Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / Commutators and the uncertainty relation

Commutators and the uncertainty relation

Quantum mechanics · 79 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Commutators and the uncertainty relation.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    The commutator [xˆ,pˆ] of position and momentum in one dimension is
    1. −iℏ
    2. ℏ
    3. 0
    4. iℏ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Act on a test function: [xˆ,pˆ]f=x(−iℏf′)−(−iℏ)(xf)′=−iℏxf′+iℏf+iℏxf′=iℏf. So [xˆ,pˆ]=iℏ.

    Why people get this wrong: Getting the sign backwards; [pˆ,xˆ]=−iℏ.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    Which identity holds for all operators A, B, C?
    1. [A,BC]=[A,B]C+B[A,C]
    2. [A,BC]=[A,B]C+[A,C]B
    3. [A,BC]=B[A,C]+C[A,B]
    4. [A,BC]=[A,B][A,C]
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Expand: [A,B]C+B[A,C]=ABC−BAC+BAC−BCA=ABC−BCA=[A,BC]. The operator that is "passed over" stays in its place: B to the left, C to the right.

    Why people get this wrong: Operators do not commute, so B[A,C] and [A,C]B are different; only the first ordering works.

  3. NATWarm-up

    The commutator [xˆ3,pˆ]=kiℏxˆ2. The value of k is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    Use [f(x),pˆ]=iℏf′(x), or the product rule: [x3,p]=x2[x,p]+x[x,p]x+[x,p]x2=3iℏx2.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    Two observables A and B have a complete set of common eigenvectors if and only if
    1. they anticommute
    2. they commute
    3. both have only positive eigenvalues
    4. their commutator is a non-zero constant
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    If [A,B]=0 the two Hermitian operators can be diagonalised together; conversely, if they are both diagonal in one basis they commute. Such observables are called compatible.
  5. MSQWarm-up

    Which pairs of operators commute?
    1. xˆ and pˆy
    2. xˆ and pˆx
    3. Lˆz and Lˆ2
    4. xˆ and yˆ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, C, D

    The canonical relations are [xi,pj]=iℏδij, so x and py commute but x and px do not. Positions commute among themselves. L2 commutes with every component of L→.
  6. NATWarm-up

    Two observables satisfy [A,B]=2iC, and in a certain state ⟨C⟩=3. The smallest value that σAσB can have in that state is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    Robertson: σAσB≥12|⟨[A,B]⟩|=12|2i⋅3|=3.
  7. MCQWarm-up

    If A and B are Hermitian operators, their commutator [A,B] is
    1. Hermitian
    2. anti-Hermitian, so that i[A,B] is Hermitian
    3. unitary
    4. always zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Take the adjoint: [A,B]†=(AB−BA)†=B†A†−A†B†=BA−AB=−[A,B]. An operator equal to minus its adjoint is anti-Hermitian. Multiplying by i fixes this: (i[A,B])†=−i(−[A,B])=i[A,B]. The canonical example is [xˆ,pˆ]=iℏ, which is i times a real number.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming that anything built from Hermitian operators is Hermitian; even the product AB is Hermitian only when A and B commute.

  8. MCQStandard

    For a differentiable function f, the commutator [pˆ,f(xˆ)] equals
    1. iℏf′(x)
    2. −iℏf′(x)
    3. −iℏf(x)
    4. 0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    [pˆ,f]g=−iℏ(fg)′+iℏfg′=−iℏf′g. So [pˆ,f(x)]=−iℏf′(x): momentum acts like −iℏd/dx on functions of position.
  9. MCQStandard

    For a function f with a power series, [xˆ,f(pˆ)] equals
    1. −iℏf′(p)
    2. 0
    3. iℏf′(p)
    4. iℏf(p)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Term by term, [x,pn]=niℏpn−1, so [x,f(p)]=iℏf′(p). In the momentum representation, xˆ=iℏd/dp, which gives the same result directly.
  10. NATStandard

    The commutator [xˆ,pˆ4]=kiℏpˆ3. The value of k is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4

    [x,pn]=niℏpn−1 (induction with [x,pn]=[x,pn−1]p+pn−1[x,p]). For n=4, k=4.
  11. MCQStandard

    For operators A, B, C, the commutator [AB,C] equals
    1. A[B,C]+B[A,C]
    2. [A,C]B+[B,C]A
    3. [A,C][B,C]
    4. A[B,C]+[A,C]B
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    A[B,C]+[A,C]B=ABC−ACB+ACB−CAB=ABC−CAB=[AB,C].
  12. MSQStandard

    Let A and B be observables with [A,B]=0. Which statements are correct?
    1. They have a complete set of common eigenvectors.
    2. If A is non-degenerate, every eigenvector of A is an eigenvector of B.
    3. Measuring A and then B and then A again gives the same A value both times.
    4. B must be a function of A.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Commuting observables share an eigenbasis; if an eigenvalue a of A is non-degenerate, B|a⟩ is again in the one-dimensional eigenspace, so |a⟩ is an eigenvector of B. After A gives a, a B measurement keeps the state inside the eigenspace of a, so A is undisturbed. B need not be a function of A (for example Lz and H for a hydrogen atom).
  13. MCQStandard

    For any two N×N matrices, the trace of their commutator is
    1. zero, so [x,p]=iℏ has no solution in finite matrices
    2. the product of their traces
    3. equal to N
    4. purely imaginary
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Tr(AB)=Tr(BA), so Tr[A,B]=0. But Tr(iℏ𝟙)=iℏN≠0. Position and momentum therefore need an infinite-dimensional space.
  14. NATStandard

    A particle has the Gaussian wavefunction ψ(x)∝e−x2/4σ2 with σ=0.20 nm. Its momentum spread Δp/ℏ is ______ nm−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.5 (±0.01)

    |ψ|2∝e−x2/2σ2, so Δx=σ. A real Gaussian is a minimum-uncertainty state: Δp=ℏ/(2Δx), so Δp/ℏ=1/(2×0.20)=2.5 nm−1.

    Why people get this wrong: Taking the width in ψ as the width in |ψ|2: the exponent x2/4σ2 was chosen so that |ψ|2 has standard deviation σ.

  15. MCQStandard

    In the Mandelstam-Tamm form of the energy-time relation, ΔEΔt≥ℏ/2 with Δt=ΔQ/|d⟨Q⟩/dt|. Here Δt means
    1. the uncertainty of a time operator
    2. the time taken to measure the energy
    3. the time for ⟨Q⟩ to change by one standard deviation of Q
    4. the lifetime of the universe
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Apply the Robertson relation to H and any observable Q: ΔEΔQ≥12|⟨[H,Q]⟩|=ℏ2|d⟨Q⟩/dt|. Dividing gives the stated form, with Δt the characteristic time of change. There is no time operator in quantum mechanics.
  16. MCQStandard

    Which operator commutes with the Hamiltonian H=pˆ2/2m of a free particle?
    1. xˆ
    2. pˆ
    3. xˆpˆ
    4. xˆ2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    [pˆ,pˆ2]=0, so momentum is conserved. [xˆ,pˆ2]=2iℏpˆ≠0, and xˆpˆ, xˆ2 also fail.
  17. NATStandard

    The commutator [xˆpˆ,xˆ]=kiℏxˆ. The value of k is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -1

    [xp,x]=x[p,x]+[x,x]p=x(−iℏ)=−iℏx. So k=−1.

    Why people get this wrong: Writing [x,p] instead of [p,x] gives +1.

  18. MCQStandard

    The double commutator [xˆ,[xˆ,pˆ2]] equals
    1. 2ℏ2
    2. 0
    3. −2ℏ2
    4. 2iℏpˆ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    First [xˆ,pˆ2]=pˆ[xˆ,pˆ]+[xˆ,pˆ]pˆ=2iℏpˆ. Then [xˆ,2iℏpˆ]=2iℏ⋅iℏ=−2ℏ2, a pure number. Dividing by 2m: [xˆ,[xˆ,H]]=−ℏ2/m for H=pˆ2/2m+V(xˆ), the starting point of the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that i⋅i=−1 gives +2ℏ2.

  19. NATStandard

    The commutator [xˆ2,xˆpˆ]=kiℏxˆ2. The value of k is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2

    Use [A,BC]=B[A,C]+[A,B]C with A=xˆ2, B=xˆ, C=pˆ: [xˆ2,xˆpˆ]=xˆ[xˆ2,pˆ]+[xˆ2,xˆ]pˆ=xˆ(2iℏxˆ)+0=2iℏxˆ2. So k=2.

    Why people get this wrong: Pulling xˆ to the wrong side of the commutator: here xˆ stands to the left, so the result is xˆ⋅2iℏxˆ, which happens to be ordered already.

  20. MCQStandard

    Using [pˆ,f(xˆ)]=−iℏf′(xˆ), the operator eikxˆ (k real) acting on a momentum eigenstate |p⟩ gives
    1. |p+ℏk⟩
    2. |p−ℏk⟩
    3. eikp|p⟩
    4. ℏk|p⟩
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    [pˆ,eikxˆ]=−iℏ(ik)eikxˆ=ℏkeikxˆ. So pˆeikxˆ|p⟩=eikxˆpˆ|p⟩+ℏkeikxˆ|p⟩=(p+ℏk)eikxˆ|p⟩: the new state has momentum p+ℏk. In position space, eikxeipx/ℏ=ei(p+ℏk)x/ℏ. This is the momentum kick an atom gets when it absorbs a photon of wavenumber k.

    Why people get this wrong: A sign slip in [pˆ,f]=−iℏf′ gives the lowered momentum.

  21. MCQExam level

    For observables A and B in any state, the generalised (Robertson) uncertainty relation is
    1. σAσB≥|⟨[A,B]⟩|
    2. σAσB≥12⟨{A,B}⟩
    3. σAσB≥ℏ/2 for every pair
    4. σAσB≥12|⟨[A,B]⟩|
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    With f=(A−⟨A⟩)ψ, g=(B−⟨B⟩)ψ, Schwarz gives σA2σB2≥|⟨f|g⟩|2≥(Im⟨f|g⟩)2=(12i⟨[A,B]⟩)2. For x and p this is ℏ/2; for other pairs the bound depends on the state.

    Why people get this wrong: The bound ℏ/2 is special to canonically conjugate pairs; for Lx and Ly it is ℏ2|⟨Lz⟩|, which can be zero.

  22. NATExam level

    For ψ(x)=1ae−|x|/a, the product ΔxΔp is kℏ, with k= ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.707 (±0.003)

    By symmetry ⟨x⟩=0, and ψ is real so ⟨p⟩=0. ⟨x2⟩=1a⋅2∫0∞x2e−2x/adx=2a⋅2a38=a22. ⟨p2⟩=ℏ2∫|ψ′|2dx=ℏ2⋅1a2∫|ψ|2dx=ℏ2/a2. So ΔxΔp=a2⋅ℏa=0.707ℏ, above the minimum 0.5ℏ.

    Why people get this wrong: Computing ⟨p2⟩ as −ℏ2∫ψψ′′ but dropping the delta function in ψ′′ at the cusp gives −ℏ2/a2, a negative "variance". Use ∫|ψ′|2.

  23. NATExam level

    A spin-half particle is in the state |↑z⟩, with S→=ℏ2σ→. The product ΔSxΔSy is kℏ2, with k= ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.25 (±0.001)

    ⟨Sx⟩=⟨Sy⟩=0 and Sx2=Sy2=ℏ2/4, so ΔSx=ΔSy=ℏ/2 and the product is ℏ2/4. The Robertson bound is 12|⟨[Sx,Sy]⟩|=12ℏ|⟨Sz⟩|=ℏ2/4: the state saturates it.
  24. MCQExam level

    In a state |l,m⟩ with m=0, Lz has zero spread while ΔLx>0. Why is ΔLzΔLx=0 allowed?
    1. Because ⟨[Lz,Lx]⟩=iℏ⟨Ly⟩=0 in that state
    2. Because Lx is not Hermitian
    3. Because uncertainty relations apply only to x and p
    4. Because ΔLx is also zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The bound is 12|⟨[Lz,Lx]⟩|=ℏ2|⟨Ly⟩|, and ⟨Ly⟩=0 in any |l,m⟩. A zero lower bound allows a zero product. ΔLx2=ℏ22[l(l+1)−m2] is not zero for l≥1.
  25. MSQExam level

    Which identities hold for all operators A, B, C?
    1. [A,[B,C]]+[B,[C,A]]+[C,[A,B]]=0
    2. [A,B]†=[B†,A†]
    3. If A and B are Hermitian, [A,B] is anti-Hermitian
    4. [A2,B]=2A[A,B]
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    The first is the Jacobi identity (expand all twelve terms). (AB−BA)†=B†A†−A†B†=[B†,A†], which for Hermitian A,B is [B,A]=−[A,B]. But [A2,B]=A[A,B]+[A,B]A, which equals 2A[A,B] only if A commutes with [A,B] (true for x and p, not in general).
  26. MCQExam level

    For real a, the operator eiapˆ/ℏxˆe−iapˆ/ℏ equals
    1. xˆ−a
    2. xˆ+a
    3. xˆ
    4. xˆ+iaℏ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Use eABe−A=B+[A,B]+12![A,[A,B]]+… with A=iapˆ/ℏ: [A,xˆ]=iaℏ(−iℏ)=a, a number, so the series stops: xˆ+a.

    Why people get this wrong: The sign depends on which exponential is on the left; check with [pˆ,xˆ]=−iℏ.

  27. MCQExam level

    For a real, normalised, bound wavefunction ψ(x), the expectation value ⟨xˆpˆ⟩ is
    1. 0
    2. ℏ/2
    3. iℏ/2
    4. −iℏ/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    ⟨xp⟩=−iℏ∫ψxψ′dx=−iℏ2∫x(ψ2)′dx=+iℏ2∫ψ2dx=iℏ2 (integrating by parts). Then ⟨px⟩=⟨xp⟩−iℏ=−iℏ/2, and the Hermitian combination ⟨xp+px⟩=0.

    Why people get this wrong: xˆpˆ is not Hermitian, so its expectation value need not be real.

  28. NATExam level

    A two-level system is in |ψ⟩=(cos⁡θ,sin⁡θ)T with θ=π/6. The product ΔσzΔσx is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.433 (±0.003)

    ⟨σz⟩=cos⁡2θ, ⟨σx⟩=sin⁡2θ, and σz2=σx2=1. So Δσz=|sin⁡2θ|, Δσx=|cos⁡2θ| and the product is 12|sin⁡4θ|=12sin⁡120∘=0.433. The Robertson bound |⟨σy⟩| is 0 for a real state: the bound is far from tight here.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming the product equals the Robertson bound; the bound can be zero while the product is not.

  29. NATExam level

    A system is prepared in (|1⟩+|2⟩)/2, where the two energy eigenstates differ by E2−E1=0.50 eV. The shortest time after which the state is orthogonal to the initial one is ______ fs. (Use h=4.136×10−15 eV s.)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4.14 (±0.03)

    ⟨ψ(0)|ψ(t)⟩=12(e−iE1t/ℏ+e−iE2t/ℏ), whose modulus is |cos⁡((E2−E1)t/2ℏ)|. It first vanishes at t=πℏ/(E2−E1)=h/(2×0.50)=4.14 fs. Since ΔE=(E2−E1)/2, this is t=πℏ/2ΔE: the fastest a state with this energy spread can change, with the energy-time bound saturated.
  30. NATExam level

    For a harmonic oscillator, take a Gaussian state of width σ with ⟨x⟩=⟨p⟩=0 and minimum uncertainty, so that ⟨H⟩=ℏ28mσ2+12mω2σ2. The minimum of ⟨H⟩ over σ, in units of ℏω, is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.5 (±0.001)

    The two terms have product ℏ2ω2/16, independent of σ, so by AM-GM their sum is at least 2ℏ2ω2/16=ℏω/2, reached at σ2=ℏ/2mω. This equals the exact ground-state energy because the true ground state is this Gaussian.

← All topics · Timed mock test →