Partial derivatives and Jacobians
Mathematical methods · 24 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
Three variables are linked by one equation . The product equals- it depends on
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Each factor is minus a ratio of partial derivatives of : , , . The product is for every . Check with : .Why people get this wrong: Cancelling the "differentials" like fractions gives . Partial derivatives held at different constants do not cancel like that.
-
MCQExam level
From , the equality of mixed partial derivatives givesAnswer and solution
Answer: B
has and . Since : .Why people get this wrong: Losing the minus sign that comes with .
-
MCQExam level
With new variables and , the operator becomesAnswer and solution
Answer: D
Chain rule: and . So and . The difference is . This is how the wave equation is solved by d'Alembert: means .Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the cross term in each square, or getting a factor 2.
-
MCQExam level
Using , find for one mole of a van der Waals gas, .Answer and solution
Answer: D
, so . Then . Positive: pulling the molecules apart against their attraction raises the internal energy.Why people get this wrong: is the ideal-gas answer; the term drops out but the term does not.
-
MSQExam level
Which statements are true?- whenever both mixed partials are continuous.
- for every function whose first partials exist.
- Equality of mixed partials is why .
- In a simply connected region, is exact exactly when .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C, D
Clairaut's (Schwarz's) theorem needs continuity of the second partials; without it there are counterexamples, so the second statement is false. Each component of is a difference of two mixed partials, which cancel. The exactness test works in a region with no holes.Why people get this wrong: In a region with a hole (like the plane without the origin) the field passes the test but is not exact.
-
MCQExam level
For with (), equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: A
, so . Then . Adding the and versions: . Check: gives 0, the familiar fact that is harmonic.Why people get this wrong: is just ; the Laplacian also has the term.
-
MCQExam level
For a function of only, , the two-dimensional Laplacian equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: D
, so . Add (same with ): . Check: gives , the 2D harmonic function.Why people get this wrong: belongs to three dimensions; in dimensions the coefficient is .
-
MCQExam level
The Helmholtz free energy has . Equality of its mixed second partial derivatives givesAnswer and solution
Answer: B
From : and . Then , so . The other two true-looking relations come from and from .Why people get this wrong: Both minus signs cancel; keeping only one gives the wrong sign.
-
NATHard
The general relation is applied to one mole of an ideal gas (take J/(mol K)). The result is ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 8.314 J/K (±0.01)
For an ideal gas and . Then J/K for one mole: Mayer's relation.Why people get this wrong: Using (the compressibility) in place of .
-
MCQHard
The enthalpy is a Legendre transform of . Its natural variables areAnswer and solution
Answer: D
. So changes with and : its natural variables are and .Why people get this wrong: belongs to the Gibbs energy , which swaps for as well.
-
MCQHard
For let and . The Jacobian isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
It is easier to find the inverse: . The Jacobian of the inverse map is the reciprocal: .Why people get this wrong: Stopping at , which is the Jacobian the other way round.
-
MSQHard
For one mole of an ideal gas, . Which statements are true?- is an exact differential.
- is an integrating factor of .
- is exact.
- for every closed cycle.
Answer and solution
Answer: B, C
Test: but : not exact, so heat depends on the path. Dividing by : passes the test; it is . is exact. is the net work of a cycle, the area enclosed on a diagram: not zero in general (that is how engines work).Why people get this wrong: Mixing up (exact) with (not exact).
-
NATHard
For , the value of at is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 750
is homogeneous of degree . Applying Euler's operator twice gives . At : , so the answer is .Why people get this wrong: Using instead of : the second application of also acts on the first derivatives.
-
MCQHard
From , the entropy change with pressure at constant temperature, , for moles of an ideal gas isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Mixed partials of : . For an ideal gas , so . Squeezing a gas at constant temperature lowers its entropy.Why people get this wrong: Missing the minus sign that comes from .
-
MSQHard
Let for and . Which statements are true?- and both exist and equal 0
- is continuous at the origin
- is differentiable at the origin
- The limit of along the line depends on
Answer and solution
Answer: A, D
On the -axis , so ; likewise . Along : , which depends on (0 on the axes, on ). So the limit at the origin does not exist: is not continuous there, and therefore not differentiable either.Why people get this wrong: Existence of both partial derivatives does not imply continuity in two variables; they only test two directions.
-
MCQHard
The internal energy of a simple system is extensive: . With , and , Euler's theorem givesAnswer and solution
Answer: C
For a function homogeneous of degree 1, . Substituting the definitions: . (Differentiating it and comparing with then gives the Gibbs-Duhem relation.)Why people get this wrong: Sign of the term: is minus the derivative, so . A factor 2 would need degree 2.
-
MSQHard
For at the origin, which statements are true?- The origin is a saddle point
- The origin is a stationary point
- The second-derivative (Hessian) test is inconclusive there
- The origin is a strict local minimum
Answer and solution
Answer: B, C, D
and both vanish at the origin, so it is stationary. All second derivatives (, , 0) vanish there, so and the test says nothing. But everywhere except the origin, where , so it is a strict minimum, not a saddle.Why people get this wrong: means "test fails", not "saddle". Look at the function itself.
-
MSQHard
Let for and . Which statements are true?- is continuous at the origin
- is differentiable at the origin
- The directional derivative at the origin along is
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
because , so : continuous. On the axes , so both partials are 0 at the origin. Along : , so the directional derivative is . If were differentiable this would equal ; it does not, so is not differentiable at the origin, even though it is continuous and has both partials.Why people get this wrong: Existence of the partial derivatives (even with continuity) does not make a function differentiable.
-
NATTop rank
For a gas with (one mole), the Joule-Thomson coefficient is . With Pa m mol, m mol and J/(mol K), changes sign at ______ K (to the nearest kelvin).Answer and solution
Answer: 864 K (±3)
. Then . It vanishes at K. Below it the gas cools on throttling; above it, it warms.Why people get this wrong: Missing the second (from ) gives half the temperature.
-
MCQTop rank
With and , the ratio equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: C
In Jacobian notation . Rearranging the Jacobians: . Since , a gas is harder to compress adiabatically than isothermally: for an ideal gas and .Why people get this wrong: Inverting the ratio. Check with the ideal gas: the adiabat is steeper, so is smaller.
-
MSQTop rank
For , which statements are true?- The origin is a local minimum.
- Every point of the circle is a local maximum.
- The largest value of is .
- At points of that circle, .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Write with . and elsewhere: the origin is a minimum. at , where is the maximum, reached on the whole circle. Along the circle is constant, so the curvature in that direction is zero and : the Hessian test is inconclusive there, even though each point is a (non-strict) maximum.Why people get this wrong: Expecting at every maximum. means the test says nothing, not that there is no extremum.
-
NATTop rank
One mole of a gas obeys with constant . Using , the value of is ______ J/(mol K) (take J/(mol K)).Answer and solution
Answer: 8.314 J/(mol K) (±0.01)
gives and . So J/(mol K), the same as an ideal gas: an excluded volume alone does not change it (an attraction term would).Why people get this wrong: The factors cancel exactly; it is not .