The variational method and WKB
Quantum mechanics · 84 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
For any normalisable trial state obeying the boundary conditions, the variational principle says- , the first excited energy
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Expand : , because every . Equality holds only if is the ground state. So any guess gives an upper bound on the ground-state energy. -
MCQWarm-up
For a smooth potential well with two ordinary (soft) classical turning points, the WKB quantisation condition isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Each soft turning point adds a phase of when the WKB wave is matched to the decaying solution outside (the connection formulas), so , i.e. , The is the zero-point term. -
MCQWarm-up
The WKB approximation is reliable where- the potential is exactly constant
- the energy is close to the top of the well
- the potential changes little over one local de Broglie wavelength
- the particle is classically forbidden
Answer and solution
Answer: C
WKB treats the wave as locally plane with . It needs , i.e. the momentum changes by a small fraction over one wavelength. It fails near turning points, where and ; connection formulas bridge them. In a forbidden region it works too, with a decaying exponential, provided varies slowly. -
MCQWarm-up
A trial function is used for the harmonic oscillator and is minimised over . The result is- below
- exactly
Answer and solution
Answer: D
, minimised at , giving . The family contains the true ground state, so the method is exact. It can never go below . -
MCQWarm-up
If the trial state differs from the true ground state by a small admixture of size , the error in the variational energy is of orderAnswer and solution
Answer: A
With (), The ground state is a stationary point of , so a mediocre wavefunction still gives a good energy. -
MSQWarm-up
Which statements about the variational method are correct?- It gives an upper bound on the ground-state energy.
- It is exact if the trial family contains the true ground state.
- A trial function orthogonal to the ground state gives an upper bound on the first excited energy.
- It gives a lower bound on the ground-state energy.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
If , the expansion starts at , so ; in practice orthogonality is often guaranteed by symmetry (an odd trial function in an even potential). The method never gives a lower bound. -
MCQWarm-up
A student uses a trial function for the hydrogen ground state (exact energy eV) and reports a minimised eV. The right conclusion is that- the trial function is better than the exact one
- there is a mistake: the calculation is wrong or the trial function breaks the rules (not normalised, wrong boundary behaviour)
- the method has found an excited state
- nothing is wrong, since variational energies can lie on either side of the true value
Answer and solution
Answer: B
For any acceptable normalised trial state, . A value below eV is impossible, so something is wrong: a lost normalisation factor, an arithmetic slip, or a function that is not in the domain of . Excited states lie higher, not lower.Why people get this wrong: The variational energy is one-sided: it can only be too high.
-
NATStandard
For an infinite well , the trial function gives . The ratio of this to the exact ground-state energy is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.013 (±0.002)
Exact . Ratio : a 1.3% overestimate from a simple parabola. (Check of : , , so .) -
NATStandard
An electron meets a rectangular barrier that is eV above its energy and nm wide. In the WKB estimate , the exponent is ______ (to one decimal place). Use nm.Answer and solution
Answer: 10.2 (±0.1)
nm, so and . Doubling the width squares . -
MCQStandard
Applied to the harmonic oscillator, the WKB rule gives- , the exact result
- only for large
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The orbit in phase space is an ellipse with semi-axes and , area . Setting it to gives for every : an accident of the quadratic potential (WKB is also exact for the Coulomb potential with the Langer correction). -
MCQStandard
For a well with infinitely hard walls at both ends (and any smooth floor between), the WKB condition is- ,
Answer and solution
Answer: C
At a hard wall the wavefunction must vanish, with no phase leak into a forbidden region. Two walls give ; for a flat floor this reproduces the exact square-well levels . -
MCQStandard
In a potential , WKB predicts that at large the levels grow as . For the linear potential this isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
The turning point is and , so . For : . Checks: gives (oscillator), gives (square well). -
MCQStandard
For helium with trial function , one finds eV. The best effective charge isAnswer and solution
Answer: A
, so . Each electron partly screens the nucleus from the other: . -
MCQStandard
Which requirement must a variational trial function satisfy?- It must solve the Schrödinger equation.
- It must be normalisable and obey the boundary conditions of the problem.
- It must have the exact energy.
- It must be an eigenfunction of the kinetic energy.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The bound needs only that the trial state lies in the space where acts: normalisable, with the right boundary conditions (for example zero at hard walls) and finite kinetic energy. It need not satisfy any equation; it can even have kinks. -
MCQStandard
For the attractive delta potential , a Gaussian trial function gives the best energy , while the exact energy is . The ratio of variational to exact energy isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
. The variational energy is higher (less negative), as it must be. A Gaussian is smooth at the origin, while the true has a cusp there, so the guess is poor.Why people get this wrong: Thinking a ratio below 1 means the bound is violated: both energies are negative, and lies above .
-
MSQStandard
Which statements about the WKB wavefunction are correct?- Its amplitude diverges at a classical turning point.
- matches the classical time spent in each .
- In a forbidden region it becomes a real growing or decaying exponential.
- It is exact for every potential.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
At the formula blows up; the true solution is an Airy function there. Away from turning points , the classical dwell time. Where , and the phase becomes . It is exact only in special cases such as constant . -
MCQStandard
In the WKB approximation, the probability density in a classically allowed region varies as- a constant
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Conservation of probability current with a slowly varying amplitude gives const, so (averaged over the fast oscillations). A slow particle spends more time in a region, just as in classical mechanics. -
NATStandard
A harmonic oscillator has eV. Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) quantisation, which is exact here, gives the number of states with energy at or below eV (measured from the bottom of the well) as ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 13
gives . We need , i.e. . With there are 13 states. (Each state takes up an area of phase space.)Why people get this wrong: suggests 12; counting must start from and include the zero-point offset.
-
MCQStandard
In Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) quantisation for a one-dimensional bound particle, the phase-space area enclosed between the orbits of two neighbouring levels isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
, so neighbouring orbits differ by exactly in enclosed area. Each quantum state "occupies" an area of phase space, the rule used to count states in statistical mechanics.Why people get this wrong: Mixing and ; the area is .
-
NATExam level
For hydrogen, a Gaussian trial function gives the best energy Ry. With Ry eV, this is ______ eV (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: -11.54 (±0.02)
and . Minimising gives Ry eV, 15% above the true eV: the Gaussian has no cusp at the nucleus and falls off too fast. -
NATExam level
For the harmonic oscillator, take the trial function and minimise over . The result is with ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.707 (±0.002)
Normalised, : (the kink contributes no extra term when computed as ), and , so . has minimum , above the exact . -
NATExam level
A particle of mass bounces on a hard floor under gravity ( for ). WKB with one hard wall and one soft turning point gives . The value of (ground state) is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.32 (±0.004)
Hard wall plus soft turning point: . With : . So and . The exact value (first zero of the Airy function) is . -
MCQExam level
The helium ground-state energy is about eV. Which estimate does the screened variational trial function () give?- eV
- eV
- eV
- eV
Answer and solution
Answer: A
eV, above the true value as required. eV ignores the repulsion; eV is first-order perturbation theory with (). Any value below eV (such as ) would violate the variational bound. -
NATExam level
A trial state is built from two orthonormal functions with eV. The best variational estimate of the ground-state energy is ______ eV (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: -2.081 (±0.002)
Minimising over (Rayleigh-Ritz) means finding the lowest eigenvalue of the matrix: eV. It lies below eV (the best single function) and above the true . -
NATExam level
For , WKB gives . The ground-state coefficient is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.116 (±0.003)
Two soft turning points at : . So and (exact ; WKB is worst for the ground state). -
MSQExam level
A Gaussian trial function is used for the hydrogen ground state. Which statements are correct?- The result is an upper bound on eV.
- It misses the cusp of the true wavefunction at .
- Its tail falls off faster than the true .
- With the best it gives exactly eV.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The best Gaussian gives eV, above eV. The true function has a cusp ( at the nucleus) and a simple exponential tail; a Gaussian has neither, so no reaches the exact energy. -
MCQExam level
For a potential with , a trial function that is odd in gives an upper bound on- the ground-state energy only
- the first excited energy
- the second excited energy
- nothing useful, because odd functions are not allowed
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The ground state of a symmetric 1D potential is even, so an odd trial function has automatically, and . The first excited state is odd, so the bound can be tight. (For the oscillator, gives exactly.) -
MCQExam level
A one-parameter trial family gives with . The variational estimate isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
gives . Then . At the minimum the two terms are equal: the kinetic and potential energies share the total equally, as the virial theorem for requires. -
MCQExam level
In the WKB estimate , doubling the width of a rectangular barrier (same height) changes the transmission from to approximatelyAnswer and solution
Answer: D
The exponent doubles: . For this means . Exponential sensitivity is why tunnelling currents in a scanning tunnelling microscope respond so strongly to distance.Why people get this wrong: Thinking of an Ohmic resistor; tunnelling is exponential in width, not linear.
-
MCQExam level
A "half oscillator" has for and an infinite wall at . WKB with one hard wall and one soft turning point gives the levelsAnswer and solution
Answer: A
is half the full-oscillator integral, . Setting it to gives in units of : exactly the odd oscillator levels, which vanish at as the wall demands.