Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / Phase changes and the Clausius-Clapeyron equation

Phase changes and the Clausius-Clapeyron equation

Kinetic theory and thermodynamics · 29 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQStandard

    In Ehrenfest's classification, a second-order phase transition is one in which
    1. the entropy and volume are continuous but the heat capacity jumps
    2. there is a latent heat but no volume change
    3. the Gibbs energy itself jumps
    4. the entropy jumps but the volume does not
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Order = the lowest derivative of the Gibbs energy that is discontinuous. First order: S=−∂G/∂T and V=∂G/∂P jump (latent heat, volume change). Second order: G, S and V are continuous, but second derivatives such as CP=−T∂2G/∂T2, the expansion coefficient and the compressibility jump. No latent heat.

    Why people get this wrong: The Gibbs energy is continuous at every transition; it is equal in the two phases on the line.

  2. MCQExam level

    At fixed pressure, the molar Gibbs energies g1(T) and g2(T) of two phases are drawn against temperature. They cross at T0. Above T0 the stable phase is
    1. always the one with the smaller molar volume
    2. the one with the smaller molar entropy
    3. whichever one the system was in below T0
    4. the one with the larger molar entropy
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The stable phase has the lower g. Since (∂g/∂T)P=−s, each curve falls with slope −s. The phase with more entropy falls faster, so it is below the other after the crossing. This is why heating always takes a substance towards the higher-entropy phase (solid to liquid to gas).

    Why people get this wrong: Volume decides what pressure does (slope ∂g/∂P=v), not what temperature does.

  3. NATExam level

    A gas obeys the van der Waals equation with a=0.364 Pa m6 mol−2 and b=4.27×10−5 m3 mol−1. Its critical temperature is ______ K (to the nearest kelvin). Take R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 304 K (±1)

    At the critical point the isotherm has an inflection with zero slope: ∂P/∂V=0 and ∂2P/∂V2=0. For van der Waals this gives Vc=3b, Tc=8a/(27Rb), Pc=a/(27b2). So Tc=8×0.364/(27×8.314×4.27×10−5)=2.912/0.009585=304 K. (These are roughly the constants of CO2, whose real Tc is 304 K.)

    Why people get this wrong: Mixing up 8a/27Rb (critical temperature) with 2a/Rb (the Joule–Thomson inversion temperature, larger by 27/4).

  4. MCQExam level

    For a van der Waals gas, the critical compressibility factor Zc=PcVc/(RTc) is
    1. 3/8
    2. 1
    3. 8/27
    4. 27/64
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    With Pc=a/27b2, Vc=3b, Tc=8a/27Rb: Zc=(a/27b2)(3b)R(8a/27Rb)=3a/27b8a/27b=38=0.375. It is the same for every van der Waals gas (real gases give 0.23–0.31), an example of the law of corresponding states.

    Why people get this wrong: An ideal gas has Z=1; at the critical point the gas is far from ideal.

  5. MCQExam level

    Which of these is a continuous (second-order in Ehrenfest's sense) transition?
    1. Water boiling at 1 atm
    2. Ice melting at 1 atm
    3. A metal becoming superconducting in zero magnetic field
    4. Dry ice subliming at 1 atm
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    In zero field the superconducting transition has no latent heat and no volume change; the heat capacity jumps at Tc. Boiling, melting and sublimation all have latent heat: first order. (In a non-zero field the superconducting transition becomes first order, with a latent heat.)

    Why people get this wrong: Many students class every transition with a "sharp" change as first order. The test is latent heat.

  6. NATExam level

    At a second-order transition at 4.0 K, the molar heat capacity jumps by ΔCP=2.0 J mol−1 K−1 and the volume expansion coefficient by Δα=1.0×10−4 K−1. The molar volume is 1.0×10−5 m3/mol. By Ehrenfest's equation, the slope dP/dT of the transition line is ______ ×108 Pa/K.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5 $10^8$ Pa/K (±0.05)

    For a second-order transition S is continuous along the line: ds1=ds2 with ds=(CP/T)dT−vαdP. Subtracting: (ΔCP/T)dT=vΔαdP, so dPdT=ΔCPTvΔα=2.04.0×1.0×10−5×1.0×10−4=5.0×108 Pa/K.

    Why people get this wrong: Clausius–Clapeyron gives 0/0 here, since both L and Δv vanish; Ehrenfest's equations replace it.

  7. NATExam level

    A rigid tank holds water and steam together at 100∘C, where the specific volumes are vl=1.0×10−3 m3/kg and vg=1.67 m3/kg. The mixture's overall specific volume is 0.10 m3/kg. The fraction of the mass that is vapour is ______ (four decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0593 (±0.0006)

    Volumes add: v=(1−x)vl+xvg, so the lever rule gives x=v−vlvg−vl=0.10−0.0011.67−0.001=0.0593. Under 6% of the mass is steam, yet it fills 0.0593×1.670.10=99% of the volume.

    Why people get this wrong: Using the volume fraction instead of the mass fraction, or v/vg (0.0599) without subtracting vl.

  8. MCQExam level

    At fixed temperature, raising the pressure on a substance that has two possible phases favours
    1. the phase with the larger molar entropy
    2. the phase with the larger molar volume
    3. the phase with the smaller molar volume
    4. neither, because pressure does not affect which phase is stable
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    (∂g∂P)T=v, so the molar Gibbs energy of each phase rises with pressure at a rate equal to its molar volume. The denser phase (smaller v) rises more slowly and ends up with the lower g. That is why pressure melts ice (water is denser) and turns graphite into diamond.

    Why people get this wrong: The entropy decides what temperature favours (∂g/∂T=−s), not pressure.

  9. MCQExam level

    In Landau theory, F=a(T−Tc)m2+bm4 with a,b>0. Just below Tc, the equilibrium order parameter behaves as
    1. m∝(Tc−T)
    2. m∝(Tc−T)1/2
    3. m∝(Tc−T)1/3
    4. m jumps to a finite value at Tc
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    ∂F/∂m=2a(T−Tc)m+4bm3=0 gives m=0 or m2=a(Tc−T)2b. Below Tc the non-zero root has lower F, so m=a(Tc−T)/2b∝(Tc−T)1/2: mean-field exponent β=12 (real fluids and magnets give about 0.33). It starts from zero, so the transition is continuous.

    Why people get this wrong: A jump in m needs a negative m4 coefficient (or a cubic term): that is a first-order transition.

  10. MSQExam level

    Which of these are first-order transitions (with latent heat)?
    1. melting of ice at 1 atm
    2. heating a fluid along an isobar above its critical pressure, from liquid-like to gas-like
    3. iron losing its ferromagnetism at the Curie point in zero field
    4. a type-I superconductor turning normal in a non-zero applied magnetic field
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, D

    Melting has a latent heat (334 J/g for ice). Above the critical pressure there is no phase boundary at all: properties change smoothly. The Curie point in zero field is continuous: magnetisation goes to zero smoothly and only the heat capacity is singular. A type-I superconductor in a field B<Bc(0) goes normal at Tc(B)<Tc with a latent heat TΔs (the entropy jumps); only at zero field is the transition second order.

    Why people get this wrong: The same material can show a first-order or continuous transition depending on the field or pressure path.

  11. NATHard

    At water's triple point the molar latent heats are 6.01 kJ/mol for fusion and 45.0 kJ/mol for vaporisation. Treat the vapour as ideal and neglect the volumes of the solid and liquid. The ratio of the slope of the sublimation curve to that of the vaporisation curve at the triple point is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.134 (±0.002)

    Going round the triple point (solid → liquid → vapour or solid → vapour directly) ends in the same state, so Lsub=Lfus+Lvap=51.01 kJ/mol. Each curve has slope dP/dT=LP/(RT2) with the same P and T (the vapour volume is the same in both). The ratio is Lsub/Lvap=51.01/45.0=1.134: the sublimation curve is steeper, so the two meet at a kink.

    Why people get this wrong: A latent heat ratio of 6.01/45 would compare melting with boiling; the melting curve uses a tiny Δv and is far steeper than both.

  12. MCQHard

    Along a liquid–vapour coexistence curve, with an ideal vapour and negligible liquid volume, one can show dL/dT=CP,vap−CP,liq (molar). For water, CP,liq=75.3 and CP,vap=33.6 J mol−1 K−1. Near 100∘C the latent heat changes with temperature at a rate of about
    1. −41.7 J mol−1 K−1: it falls as the temperature rises
    2. +41.7 J mol−1 K−1: it rises with temperature
    3. 0: the latent heat is a constant of the substance
    4. −109 J mol−1 K−1, that is −L/T
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Take the derivative of L=TΔs along the curve: dL/dT=Δs+TdΔs/dT. Along the curve ds=(CP/T)dT−(∂v/∂T)PdP; for the ideal vapour (∂v/∂T)P=v/T and dP/dT=L/(Tv), giving TdΔs/dT=ΔCP−L/T. The L/T terms cancel: dL/dT=ΔCP=33.6−75.3=−41.7 J mol−1 K−1. (Measured: water's L falls from 45.0 kJ/mol at 0∘C to 40.7 at 100∘C, about −43 per kelvin.) It keeps falling and reaches zero at the critical point.

    Why people get this wrong: Treating L as a fixed property of the substance is fine over small ranges only.

  13. MSQHard

    Below its critical temperature a van der Waals isotherm has an S-shaped loop. The real isotherm replaces the loop with a horizontal line (the Maxwell construction). Which statements are correct?
    1. The horizontal line is drawn at the pressure of the loop's local maximum.
    2. The line is placed so that the two areas it cuts off from the loop are equal.
    3. States on the part of the loop where ∂P/∂V>0 are unstable.
    4. The pressure of the horizontal line is the vapour pressure at that temperature.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B, C, D

    First: false. The line's height is fixed by equal Gibbs energies of liquid and gas: Δg=∫vdP=0 along the isotherm, which is the equal-area rule (second, true). Third: where ∂P/∂V>0 the compressibility is negative, so any squeeze is self-reinforcing: mechanically unstable. Fourth: along the line liquid and vapour coexist, so its pressure is the saturated vapour pressure.

    Why people get this wrong: The parts of the loop between the line and the extremes are metastable (superheated liquid, supercooled vapour); only the middle part is truly unstable.

  14. MCQHard

    Below about 0.3 K, the melting curve of helium-3 has dP/dT<0, although the solid is denser than the liquid. What does this tell you?
    1. The latent heat of fusion is zero there
    2. The Clausius–Clapeyron equation does not apply to quantum liquids
    3. The liquid has a larger molar volume and a larger molar entropy
    4. The solid has a larger molar entropy than the liquid
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    dP/dT=Δs/Δv with Δ= liquid − solid. The solid is denser, so Δv>0. A negative slope then needs Δs<0: the solid has more entropy. In solid helium-3 the nuclear spins are disordered (entropy Rln⁡2 per mole) while in the liquid they are ordered by Fermi statistics. Squeezing the liquid into solid therefore absorbs heat and cools it: Pomeranchuk cooling.

    Why people get this wrong: Clausius–Clapeyron holds for any two phases in equilibrium; it is pure thermodynamics.

  15. MCQHard

    At a second-order (Ehrenfest) transition, which pair of quantities jumps?
    1. The entropy and the volume
    2. The Gibbs energy and the enthalpy
    3. The heat capacity and the expansion coefficient
    4. The Gibbs energy and the volume
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Second order: G and its first derivatives (S, V, hence also H=G+TS) are continuous. Second derivatives jump: CP=−T∂2G/∂T2, Vα=∂2G/∂T∂P and VκT=−∂2G/∂P2.

    Why people get this wrong: Entropy and volume jumping is the first-order case.

  16. MSQHard

    Near the triple point of water, which statements about the three coexistence curves are correct?
    1. The melting curve of water has a positive slope.
    2. The sublimation curve is steeper than the vaporisation curve.
    3. At the triple point Lsub=Lfus+Lvap.
    4. The melting curve is nearly vertical because the volume change on melting is tiny.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B, C, D

    C: going solid to vapour directly or via the liquid must cost the same (enthalpy is a state function). B: with an ideal vapour and negligible condensed volume, dPdT=LPRT2; at the same P and T the larger Lsub gives the steeper curve. D: dP/dT=L/TΔv with a very small Δv. A is false: ice is less dense than water, so Δv<0 and the slope is negative.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming every melting curve tilts to the right, as for most substances.

  17. NATHard

    A water droplet of radius 10 nm sits in its own vapour at 300 K. Surface tension 0.072 N/m, liquid molar volume 1.8×10−5 m3. By the Kelvin equation, the vapour pressure over the droplet divided by that over a flat surface is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.11 (±0.002)

    The extra Laplace pressure 2γ/r inside the droplet raises the liquid's chemical potential by vl⋅2γ/r. Equating with the vapour, RTln⁡PrP∞=2γvlr. Exponent: 2(0.072)(1.8×10−5)(10−8)(8.314)(300)=0.104, ratio e0.104=1.110. So small droplets evaporate while large ones grow, and clouds need nuclei to start.

    Why people get this wrong: Using γ/r instead of 2γ/r for the pressure jump across a spherical surface.

  18. NATHard

    A Landau free energy per mole is F=a(T−Tc)m2+bm4 with a=2.0 J mol−1 K−1, b=40 J/mol and Tc=100 K. The jump in molar heat capacity at Tc is ______ J mol−1 K−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5 (±0.05)

    Below Tc, m2=a(Tc−T)/2b and Fmin⁡=−a2(Tc−T)24b; above, F=0. C=−T∂2F∂T2=a2T2b below and 0 above. At Tc: ΔC=a2Tc2b=4×10080=5.0 J mol−1 K−1, larger on the ordered side. No latent heat: entropy is continuous, its slope is not (second order in Ehrenfest's sense).

    Why people get this wrong: Dropping the factor T in C=−T∂2F/∂T2 gives 0.05.

  19. NATHard

    Pure water is supercooled by ΔT=20 K. In classical nucleation theory a spherical ice nucleus grows only if its radius exceeds r∗=2γTmLVΔT. With γ=0.033 J/m2, Tm=273 K and latent heat per volume LV=3.06×108 J/m3, r∗ is ______ nm (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.94 nm (±0.03)

    A nucleus of radius r changes the free energy by ΔG=−43πr3Δg+4πr2γ with Δg=LVΔT/Tm (the bulk gain per volume, from Δg=Δh−TΔs near Tm). The maximum is at r∗=2γ/Δg=2×0.033×2733.06×108×20=2.94×10−9 m. Such a nucleus holds thousands of molecules, which rarely gather by chance; hence deep supercooling of clean water.

    Why people get this wrong: Setting ΔG=0 instead of maximising it gives 3γ/Δg=1.5r∗ (4.41 nm).

  20. NATTop rank

    For a substance, the sublimation curve is ln⁡(P/Pa)=30−6000K/T and the vaporisation curve is ln⁡(P/Pa)=25−5000K/T (ideal vapour, condensed volumes negligible). The molar latent heat of fusion at the triple point is ______ kJ/mol (to two decimal places). Take R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 8.31 kJ/mol (±0.02)

    Each curve is ln⁡P=−L/(RT)+c, so Lsub=6000R=49.9 kJ/mol and Lvap=5000R=41.6 kJ/mol. Around the triple point, Lfus=Lsub−Lvap=1000R=8.31 kJ/mol. (The triple point itself: 30−6000/T=25−5000/T gives T=200 K and P=e0=1 Pa; it is not needed for Lfus.)

    Why people get this wrong: Trying to use the melting curve: it is not given, and it is not needed.

  21. MSQTop rank

    As the liquid–vapour coexistence curve is followed up to the critical point, which statements are correct?
    1. The latent heat of vaporisation goes to zero.
    2. The difference between the molar volumes of liquid and vapour goes to zero.
    3. The slope dP/dT of the curve stays finite.
    4. The integrated form ln⁡P=−L/RT+c with constant L stays accurate all the way.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    At the critical point liquid and vapour become identical, so Δs→0 (hence L=TΔs→0) and Δv→0. Their ratio dP/dT=Δs/Δv tends to the finite slope of the vapour-pressure curve where it ends. The integrated form assumed constant L, an ideal vapour and negligible liquid volume, and all three fail near Tc.

    Why people get this wrong: L→0 does not mean the slope goes to zero; it is a 0/0 limit.

  22. NATTop rank

    A type-I superconductor has a critical field μ0Hc(T)=B0(1−T2/Tc2) with B0=0.080 T and Tc=7.2 K. The Gibbs energy per unit volume of the normal state exceeds that of the superconducting state by μ0Hc2/2. Find the latent heat per unit volume absorbed when the sample turns normal in its critical field at T=3.6 K: ______ kJ/m3 (to two decimal places). Take μ0=4π×10−7 T m/A.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.91 kJ/m³ (±0.02)

    Entropy difference: sn−ss=−∂(gn−gs)/∂T=−μ0HcdHc/dT. With μ0Hc=B0(1−t2), t=T/Tc: dHc/dT=−2B0T/(μ0Tc2), so L=T(sn−ss)=2B02μ0t2(1−t2). Here t=0.5: B02/μ0=0.0064/1.2566×10−6=5093 J/m3, and L=2×5093×0.25×0.75=1910 J/m3=1.91 kJ/m3. It is positive because the normal state has more entropy, and it vanishes at T=0 and at T=Tc (where the transition becomes second order).

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that Hc itself depends on T: the latent heat comes entirely from dHc/dT.

  23. MCQTop rank

    Accurate vapour-pressure data for a liquid, plotted as ln⁡P against 1/T over a wide range, give a curve whose slope gets less steep as T rises (towards small 1/T). The best explanation is that
    1. the latent heat falls as the temperature rises, because the vapour's heat capacity is less than the liquid's
    2. the vapour becomes more ideal at high temperature
    3. the liquid's volume becomes negligible at high temperature
    4. the latent heat rises with temperature
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The local slope of ln⁡P against 1/T is −L/R (in the ideal-vapour approximation). A shallower slope at higher T means a smaller L. Indeed dL/dT≈CP,vap−CP,liq<0 for ordinary liquids, and L→0 at the critical point. (Non-ideal vapour and the growing liquid volume push the same way near Tc, but the second and third options are the wrong way round: both get worse, not better, as T rises.)

    Why people get this wrong: A curved Clausius–Clapeyron plot does not mean the equation is wrong, only that L is not constant.

  24. MCQTop rank

    In Landau theory with a field, F=a(T−Tc)m2+bm4−hm. At the same distance |T−Tc| from the transition, the zero-field susceptibility χ=∂m/∂h above Tc is how many times its value below Tc?
    1. 1
    2. 1/2
    3. 4
    4. 2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Let t=T−Tc. Equilibrium needs ∂F/∂m=0, i.e. h=2atm+4bm3; differentiating, 1/χ=∂h/∂m=∂2F/∂m2 at the equilibrium m. Above: m=0, 1/χ=2at. Below: m02=−at/2b, so 1/χ=2at+12bm02=2at−6at=4a|t|. Ratio χabove/χbelow=4a|t|/2a|t|=2. Both diverge as |t|−1 (mean-field γ=1).

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the curvature added by the m4 term below Tc gives a ratio of 1.

← All topics · Timed mock test →