Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling

The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling

Modern physics · 9 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. NATHard

    In the ground state of a harmonic oscillator, |ψ0|2∝e−x2/x02, where x=±x0 are the classical turning points at energy 12ℏω. The probability of finding the particle outside the classically allowed region is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.157 (±0.002)

    With u=x/x0, P(|x|>x0)=∫|u|>1e−u2du∫e−u2du=1−erf(1)=1−0.8427=0.157. (Check the turning point: 12mω2x02=12ℏω gives x02=ℏ/mω, and ψ0∝e−mωx2/2ℏ, so |ψ0|2∝e−x2/x02.)

    Why people get this wrong: Almost 16% of the time the particle is where classical physics says it can never be.

  2. MSQHard

    Which statements are correct for a particle with Hamiltonian H=p2/2m+V(x), with V not depending on time?
    1. [x,p]=iℏ.
    2. ⟨H⟩ does not change with time for any state.
    3. d⟨x⟩/dt=⟨p⟩/m.
    4. In a stationary state ⟨x⟩ oscillates at angular frequency E/ℏ.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    First: canonical commutator. Second: d⟨A⟩/dt=(i/ℏ)⟨[H,A]⟩ and [H,H]=0. Third: [H,x]=−iℏp/m, giving d⟨x⟩/dt=⟨p⟩/m (Ehrenfest). Fourth: false; in a stationary state every such expectation value is constant.

    Why people get this wrong: Only superpositions of different energies make expectation values move.

  3. MCQHard

    A particle of mass m moves in V=∞ for x<0, V=0 for 0<x<a and V=V0 for x>a. It has at least one bound state only if
    1. V0>0, whatever its size
    2. V0>π2ℏ2/2ma2
    3. V0>π2ℏ2/8ma2
    4. V0>ℏ2/2ma2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The wall forces ψ(0)=0, so the solutions are exactly the odd states of a symmetric well of width 2a and depth V0. The first odd state needs z0=a2mV0/ℏ>π/2, i.e. V0>π2ℏ2/8ma2. Unlike the symmetric 1D well, a too-shallow step binds nothing. This is the same condition as for an s-wave bound state in a 3D spherical well of radius a.

    Why people get this wrong: "Any attractive well binds in 1D" holds for symmetric wells without a wall; the wall kills the even ground state.

  4. NATTop rank

    A particle is in the ground state of an infinite well 0<x<L. Suddenly the right wall is moved to x=2L, too fast for the wavefunction to change. The probability that the particle is then found in the ground state of the new, wider well is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.36 (±0.002)

    Old state ψ=2/Lsin⁡(πx/L) on (0,L), zero beyond. New ground state ϕ1=1/Lsin⁡(πx/2L) on (0,2L). Overlap c=∫0Lψϕ1dx=2L∫0Lsin⁡πxLsin⁡πx2Ldx. With u=πx/L: c=2π∫0πsin⁡usin⁡u2du=2π⋅43=423π. Probability |c|2=32/(9π2)=0.360.

    Why people get this wrong: The new ground state is normalised over the new width 2L: its amplitude is 1/L, not 2/L.

  5. MSQTop rank

    Compare a finite square well of depth V0 and width a with an infinite well of the same width. Which statements are correct?
    1. In one dimension the finite well always has at least one bound state.
    2. Measured from the bottom of the well, each bound-state energy of the finite well is lower than the matching level of the infinite well.
    3. The number of bound states depends on V0 and a only through the combination V0a2 (for a given mass).
    4. The finite-well wavefunctions vanish at the walls.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    First: the even solution exists for any z0>0. Second: the wave leaks into the walls, so it is effectively longer and its energy lower. Third: the count is set by z0=(a/2)2mV0/ℏ, which depends on V0a2. Fourth: false; at the walls ψ joins smoothly on to decaying exponentials.

    Why people get this wrong: Only the infinite well forces ψ=0 at the walls.

  6. NATTop rank

    An electron of energy 1.0 eV meets a barrier of height 2.0 eV and width 0.20 nm. Use the exact result T=[1+V02sinh2⁡(κa)4E(V0−E)]−1 with ℏ2/(2me)=0.0381 eV nm2. T is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.404 (±0.003)

    κ=1.0/0.0381=5.123 nm−1, κa=1.025, sinh⁡(1.025)=1.214, sinh2⁡=1.473. The prefactor V02/[4E(V0−E)]=4/(4×1×1)=1. T=1/(1+1.473)=0.404.

    Why people get this wrong: Here κa≈1, so the thick-barrier formula e−2κa=0.129 is badly wrong. Check κa before using it.

  7. NATTop rank

    A particle in an infinite well 0<x<L has the normalised wavefunction ψ(x)=30/L5x(L−x). The probability that an energy measurement gives the ground-state energy E1 is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.999 (±0.001)

    c1=∫0L2/Lsin⁡(πx/L)30/L5x(L−x)dx. With u=πx/L, ∫0πu(π−u)sin⁡udu=4, so c1=60⋅4/π3=815/π3. Probability |c1|2=960/π6=0.9986, about 0.999. The parabola is almost exactly the sine.

    Why people get this wrong: Even n give zero (the parabola is even about the centre); the remaining 0.14% is spread over n=3,5,…

  8. MCQTop rank

    A harmonic oscillator is in the state ψ=(ψ0+ψ1)/2 at t=0, with ψ0,ψ1 the two lowest real eigenfunctions. Which describes ⟨x⟩(t)?
    1. It is zero at all times.
    2. It oscillates at angular frequency 32ω.
    3. It oscillates at angular frequency ω, like the classical oscillator.
    4. It decays to zero.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The diagonal terms ⟨ψ0|x|ψ0⟩ and ⟨ψ1|x|ψ1⟩ vanish by parity. The two cross terms, each with weight 12, add to ⟨x⟩(t)=Re[⟨ψ0|x|ψ1⟩e−i(E1−E0)t/ℏ]. E1−E0=ℏω and ⟨ψ0|x|ψ1⟩=ℏ/2mω≠0, so ⟨x⟩=ℏ/2mωcos⁡ωt: classical motion at ω.

    Why people get this wrong: The frequency comes from the difference of the two energies, not from either energy alone (32ω is E1/ℏ).

  9. MSQTop rank

    Which statements about the existence of bound states are correct?
    1. In one dimension, a symmetric attractive square well of any depth has at least one bound state.
    2. In three dimensions, a spherical square well of any depth has at least one bound state.
    3. For a spherical square well of radius a, an s-wave bound state needs V0a2>π2ℏ2/8m.
    4. Making a well deeper can only remove bound states, never add them.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, C

    In 1D the even ground state survives at any depth: its energy just moves up to near zero as the well gets shallow. In 3D the radial function u=rψ must vanish at r=0, making the problem the "wall plus well" in one dimension, which needs V0a2>π2ℏ2/8m. Deepening a well always adds states (each time z0 passes a multiple of π/2), never removes them.

    Why people get this wrong: The 1D result does not carry over to 3D, because the radial wave function must vanish at the origin.

← All topics · Timed mock test →