The Schrödinger equation: wells, steps and tunnelling
Modern physics · 9 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATHard
In the ground state of a harmonic oscillator, , where are the classical turning points at energy . The probability of finding the particle outside the classically allowed region is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.157 (±0.002)
With , . (Check the turning point: gives , and , so .)Why people get this wrong: Almost 16% of the time the particle is where classical physics says it can never be.
-
MSQHard
Which statements are correct for a particle with Hamiltonian , with not depending on time?- .
- does not change with time for any state.
- .
- In a stationary state oscillates at angular frequency .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
First: canonical commutator. Second: and . Third: , giving (Ehrenfest). Fourth: false; in a stationary state every such expectation value is constant.Why people get this wrong: Only superpositions of different energies make expectation values move.
-
MCQHard
A particle of mass moves in for , for and for . It has at least one bound state only if- , whatever its size
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The wall forces , so the solutions are exactly the odd states of a symmetric well of width and depth . The first odd state needs , i.e. . Unlike the symmetric 1D well, a too-shallow step binds nothing. This is the same condition as for an -wave bound state in a 3D spherical well of radius .Why people get this wrong: "Any attractive well binds in 1D" holds for symmetric wells without a wall; the wall kills the even ground state.
-
NATTop rank
A particle is in the ground state of an infinite well . Suddenly the right wall is moved to , too fast for the wavefunction to change. The probability that the particle is then found in the ground state of the new, wider well is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.36 (±0.002)
Old state on , zero beyond. New ground state on . Overlap . With : . Probability .Why people get this wrong: The new ground state is normalised over the new width : its amplitude is , not .
-
MSQTop rank
Compare a finite square well of depth and width with an infinite well of the same width. Which statements are correct?- In one dimension the finite well always has at least one bound state.
- Measured from the bottom of the well, each bound-state energy of the finite well is lower than the matching level of the infinite well.
- The number of bound states depends on and only through the combination (for a given mass).
- The finite-well wavefunctions vanish at the walls.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
First: the even solution exists for any . Second: the wave leaks into the walls, so it is effectively longer and its energy lower. Third: the count is set by , which depends on . Fourth: false; at the walls joins smoothly on to decaying exponentials.Why people get this wrong: Only the infinite well forces at the walls.
-
NATTop rank
An electron of energy eV meets a barrier of height eV and width nm. Use the exact result with eV nm. is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.404 (±0.003)
nm, , , . The prefactor . .Why people get this wrong: Here , so the thick-barrier formula is badly wrong. Check before using it.
-
NATTop rank
A particle in an infinite well has the normalised wavefunction . The probability that an energy measurement gives the ground-state energy is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.999 (±0.001)
. With , , so . Probability , about . The parabola is almost exactly the sine.Why people get this wrong: Even give zero (the parabola is even about the centre); the remaining is spread over
-
MCQTop rank
A harmonic oscillator is in the state at , with the two lowest real eigenfunctions. Which describes ?- It is zero at all times.
- It oscillates at angular frequency .
- It oscillates at angular frequency , like the classical oscillator.
- It decays to zero.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The diagonal terms and vanish by parity. The two cross terms, each with weight , add to . and , so : classical motion at .Why people get this wrong: The frequency comes from the difference of the two energies, not from either energy alone ( is ).
-
MSQTop rank
Which statements about the existence of bound states are correct?- In one dimension, a symmetric attractive square well of any depth has at least one bound state.
- In three dimensions, a spherical square well of any depth has at least one bound state.
- For a spherical square well of radius , an -wave bound state needs .
- Making a well deeper can only remove bound states, never add them.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C
In 1D the even ground state survives at any depth: its energy just moves up to near zero as the well gets shallow. In 3D the radial function must vanish at , making the problem the "wall plus well" in one dimension, which needs . Deepening a well always adds states (each time passes a multiple of ), never removes them.Why people get this wrong: The 1D result does not carry over to 3D, because the radial wave function must vanish at the origin.