Commutators and the uncertainty relation
Quantum mechanics · 79 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Commutators and the uncertainty relation.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
The commutator of position and momentum in one dimension isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
Act on a test function: . So .Why people get this wrong: Getting the sign backwards; .
-
MCQWarm-up
Which identity holds for all operators , , ?Answer and solution
Answer: A
Expand: . The operator that is "passed over" stays in its place: to the left, to the right.Why people get this wrong: Operators do not commute, so and are different; only the first ordering works.
-
NATWarm-up
The commutator . The value of is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 3
Use , or the product rule: . -
MCQWarm-up
Two observables and have a complete set of common eigenvectors if and only if- they anticommute
- they commute
- both have only positive eigenvalues
- their commutator is a non-zero constant
Answer and solution
Answer: B
If the two Hermitian operators can be diagonalised together; conversely, if they are both diagonal in one basis they commute. Such observables are called compatible. -
MSQWarm-up
Which pairs of operators commute?- and
- and
- and
- and
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C, D
The canonical relations are , so and commute but and do not. Positions commute among themselves. commutes with every component of . -
NATWarm-up
Two observables satisfy , and in a certain state . The smallest value that can have in that state is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 3
Robertson: . -
MCQWarm-up
If and are Hermitian operators, their commutator is- Hermitian
- anti-Hermitian, so that is Hermitian
- unitary
- always zero
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Take the adjoint: . An operator equal to minus its adjoint is anti-Hermitian. Multiplying by fixes this: . The canonical example is , which is times a real number.Why people get this wrong: Assuming that anything built from Hermitian operators is Hermitian; even the product is Hermitian only when and commute.
-
MCQStandard
For a differentiable function , the commutator equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: B
. So : momentum acts like on functions of position. -
MCQStandard
For a function with a power series, equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Term by term, , so . In the momentum representation, , which gives the same result directly. -
NATStandard
The commutator . The value of is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 4
(induction with ). For , . -
MCQStandard
For operators , , , the commutator equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: D
. -
MSQStandard
Let and be observables with . Which statements are correct?- They have a complete set of common eigenvectors.
- If is non-degenerate, every eigenvector of is an eigenvector of .
- Measuring and then and then again gives the same value both times.
- must be a function of .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Commuting observables share an eigenbasis; if an eigenvalue of is non-degenerate, is again in the one-dimensional eigenspace, so is an eigenvector of . After gives , a measurement keeps the state inside the eigenspace of , so is undisturbed. need not be a function of (for example and for a hydrogen atom). -
MCQStandard
For any two matrices, the trace of their commutator is- zero, so has no solution in finite matrices
- the product of their traces
- equal to
- purely imaginary
Answer and solution
Answer: A
, so . But . Position and momentum therefore need an infinite-dimensional space. -
NATStandard
A particle has the Gaussian wavefunction with nm. Its momentum spread is ______ nm.Answer and solution
Answer: 2.5 (±0.01)
, so . A real Gaussian is a minimum-uncertainty state: , so nm.Why people get this wrong: Taking the width in as the width in : the exponent was chosen so that has standard deviation .
-
MCQStandard
In the Mandelstam-Tamm form of the energy-time relation, with . Here means- the uncertainty of a time operator
- the time taken to measure the energy
- the time for to change by one standard deviation of
- the lifetime of the universe
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Apply the Robertson relation to and any observable : . Dividing gives the stated form, with the characteristic time of change. There is no time operator in quantum mechanics. -
MCQStandard
Which operator commutes with the Hamiltonian of a free particle?Answer and solution
Answer: B
, so momentum is conserved. , and , also fail. -
NATStandard
The commutator . The value of is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: -1
. So .Why people get this wrong: Writing instead of gives .
-
MCQStandard
The double commutator equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: C
First . Then , a pure number. Dividing by : for , the starting point of the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that gives .
-
NATStandard
The commutator . The value of is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 2
Use with , , : . So .Why people get this wrong: Pulling to the wrong side of the commutator: here stands to the left, so the result is , which happens to be ordered already.
-
MCQStandard
Using , the operator ( real) acting on a momentum eigenstate givesAnswer and solution
Answer: A
. So : the new state has momentum . In position space, . This is the momentum kick an atom gets when it absorbs a photon of wavenumber .Why people get this wrong: A sign slip in gives the lowered momentum.
-
MCQExam level
For observables and in any state, the generalised (Robertson) uncertainty relation is- for every pair
Answer and solution
Answer: D
With , , Schwarz gives . For and this is ; for other pairs the bound depends on the state.Why people get this wrong: The bound is special to canonically conjugate pairs; for and it is , which can be zero.
-
NATExam level
For , the product is , with ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.707 (±0.003)
By symmetry , and is real so . . . So , above the minimum .Why people get this wrong: Computing as but dropping the delta function in at the cusp gives , a negative "variance". Use .
-
NATExam level
A spin-half particle is in the state , with . The product is , with ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.25 (±0.001)
and , so and the product is . The Robertson bound is : the state saturates it. -
MCQExam level
In a state with , has zero spread while . Why is allowed?- Because in that state
- Because is not Hermitian
- Because uncertainty relations apply only to and
- Because is also zero
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The bound is , and in any . A zero lower bound allows a zero product. is not zero for . -
MSQExam level
Which identities hold for all operators , , ?- If and are Hermitian, is anti-Hermitian
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The first is the Jacobi identity (expand all twelve terms). , which for Hermitian is . But , which equals only if commutes with (true for and , not in general). -
MCQExam level
For real , the operator equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Use with : , a number, so the series stops: .Why people get this wrong: The sign depends on which exponential is on the left; check with .
-
MCQExam level
For a real, normalised, bound wavefunction , the expectation value isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
(integrating by parts). Then , and the Hermitian combination .Why people get this wrong: is not Hermitian, so its expectation value need not be real.
-
NATExam level
A two-level system is in with . The product is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.433 (±0.003)
, , and . So , and the product is . The Robertson bound is for a real state: the bound is far from tight here.Why people get this wrong: Assuming the product equals the Robertson bound; the bound can be zero while the product is not.
-
NATExam level
A system is prepared in , where the two energy eigenstates differ by eV. The shortest time after which the state is orthogonal to the initial one is ______ fs. (Use eV s.)Answer and solution
Answer: 4.14 (±0.03)
, whose modulus is . It first vanishes at fs. Since , this is : the fastest a state with this energy spread can change, with the energy-time bound saturated. -
NATExam level
For a harmonic oscillator, take a Gaussian state of width with and minimum uncertainty, so that . The minimum of over , in units of , is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.5 (±0.001)
The two terms have product , independent of , so by AM-GM their sum is at least , reached at . This equals the exact ground-state energy because the true ground state is this Gaussian.