radiates at that same frequency: no shift.Why people get this wrong: The shift is a quantum (particle) effect; the classical limit of Compton scattering is unshifted Thomson scattering.
-
NATTop rank
An ultra-relativistic electron with Lorentz factor meets a eV laser photon head-on, and the photon is scattered straight back along the electron's direction. In the limit where (so the electron's recoil in its own rest frame can be neglected), the scattered photon's energy in the laboratory is about ______ MeV.Answer and solution
Answer: 8 MeV (±0.2)
Go to the electron's rest frame: the photon is blue-shifted to about (head-on Doppler factor ). Since keV is far below keV, it scatters back with nearly the same energy. Transforming back to the lab gives another factor . Total eV MeV. (Keeping the recoil gives MeV.)Why people get this wrong: Using one Doppler factor of instead of two factors of . This is how lasers and electron beams make gamma rays.
-
MCQTop rank
In Compton scattering, as the photon scattering angle goes from to , the angle between the recoil electron and the incident beam- goes from down to
- goes from up to
- stays at
- goes from up to
Answer and solution
Answer: A
. At , , so and (a grazing photon gives the electron a tiny sideways kick). At , , so : head-on. The electron never moves backwards.Why people get this wrong: The photon and electron go to opposite sides; when the photon goes straight back the electron goes straight forward.
-
NATTop rank
Photons of a single energy are scattered by free electrons, and the back-scattered photons () are found to have energy keV, while those at have keV. Using only these two readings (not the known value of ), find in keV (to the nearest keV).Answer and solution
Answer: 510 keV (±2)
Write . At : . At : . Subtract: , so and keV. The same subtraction gives keV, a check on the data: the true value is keV, so the photons had .Why people get this wrong: Work with reciprocals of energy: is linear in , energies themselves are not.
-
MCQTop rank
A photon produces an electron-positron pair in the field of a free electron at rest (the target electron recoils; three particles leave). The threshold photon energy is ( MeV)- MeV
- MeV
- MeV
- MeV
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Use the invariant . Initially: . At threshold the three final particles move together with total rest energy , so . Then , MeV. Near a heavy nucleus, which takes momentum but almost no energy, the threshold is close to .Why people get this wrong: Answering (the rest energy of the pair); a light target must also be given kinetic energy to conserve momentum.
-
NATTop rank
An ideal photon rocket starts from rest and pushes itself by emitting light straight backwards, turning rest mass into the light's energy. When it reaches speed , the ratio of its initial rest mass to its final rest mass is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.732 (±0.003)
Let the emitted light carry total energy and momentum backwards. Energy: . Momentum: . Eliminating : , so . For : . (The result holds for any number of emissions along the way, since each step gives the same relation.)Why people get this wrong: Using the non-relativistic rocket equation with exhaust speed , .
-
MCQTop rank
Light of frequency falls normally on a mirror that is moving straight away from the source at a small speed . Treating the reflection as photons bouncing elastically off a heavy mirror, the frequency of the reflected light is, to first order in ,- , since the mirror is much heavier than a photon
Answer and solution
Answer: A
In the mirror's frame the photon bounces back with unchanged energy. Going back to the lab frame, the reflected photon loses energy: its momentum change is , and the mirror moving at takes work per photon. So , giving . The exact result is , the Doppler shift applied twice. The mirror's mass is irrelevant: what matters is that it moves.Why people get this wrong: A heavy mirror at rest returns the same frequency, but a moving one does work on (or receives work from) each photon.