Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / Matter waves and the uncertainty principle

Matter waves and the uncertainty principle

Modern physics · 24 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQStandard

    A free particle moves with speed v. Using the relativistic energy E=γmc2 (including rest energy) and E=ℏω, p=ℏk, the phase velocity ω/k of its de Broglie wave is
    1. v
    2. c
    3. c2/v
    4. v/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    vp=ω/k=E/p=γmc2/(γmv)=c2/v, which is more than c. It carries no energy or information, so relativity is not broken; the packet (and the particle) moves at the group velocity v.

    Why people get this wrong: v/2 is what you get with the non-relativistic E=p2/2m; the phase velocity depends on where the zero of energy is, so it is not a physical speed.

  2. MSQExam level

    For the de Broglie wave of a free relativistic particle of rest mass m>0, which statements are correct?
    1. vpvg=c2.
    2. vp>c, which does not break relativity because the phase carries no information.
    3. vg equals the speed of the particle.
    4. vp=vg.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    vp=E/p=c2/v and vg=dE/dp=v, so vpvg=c2 and vp>c since v<c. The group velocity is the particle speed. They are equal only for a massless particle (vp=vg=c).

    Why people get this wrong: Massive particles are dispersive: ω(k) is not a straight line, so phase and group velocities differ.

  3. NATExam level

    An electron has kinetic energy 1.0 MeV. Using mec2=0.511 MeV and hc=1240 MeV fm, its de Broglie wavelength is ______ pm (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.872 pm (±0.004)

    Relativistic: E=K+mc2 and (pc)2=E2−(mc2)2=K2+2Kmc2=1+1.022=2.022 MeV2, so pc=1.422 MeV. λ=hc/pc=1240/1.422=872 fm =0.872 pm.

    Why people get this wrong: The non-relativistic rule 1.23/V nm gives 1.23 pm, 40% too large: at K>mec2 you must use the relativistic momentum.

  4. NATExam level

    An excited state has lifetime 2.0 ns. Using ΔEΔt≥ℏ/2 with Δt equal to the lifetime, the minimum frequency spread Δν=ΔE/h of the emitted light is ______ MHz (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 39.8 MHz (±0.2)

    ΔE=ℏ/(2τ), so Δν=ΔE/h=1/(4πτ)=1/(4π×2.0×10−9)=3.98×107 Hz =39.8 MHz.

    Why people get this wrong: Dividing by ℏ instead of h gives the angular frequency spread, 2π times larger.

  5. MCQHard

    For a free non-relativistic particle, ω=ℏk2/2m. The group velocity vg and phase velocity vp are related by
    1. vg=2vp
    2. vg=vp
    3. vg=vp/2
    4. vgvp=c2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    vp=ω/k=ℏk/2m and vg=dω/dk=ℏk/m, so vg=2vp. The group velocity ℏk/m=p/m is the particle speed.

    Why people get this wrong: vgvp=c2 is the relativistic result with the rest energy included.

  6. MSQHard

    A free particle is described by a Gaussian wave packet. Which statements are correct?
    1. At the moment of minimum width a Gaussian packet has ΔxΔp=ℏ/2 exactly.
    2. The packet spreads out in position as time passes.
    3. The narrower the packet starts, the faster it spreads.
    4. Its momentum spread grows with time.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    A Gaussian is the minimum-uncertainty shape. Different momentum components travel at different speeds, so the packet spreads. A narrow start means a large Δp, hence a large spread in speeds and fast spreading. For a free particle each momentum is conserved, so the momentum distribution, and Δp, never change.

    Why people get this wrong: The position spread grows; the momentum spread does not.

  7. MCQHard

    For electrons, at roughly what kinetic energy does the non-relativistic formula λ=h/2mK give a wavelength 1% too large? (mec2=511 keV)
    1. About 200 eV
    2. About 20 keV
    3. About 2 MeV
    4. About 511 keV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Exactly, (pc)2=K2+2Kmc2=2Kmc2(1+K/2mc2). So λrel/λnr=(1+K/2mc2)−1/2. For this to be 0.99: 1+K/2mc2=1.0203, so K=0.0203×1022 keV ≈21 keV. Electron microscopes (100 to 300 kV) must use the relativistic formula.

    Why people get this wrong: Corrections start well below mec2; "relativistic only near 511 keV" is wrong for a 1% answer.

  8. NATHard

    An electron microscope needs electrons of wavelength 5.0 pm. Using hc=1.24 MeV pm and mec2=0.511 MeV (relativistic formula), the accelerating voltage must be ______ kV (to the nearest kV).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 57 kV (±1)

    pc=hc/λ=1.24/5.0=0.248 MeV. E=(pc)2+(mc2)2=0.0615+0.2611=0.5680 MeV. K=E−mc2=0.0570 MeV =57 keV, so 57 kV.

    Why people get this wrong: The non-relativistic formula gives (pc)2/2mc2=60 kV, about 5% too high.

  9. MSQHard

    Which statements about matter waves are correct?
    1. |ψ|2 gives the probability per unit length (or volume) of finding the particle.
    2. An electron two-slit pattern builds up spot by spot even when electrons pass one at a time.
    3. Matter waves are electromagnetic waves emitted by the moving particle.
    4. The de Broglie wavelength of a particle depends on the frame of reference of the observer.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    First: Born's rule. Second: seen in experiments; each electron lands at one spot, and the fringes appear in the statistics. Third: false; they are probability amplitudes, not electromagnetic fields (neutral neutrons show them too). Fourth: true, since momentum depends on the frame; in the particle's own rest frame p=0.

    Why people get this wrong: A neutral particle (neutron, atom, molecule) diffracts just as well, so matter waves cannot be electromagnetic.

  10. MSQHard

    Which statements about wave packets are correct?
    1. For a free non-relativistic particle the group velocity is half the phase velocity.
    2. A free non-relativistic particle's packet spreads as time goes on.
    3. For the same initial width, a heavier particle's packet spreads more slowly.
    4. A light pulse in vacuum does not spread, since all its frequencies travel at c.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B, C, D

    With ω=ℏk2/2m: vp=ω/k=ℏk/2m and vg=dω/dk=ℏk/m=2vp, so A is false (the group velocity is twice the phase velocity, and equals the particle speed). B, C: the dispersion makes the width grow as σ(t)=σ01+(ℏt/2mσ02)2, slower for larger m. D: ω=ck is dispersionless.

    Why people get this wrong: Swapping group and phase velocity; the group velocity is the one that matches the classical speed.

  11. NATHard

    An electron's de Broglie wavelength equals its Compton wavelength h/mec. With mec2=511 keV, its kinetic energy is ______ keV (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 211.7 keV (±0.3)

    λ=h/p=h/mec means p=mec, so pc=mec2. Total energy E=(pc)2+(mec2)2=2mec2, and K=(2−1)mec2=0.4142×511=211.7 keV. The non-relativistic formula would give p2/2m=mec2/2=255.5 keV, about 20% too high.

    Why people get this wrong: K=p2/2m is not valid when pc is comparable to mec2.

  12. MCQHard

    An electron and a proton both have de Broglie wavelength 1.0 fm. With hc=1240 MeV fm, mec2=0.511 MeV and mpc2=938.3 MeV, the ratio Ke/Kp of their kinetic energies is about
    1. 1836
    2. 1.0
    3. 0.50
    4. 2.0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Both have pc=hc/λ=1240 MeV. The electron is ultra-relativistic: Ke=12402+0.5112−0.511≈1239.5 MeV. The proton: Kp=12402+938.32−938.3=1555.0−938.3=616.7 MeV. Ratio ≈2.0. The non-relativistic K=p2/2m would wrongly give 1836.

    Why people get this wrong: mp/me=1836 holds only when both particles are slow.

  13. NATTop rank

    An electron has kinetic energy 1.0 MeV (mec2=0.511 MeV). The phase velocity of its de Broglie wave (relativistic, rest energy included) is ______ times c (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.063 $c$ (±0.002)

    E=1.511 MeV, pc=K2+2Kmc2=2.022=1.4220 MeV. Particle speed v/c=pc/E=0.9411. Phase velocity vp=c2/v, so vp/c=E/pc=1.511/1.4220=1.063.

    Why people get this wrong: The phase velocity is above c for every massive particle and approaches c only as the particle itself does.

  14. MSQTop rank

    Which statements are correct?
    1. A packet localised within Δx is made of wave numbers spread over a range of about 1/Δx.
    2. A plane wave eikx has a sharp momentum ℏk but is spread evenly over all space.
    3. A state sharply localised at one point has equal amplitude for all momenta.
    4. The uncertainty relation limits only successive measurements on one particle; it says nothing about the spread of results over many identically prepared particles.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    First: Fourier pairs, ΔxΔk≳1. Second: |eikx|2=1 everywhere. Third: the Fourier transform of a delta function is a constant. Fourth: false; Δx and Δp are the standard deviations of results over an ensemble of identically prepared systems, and the relation constrains exactly those spreads.

    Why people get this wrong: The principle is about the state (the spreads it gives), not about one unlucky measurement.

  15. NATTop rank

    Neutrons are reflected in first order from crystal planes 0.20 nm apart at a glancing angle of 30∘. Using h=6.63×10−34 J s, mn=1.675×10−27 kg and 1 eV =1.6×10−19 J, their kinetic energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 20.5 meV (±0.2)

    Bragg: λ=2dsin⁡θ=2(0.20)(0.5)=0.20 nm. K=h2/(2mnλ2)=(6.63×10−34)2/(2×1.675×10−27×4.0×10−20)=3.28×10−21 J =20.5 meV, close to room-temperature thermal energy.

    Why people get this wrong: The Bragg angle is measured from the planes (glancing angle), not from the normal.

  16. NATTop rank

    A free electron is described at t=0 by a Gaussian packet of width σ0=0.10 nm, whose width grows as σ(t)=σ01+(ℏt/2mσ02)2. With ℏ=1.055×10−34 J s and me=9.11×10−31 kg, the width doubles after ______ ×10−16 s (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.99 $10^{-16}$ s (±0.02)

    σ=2σ0 needs 1+(ℏt/2mσ02)2=4, so ℏt/2mσ02=3 and t=23mσ02/ℏ=2(1.732)(9.11×10−31)(10−20)/(1.055×10−34)=2.99×10−16 s. An atom-sized free electron packet spreads in well under a femtosecond.

    Why people get this wrong: The square root must equal 2, so the quantity under it must equal 4. Setting the quantity under the root equal to 2 gives the time for a width of only 2σ0.

  17. MSQTop rank

    For a free particle with E2=p2c2+m2c4, which statements are correct?
    1. dE/dp equals the particle's speed.
    2. E/p≥c.
    3. For a photon, phase and group velocities are both c.
    4. The phase velocity is the speed at which the probability density moves.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    First: dE/dp=pc2/E=v. Second: E≥pc, so E/p≥c, equality for m=0. Third: E=pc gives ω=ck, no dispersion. Fourth: false; the probability (and energy) moves with the group velocity.

    Why people get this wrong: Phase velocity is a property of a single plane wave, not of anything you could detect moving.

  18. MCQTop rank

    In a neutron interferometer, two paths enclosing an area A in a vertical plane are at different heights, so gravity gives them different phases. For a fixed neutron wavelength λ, the gravitational phase difference is proportional to
    1. m
    2. m2
    3. m
    4. m0 (it does not depend on the mass)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    On the upper path the neutron's kinetic energy is lower by mgH, so its wave number changes by Δk=dkdEmgH=mℏ2kmgH. Over a horizontal length L the phase difference is ΔkL=m2gHLℏ2k=m2gλA2πℏ2 with A=HL. One power of m comes from the gravitational energy and one from converting energy to wave number.

    Why people get this wrong: Saying the mass cancels, as it does for a classical falling body; the wave description keeps m2/ℏ2.

  19. NATTop rank

    A beam of electrons of de Broglie wavelength 0.125 nm passes through a circular hole of diameter a and lands on a screen L=1.0 m away. Take the angular half-spread from diffraction to be λ/a, so the spot diameter is D=a+2Lλ/a. The smallest possible spot diameter (choosing a freely) is ______ μm (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 31.6 μm (±0.2)

    A large hole lets the beam through wide; a small hole spreads it by diffraction. dD/da=1−2Lλ/a2=0 gives a=2Lλ=2×1.0×1.25×10−10=15.8 μm, and then D=2a=22Lλ=31.6 μm. This trade-off is the uncertainty principle at work: narrowing Δx widens Δpx.

    Why people get this wrong: Making the hole as small as possible does not make the spot as small as possible.

  20. MSQTop rank

    A non-relativistic particle of total energy E moves through a region where the potential energy V(x) changes slowly. Its local de Broglie wavelength is λ(x)=h/2m[E−V(x)]. Which statements are correct?
    1. The frequency E/h of the wave is the same everywhere along the path.
    2. The wavelength is longer where the potential energy is higher.
    3. The phase velocity of the wave is the same everywhere along the path.
    4. Adding a constant to V everywhere (and to E) changes the frequency but leaves every wavelength unchanged.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    For a stationary state the time factor e−iEt/ℏ is common to all x, so the frequency is fixed. Where V is higher the kinetic energy E−V is smaller, p is smaller, and λ is longer. The phase velocity ω/k=E/p(x) changes as p changes, so it is not constant. Shifting the zero of potential energy shifts E (so the frequency, which is not measurable on its own) but not E−V, so all wavelengths stay the same.

    Why people get this wrong: Only the frequency is fixed, not the phase velocity: like light entering glass, the wave changes speed and wavelength together.

← All topics · Timed mock test →