Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / Identical particles

Identical particles

Quantum mechanics · 83 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Identical particles.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    The total wavefunction (space and spin) of a system of two identical fermions must be
    1. antisymmetric under exchange of the two particles
    2. symmetric under exchange
    3. symmetric in space and antisymmetric in spin, always
    4. unchanged in magnitude only, with any phase
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Exchange P12 commutes with H for identical particles and P122=1, so states have P12=±1. Nature chooses: −1 for fermions (half-integer spin), +1 for bosons (integer spin). For fermions the space part can be symmetric if the spin part is antisymmetric, or the other way round; only the product must be antisymmetric.

    Why people get this wrong: The third option is only one of the two possibilities (the singlet case).

  2. MCQWarm-up

    Which of these behaves as a boson?
    1. An electron
    2. A neutral 4He atom
    3. A neutral 3He atom
    4. A proton
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Count the fermions inside: 4He has 2 protons, 2 neutrons and 2 electrons, 6 fermions, so its total spin is an integer and it is a boson (hence superfluid 4He). 3He has 5 fermions: a fermion. Electrons and protons are spin-12 fermions.
  3. MCQWarm-up

    Two non-interacting electrons (spin 12) are in a 1D infinite well whose single-particle levels are n2E1. The ground-state energy of the pair is
    1. E1
    2. 5E1
    3. 2E1
    4. 8E1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Both can occupy n=1 if their spins form the antisymmetric singlet, so E=E1+E1=2E1. For spinless fermions (or electrons forced into a triplet) one must go to n=2: E1+4E1=5E1.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    The Pauli exclusion principle follows from antisymmetry because
    1. fermions repel each other electrically
    2. fermions have spin
    3. bosons occupy only even states
    4. an antisymmetric product of two identical one-particle states, ϕ(1)ϕ(2)−ϕ(2)ϕ(1), is zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    If both particles had the same one-particle state (space and spin), the antisymmetrised wavefunction would vanish identically. So no two identical fermions share a complete set of quantum numbers. It has nothing to do with charge: neutrons obey it too.
  5. NATWarm-up

    Two identical bosons can each be in any of 3 single-particle states. The number of distinct two-particle states is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6

    Symmetric states: both in the same state (3 ways) or in two different states, symmetrised (3 pairs). Total 6=(3+2−12). Distinguishable particles would have 32=9; identical fermions (32)=3.
  6. MSQWarm-up

    Which statements about the exchange operator P12 for identical particles are correct?
    1. Its eigenvalues are +1 and −1.
    2. It commutes with the Hamiltonian.
    3. A state that starts symmetric stays symmetric as it evolves.
    4. Spin-12 particles can form a symmetric total wavefunction and so act as bosons.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    P122=1 gives eigenvalues ±1. For identical particles H is unchanged by relabelling, so [H,P12]=0 and the symmetry is conserved. Spin-statistics fixes antisymmetric total wavefunctions for spin 12. (A bound pair of fermions can be a composite boson, but each electron itself cannot.)
  7. MCQWarm-up

    Which of these is a fermion?
    1. a neutral 4He atom
    2. a neutral 3He atom
    3. a deuteron
    4. a neutral 1H atom
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Count the spin-12 constituents: an odd number makes a fermion. 3He: 2 protons + 1 neutron + 2 electrons = 5, odd: fermion. 4He: 6, deuteron: 2, 1H: 2 (proton + electron), all even: bosons.

    Why people get this wrong: Count electrons too for neutral atoms; a hydrogen atom is a boson although the proton and electron are fermions.

  8. NATStandard

    Two identical spinless fermions are in a 1D infinite well (levels n2E1). The ground-state energy of the pair is ______ E1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5

    They cannot share a level, so the lowest is n=1 and n=2: E=(1+4)E1=5E1, with ψ=12[ψ1(x1)ψ2(x2)−ψ2(x1)ψ1(x2)]. Two identical bosons would both sit in n=1: 2E1.
  9. NATStandard

    Three non-interacting electrons are in a 1D harmonic oscillator. The ground-state energy is ______ ℏω (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.5 (±0.01)

    Each level holds two electrons (spin up and down). Two in n=0 (12ℏω each) and one in n=1 (32ℏω): 1+1.5=2.5ℏω.
  10. MCQStandard

    Two electrons are in the spin singlet state. Their spatial wavefunction must be
    1. symmetric under exchange
    2. antisymmetric under exchange
    3. zero
    4. either; the spin state places no restriction
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The singlet (↑↓−↓↑)/2 is antisymmetric, so the spatial part must be symmetric to make the total antisymmetric. The three triplet states are symmetric, and go with antisymmetric spatial functions.
  11. NATStandard

    Three identical fermions are distributed over 5 single-particle states (at most one per state). The number of distinct three-particle states is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 10

    An antisymmetric state is fixed by which 3 of the 5 states are occupied (a Slater determinant), so the count is (53)=10. Order does not matter, and no state is used twice.
  12. MCQStandard

    In excited helium with configuration 1s2s, the triplet (S=1) level lies below the singlet level because
    1. the spins interact magnetically, favouring parallel spins
    2. the antisymmetric spatial function keeps the electrons apart and lowers their Coulomb repulsion
    3. the triplet has three states
    4. the triplet electrons are closer to the nucleus by the Pauli principle
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The triplet spin state is symmetric, so its spatial part 12[ϕ1s(1)ϕ2s(2)−ϕ2s(1)ϕ1s(2)] vanishes when the electrons meet. Less overlap means less repulsion: E=J−K for the triplet and J+K for the singlet, with exchange integral K>0. Magnetic spin-spin energies are far smaller.
  13. MCQStandard

    For two non-interacting identical fermions in one-particle states ϕa and ϕb (including spin), the normalised two-particle state is
    1. ϕa(1)ϕb(2)
    2. 12[ϕa(1)ϕb(2)+ϕb(1)ϕa(2)]
    3. 12[ϕa(1)ϕb(2)−ϕb(1)ϕa(2)]
    4. 12[ϕa(1)−ϕb(2)]
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    It is the 2×2 Slater determinant 12|ϕa(1)ϕb(1)ϕa(2)ϕb(2)|. It changes sign under 1↔2 and vanishes if a=b. The plus combination is the bosonic one.
  14. NATStandard

    Two identical bosons share 5 available single-particle states. The number of distinct two-particle states is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 15

    Both in one state: 5 ways. In two different states: (52)=10 symmetrised pairs. Total 15=(5+12).
  15. MSQStandard

    Which statements about the 1s2s configuration of helium are correct?
    1. It contains 4 states in all.
    2. The three triplet states have an antisymmetric spatial wavefunction.
    3. The singlet state has a symmetric spatial wavefunction.
    4. The ground configuration 1s2 also has a triplet.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Two different orbitals, each electron with 2 spin states: one symmetric spatial function times the singlet, one antisymmetric spatial function times the three triplet states, 1+3=4. In 1s2 the spatial function ϕ1s(1)ϕ1s(2) is necessarily symmetric, so only the singlet is allowed.
  16. MCQStandard

    The spin-statistics connection states that
    1. all particles with spin are fermions
    2. bosons have half-integer spin
    3. statistics depends on the temperature
    4. particles with integer spin are bosons and particles with half-integer spin are fermions
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Photons (spin 1), pions (0) and 4He atoms are bosons; electrons, protons, neutrons and 3He atoms are fermions. Within non-relativistic quantum mechanics it is a postulate; relativistic quantum field theory proves it.
  17. MCQStandard

    Two non-interacting electrons are in a 1D infinite well (levels n2E1). The first excited level of the pair, at 5E1 (one electron in n=1, one in n=2), is how many-fold degenerate?
    1. 4
    2. 1
    3. 2
    4. 3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    With different orbitals, the spatial function can be symmetric (with the spin singlet, 1 state) or antisymmetric (with the triplet, 3 states). Without interactions all four have the same energy 5E1; a repulsion would split them into 1+3.
  18. NATStandard

    Two electrons are placed in 4 available spatial orbitals (each orbital has two spin states). The number of distinct antisymmetric two-electron states is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 28

    There are 4×2=8 single-particle spin-orbitals. An antisymmetric state is fixed by choosing which 2 are occupied: (82)=28. Check by spin: both in the same orbital (4 ways, singlet only) gives 4; in different orbitals ((42)=6 pairs) gives singlet + triplet = 4 states each, 24. Total 28.

    Why people get this wrong: 8×8=64 counts ordered pairs of distinguishable particles.

  19. MCQStandard

    Two electrons occupy the same spatial orbital ϕ(r→) (as in the helium ground state). Their spin state must be
    1. the singlet
    2. one of the triplet states
    3. either a singlet or a triplet
    4. any product state such as |↑↑⟩
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The spatial part ϕ(r→1)ϕ(r→2) is symmetric under exchange. The total state must be antisymmetric, so the spin part must be antisymmetric: the singlet 12(|↑↓⟩−|↓↑⟩). This is the Pauli rule "two electrons per orbital, with opposite spins".

    Why people get this wrong: |↑↑⟩ is a triplet state; it would need an antisymmetric spatial part, impossible with one orbital.

  20. MSQStandard

    Which of these are acceptable wavefunctions (up to normalisation) for two identical spinless bosons, with ϕa≠ϕb?
    1. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)+ϕb(x1)ϕa(x2)
    2. ϕa(x1)ϕa(x2)
    3. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)−ϕb(x1)ϕa(x2)
    4. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B

    Spinless bosons need ψ(x1,x2)=ψ(x2,x1). The symmetrised sum and the doubly occupied product are symmetric. The difference is antisymmetric (fermions), and the plain product is neither: it labels which particle is in which state.

    Why people get this wrong: A product of two different orbitals is not symmetric unless it is symmetrised.

  21. NATExam level

    Two identical spinless fermions in an infinite well 0<x<a occupy n=1 and n=2 (antisymmetric spatial state). Using ⟨x2⟩n=a2(13−12n2π2), ⟨x⟩n=a/2 and ⟨1|x|2⟩=−16a9π2, ⟨(x1−x2)2⟩=ka2 with k= ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.168 (±0.002)

    ⟨(x1−x2)2⟩=⟨x2⟩1+⟨x2⟩2−2⟨x⟩1⟨x⟩2±2|⟨1|x|2⟩|2, with + for the antisymmetric (fermion) state. Numbers: 0.2827+0.3207−0.5=0.1033 (the distinguishable value) plus 2(0.1801)2=0.0649: 0.168a2. The particles are pushed apart by symmetry alone (the "exchange force").
  22. MCQExam level

    Compared with distinguishable particles in the same two orbitals, two identical particles in a spatially symmetric state are
    1. on average farther apart
    2. on average closer together
    3. at the same average separation
    4. never found at the same point
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The exchange term −2|⟨a|x|b⟩|2 lowers ⟨(x1−x2)2⟩ for symmetric spatial states (bosons, or fermions in a spin singlet) and raises it for antisymmetric ones. It is not a real force but a correlation from the symmetry of the wavefunction; it vanishes when the orbitals do not overlap.
  23. NATExam level

    Five non-interacting electrons are placed in a 2D square infinite well, whose single-particle levels are (nx2+ny2)ϵ. The ground-state energy is ______ ϵ.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 19

    Levels: (1,1) at 2ϵ (one orbital, 2 electrons); (1,2) and (2,1) at 5ϵ (two orbitals, up to 4 electrons). Fill: 2×2+3×5=19ϵ.
  24. NATExam level

    For helium 1s2s, the direct and exchange integrals of the electron repulsion are J and K=0.40 eV. The singlet-triplet splitting E(1S)−E(3S) is ______ eV (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.8 (±0.01)

    Singlet (symmetric space): E0+J+K. Triplet (antisymmetric space): E0+J−K. Splitting 2K=0.80 eV, close to the measured gap between the 21S and 23S levels of helium.
  25. MCQExam level

    In the H2 molecule (protons are spin-12 fermions; ground electronic state symmetric under proton exchange), para-hydrogen has total nuclear spin I=0. Its allowed rotational levels are
    1. odd J only
    2. all J
    3. even J only
    4. J=0 only
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Swapping the protons multiplies the rotational function by (−1)J. The total must be antisymmetric. The I=0 nuclear spin singlet is antisymmetric, so the rotation must be symmetric: even J. Ortho-hydrogen (I=1, symmetric) has odd J.
  26. MCQExam level

    At high temperature, the equilibrium ratio of ortho-H2 to para-H2 approaches
    1. 1:1
    2. 1:3
    3. 2:1
    4. 3:1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    When many J levels are populated, odd and even J have about equal rotational weight, so the ratio is set by the nuclear spin multiplicities: triplet (3) for ortho, singlet (1) for para. This 3:1 ratio shows up as alternating line intensities in the rotational Raman spectrum.
  27. MSQExam level

    For two identical spinless fermions with ψ(x1,x2)=−ψ(x2,x1), which statements about P(x1,x2)=|ψ|2 are correct?
    1. P(x,x)=0 for every x.
    2. P(x1,x2)=P(x2,x1).
    3. ∬Pdx1dx2=1.
    4. P is the same as for two distinguishable particles in the same orbitals.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Setting x1=x2 in the antisymmetry relation gives ψ(x,x)=0: a hole along the diagonal. |ψ|2 is symmetric because the overall sign squares away. The cross term −2Re[ϕa(1)ϕb(2)ϕb∗(1)ϕa∗(2)] makes it differ from the distinguishable case.
  28. NATExam level

    Two identical spinless bosons in an infinite well 0<x<a occupy n=1 and n=2 (symmetric state). With the same integrals as for the fermion case (⟨1|x|2⟩=−16a/9π2), ⟨(x1−x2)2⟩=ka2 with k= ______ (to four decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0385 (±0.0005)

    Distinguishable value 0.1033a2 minus 2|⟨1|x|2⟩|2=0.0649a2: 0.0385a2. The bosons huddle together; the fermions (0.168a2) keep apart.
  29. MCQExam level

    For two electrons in a spin-independent potential with a non-degenerate ground state of the two-electron problem, the ground state is
    1. a spin singlet with a symmetric spatial wavefunction
    2. a spin triplet with an antisymmetric spatial wavefunction
    3. an equal mixture of singlet and triplet
    4. a state with total spin 12
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The lowest spatial state of a two-particle Hamiltonian is nodeless and so symmetric; antisymmetric functions need a node along x1=x2, costing kinetic energy. A symmetric space requires the antisymmetric singlet. (Hund's rule favouring triplets applies to electrons in different degenerate orbitals.)
  30. MCQExam level

    Deuterons have spin 1 (bosons). At high temperature, the ratio of ortho-D2 (symmetric nuclear spin states, even J) to para-D2 (antisymmetric nuclear spin states, odd J) approaches
    1. 3:1
    2. 2:1
    3. 1:2
    4. 1:1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Two spin-1 nuclei give I=0,1,2: I=2 and 0 are symmetric (5+1=6 states), I=1 antisymmetric (3 states). For bosons the total must be symmetric, so symmetric spins go with even J. Ratio 6:3=2:1.

← All topics · Timed mock test →