Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Lattice vibrations and phonons

Lattice vibrations and phonons

Solid state physics and devices · 88 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    For a chain of atoms of mass m and spacing a joined by springs of constant K (nearest neighbours only), the dispersion relation is
    1. ω=K/mka
    2. ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka/2)|
    3. ω=2K/m|cos⁡(ka/2)|
    4. ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka)|
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Newton for atom n: mu¨n=K(un+1−un)−K(un−un−1). With un=Aei(kna−ωt): −mω2=K(eika+e−ika−2)=−4Ksin2⁡(ka/2). So ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka/2)|, linear only for small k.

    Why people get this wrong: The linear form is just the long-wavelength limit; the cosine form would give a maximum frequency at k=0.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    At the edge of the first Brillouin zone (k=π/a), the group velocity of a wave on a monatomic chain is
    1. equal to the speed of sound
    2. infinite
    3. zero
    4. twice the speed of sound
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    vg=dω/dk=aK/mcos⁡(ka/2), which vanishes at ka=π. Neighbouring atoms move in exact opposition: a standing wave, the Bragg-reflected combination of waves travelling both ways, which carries no energy.

    Why people get this wrong: The phase velocity ω/k is not zero there; only the group velocity is.

  3. MCQWarm-up

    A 3D crystal has two atoms in each primitive cell. How many phonon branches does it have?
    1. 2
    2. 3
    3. 6
    4. 12
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Each atom can move in 3 directions, so a cell has 3p=6 degrees of freedom and there are 6 branches: 3 acoustic (one longitudinal, two transverse) and 3p−3=3 optical.

    Why people get this wrong: Counting only the atoms (2) or only the directions (3).

  4. MCQWarm-up

    A phonon is
    1. a quantum of energy ℏω in one normal mode of lattice vibration
    2. an electron bound to a vibrating ion
    3. a photon trapped inside a crystal
    4. the smallest piece of a crystal that can vibrate
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Each normal mode of a harmonic lattice is an independent oscillator with energies (n+12)ℏω. Raising n by one adds one phonon of that mode. Phonons are bosons: any number can occupy a mode.

    Why people get this wrong: A phonon belongs to the whole crystal (a collective mode), not to one atom.

  5. NATWarm-up

    A monatomic chain has atoms of mass 1.0×10−26 kg joined by springs of 10 N/m. Its highest vibration angular frequency is ______ ×1013 rad/s (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6.32 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)

    ωmax=2K/m=210/10−26=2×3.162×1013=6.32×1013 rad/s, reached at the zone boundary.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the factor 2 gives K/m, the frequency of one mass on one spring.

  6. MCQWarm-up

    In thermal equilibrium, the mean number of phonons in a mode of frequency ω is given by
    1. Fermi-Dirac statistics with μ=EF
    2. Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics
    3. Bose-Einstein statistics with μ=0
    4. Bose-Einstein statistics with μ fixed by the number of atoms
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Phonons are bosons whose number is not conserved (the lattice creates and destroys them freely), so the chemical potential is zero: ⟨n⟩=1/(eℏω/kBT−1). This is exactly the mean excitation of a quantum oscillator.

    Why people get this wrong: Phonon number is not tied to the number of atoms; only the number of modes is.

  7. MCQWarm-up

    An optical phonon has frequency ν=10 THz. With h=4.136×10−15 eV s, its energy is about
    1. 6.6 meV
    2. 4.1 meV
    3. 41 meV
    4. 414 meV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    E=hν=4.136×10−15×1013=4.14×10−2 eV =41 meV, comparable to kBT at about 480 K. A handy rule: 1 THz ≈4.1 meV.

    Why people get this wrong: 6.6 meV is ℏν; with a frequency in hertz the energy is hν (or ℏω).

  8. NATStandard

    A chain of atoms of mass 40 u with spacing 3.0 Å and spring constant 15 N/m carries long-wavelength sound at a speed of ______ m/s (to the nearest 10 m/s). Use 1 u =1.6605×10−27 kg.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4510 m/s (±10)

    For small k, ω≈aK/mk, so vs=aK/m. m=6.642×10−26 kg, 15/6.642×10−26=1.503×1013 s−1, vs=3.0×10−10×1.503×1013=4.51×103 m/s.

    Why people get this wrong: Using the mass in u without converting to kg.

  9. MCQStandard

    In the long-wavelength limit (ka≪1), acoustic phonons of a monatomic chain
    1. have a frequency independent of k
    2. have ω∝k, with equal phase and group velocities (no dispersion)
    3. have ω∝k2, like free particles
    4. have zero group velocity
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    sin⁡(ka/2)≈ka/2 gives ω≈aK/mk. Phase and group velocity both equal aK/m: the chain behaves as a continuous elastic string, which is why ordinary sound does not disperse.

    Why people get this wrong: ω∝k2 is the dispersion of magnons in a ferromagnet (and of free particles), not of phonons.

  10. MCQStandard

    In a diatomic chain (masses M1 and M2), the optical mode at k=0 has
    1. both atoms moving together with equal amplitudes
    2. only the heavier atoms moving
    3. zero frequency
    4. neighbouring atoms moving in opposite directions with amplitudes in the ratio M2:M1, so the centre of mass stays still
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    At k=0 every cell does the same thing, so the motion is just the two atoms of a cell oscillating against each other on their springs: M1u1+M2u2=0, i.e. u1/u2=−M2/M1, with ω2=2K(1/M1+1/M2). In an ionic crystal this sets up an oscillating dipole that couples to infrared light, hence "optical".

    Why people get this wrong: Moving together with equal amplitudes is the acoustic mode at k=0 (a rigid translation, ω=0).

  11. NATStandard

    A diatomic chain has masses M1=2.0×10−26 kg and M2=1.0×10−26 kg joined alternately by identical springs of 20 N/m. The optical-branch frequency at k=0 is ______ ×1013 rad/s (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 7.75 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)

    ω2=2K(1M1+1M2)=40×(5×1025+1026)=6.0×1027 s−2, so ω=7.75×1013 rad/s.

    Why people get this wrong: Using K instead of 2K: each atom has two springs.

  12. MSQStandard

    For a diatomic chain with masses M1>M2 and equal springs K, which statements are correct?
    1. At the zone boundary the acoustic frequency is 2K/M1.
    2. At the zone boundary the optical frequency is 2K/M2.
    3. The gap between the branches grows as the two masses get closer.
    4. A monatomic chain also has an optical branch.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B

    At ka=π, sin2⁡(ka/2)=1 and the roots become ω2=2K/M1 (only the heavy atoms move) and 2K/M2 (only the light ones). The gap 2K/M2−2K/M1 shrinks to zero as M1→M2; then the chain is monatomic with half the period, and its single branch, folded back, is all that remains. A one-atom basis has no optical branch.

    Why people get this wrong: In the boundary modes one kind of atom stays at rest: the heavy atoms set the acoustic, the light the optical frequency.

  13. NATStandard

    Cubic perovskite SrTiO3 has five atoms in its primitive cell. The number of optical phonon branches is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 12

    3p=15 branches in all. Three are acoustic (frequency →0 as k→0: the whole crystal translating). The other 15−3=12 are optical.

    Why people get this wrong: Answering 15 (all branches) or 10 (2p).

  14. MCQStandard

    A phonon of wave vector q→ in a crystal
    1. carries crystal momentum ℏq→, defined only up to ℏG→
    2. carries real momentum ℏq→ that moves the crystal's centre of mass
    3. has no momentum of any kind
    4. has momentum ℏω/c
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Atom displacements un∝eiq→⋅R→n are unchanged by q→→q→+G→, so q→ is fixed only modulo G→. ℏq→ behaves like a momentum in collisions (with neutrons, electrons, photons, other phonons) but is conserved only up to ℏG→. Except for q→=0, a phonon carries no physical momentum: the atoms just oscillate about fixed sites.

    Why people get this wrong: ℏω/c is the momentum of a photon of the same frequency, irrelevant here.

  15. MCQStandard

    In an Umklapp (U) process between phonons,
    1. the total crystal momentum is exactly conserved and heat flow is unaffected
    2. the wave vectors satisfy q→1+q→2=q→3+G→ with G→≠0, which degrades the heat current
    3. a phonon is absorbed by an electron
    4. the number of phonons stays fixed
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    When q→1+q→2 falls outside the first zone, it is brought back by a reciprocal vector: q→3=q→1+q→2−G→. The new phonon may travel roughly backwards, so the net phonon flow is reversed: U processes give an insulator its finite thermal resistance. Normal processes (G→=0) conserve the total phonon momentum and alone cannot relax a heat current.

    Why people get this wrong: Normal processes redistribute energy among phonons but cannot by themselves stop a heat current.

  16. MCQStandard

    On a monatomic chain with sound speed vs, the group velocity at k=π/(2a) (half way to the zone edge) is
    1. vs
    2. vs/2
    3. 0
    4. vs/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    vg=aK/mcos⁡(ka/2)=vscos⁡(π/4)=vs/2=0.707vs.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming the velocity falls linearly to zero at the zone edge (vs/2).

  17. MSQStandard

    Which statements about measuring phonon dispersion are correct?
    1. Inelastic neutron scattering uses conservation of energy and of crystal momentum.
    2. Thermal neutrons have energies (tens of meV) comparable to phonon energies.
    3. For 1 Å X-rays (about 12 keV) a phonon changes the photon energy by only about one part in 106.
    4. Raman scattering of visible light probes phonons across the whole Brillouin zone.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Neutron: Ei−Ef=±ℏω and k→i−k→f=q→+G→; measuring both gives ω(q→) point by point. A 25 meV neutron changes its energy by a large fraction when it makes a 10 meV phonon; a 12 keV photon changes by 10−6, which needs special meV-resolution instruments. Visible photons have k∼10−3 of a zone, so Raman sees only q≈0 optical phonons.

    Why people get this wrong: Light can only give a small q; whole-zone dispersion needs neutrons (or inelastic X-rays).

  18. MCQStandard

    On a monatomic chain with spacing a, a wave with k=0.4π/a and one with k=2.4π/a describe
    1. exactly the same atomic displacements
    2. waves of different frequency
    3. waves moving in opposite directions with the same speed
    4. a mode and its optical partner
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The displacements are un∝eikna. The two k values differ by 2π/a, and ei(2π/a)na=e2πin=1. The atoms (the only things that exist) move identically; the shorter wave just wiggles between atoms where there is nothing. So k can always be taken in the first zone.

    Why people get this wrong: A continuous string would distinguish them; a lattice cannot.

  19. NATStandard

    The optical phonon of silicon at k≈0 gives a Raman shift of 520 cm−1. Its energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 64.5 meV (±0.1)

    E=hcν~; 1 cm−1 corresponds to 0.12398 meV. 520×0.12398=64.5 meV (frequency 15.6 THz). The shift of the scattered light equals the phonon energy created (Stokes) or absorbed (anti-Stokes).

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting to convert cm−1 to m−1 (a factor of 100).

  20. MCQStandard

    A chain of N atoms (spacing a) with periodic (Born-von Kármán) boundary conditions has allowed wave vectors spaced by
    1. π/a
    2. 2π/(Na)
    3. π/(Na)
    4. 2π/a
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Periodicity un+N=un requires eikNa=1, so k=2πj/(Na) with j an integer. Taking N consecutive values (one zone of width 2π/a) gives exactly N distinct modes, one per atom.

    Why people get this wrong: π/(Na) is the spacing for fixed ends (standing waves with k>0 only); the count of modes is the same.

  21. MSQStandard

    For a monatomic chain (mass m, spring K, spacing a), which statements are correct?
    1. The highest frequency is 2K/m.
    2. ω(k) is periodic in k with period 2π/a.
    3. At k=π/a neighbouring atoms move in opposite directions.
    4. The speed of sound does not depend on a.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka/2)| peaks at 2K/m and repeats every Δk=2π/a. At ka=π, un+1/un=eiπ=−1. The sound speed vs=aK/m is proportional to a (for fixed K and m).

    Why people get this wrong: Statement 4 forgets that the sound speed is the slope ω/k at small k, which brings in a.

  22. NATStandard

    The Raman-active optical phonon of natural silicon (take all atoms as 28Si) is at 520 cm−1. In a crystal made entirely of 30Si, with the same spring constants, it is at ______ cm−1 (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 502.4 cm⁻¹ (±0.3)

    The interatomic forces come from the electrons and do not depend on the nuclear mass, so every phonon frequency scales as 1/m. ω′=52028/30=520×0.9661=502.4 cm−1. Isotope shifts like this are used to check which atoms take part in a vibration.

    Why people get this wrong: Frequencies scale as m−1/2, not m−1: the shift is about 3.4%, not 6.7%.

  23. MSQStandard

    A monatomic chain (mass m, spring constant K) is stretched so that its spacing a doubles, with m and K unchanged. Which statements are correct?
    1. The highest frequency 2K/m is unchanged.
    2. The speed of long-wavelength sound doubles.
    3. The first Brillouin zone becomes half as wide.
    4. The number of vibrational modes per atom changes.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka/2)|: the maximum does not involve a. Sound speed v=aK/m is proportional to a. The zone width 2π/a halves. There is still one mode per atom in 1D: fewer k per unit length of zone, but the zone is narrower in proportion.

    Why people get this wrong: The maximum frequency depends on masses and springs only; the spacing sets the k scale.

  24. NATExam level

    A diatomic chain has atoms of 40 u and 20 u joined alternately by identical springs of 30 N/m. The width of the frequency gap at the zone boundary is ______ ×1013 rad/s (to two decimal places). Use 1 u =1.6605×10−27 kg.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.25 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)

    At ka=π: ω−=2K/M1=60/6.642×10−26=3.006×1013 rad/s and ω+=2K/M2=60/3.321×10−26=4.251×1013 rad/s. Gap =1.25×1013 rad/s. No travelling wave exists at these frequencies; a wave sent in is damped.

    Why people get this wrong: Using K instead of 2K in the boundary frequencies.

  25. NATExam level

    Neutron measurements on a crystal show that its longitudinal acoustic branch along a direction of atomic spacing 2.5 Å follows ω=ωm|sin⁡(ka/2)| with ωm=4.0×1013 rad/s. The longitudinal sound speed in that direction is ______ m/s.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5000 m/s (±5)

    For small k: ω≈ωmka/2, so vs=ωma/2=4.0×1013×2.5×10−10/2=5.0×103 m/s.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the 1/2 from sin⁡(ka/2)≈ka/2.

  26. MCQExam level

    For a monatomic chain with sound speed vs, the phase velocity at the zone boundary k=π/a is
    1. vs
    2. 0
    3. (π/2)vs
    4. (2/π)vs
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    vp=ω/k=2K/m/(π/a)=(2/π)aK/m=(2/π)vs≈0.64vs. The group velocity there is zero, but the phase velocity is not.

    Why people get this wrong: Confusing phase and group velocity at the zone edge.

  27. NATExam level

    A monatomic chain of 900 atoms (periodic boundary conditions) has maximum frequency ωm. The number of normal modes with ω<ωm/2 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 300

    Modes are evenly spaced in k (N of them in −π/a<k≤π/a). ω<ωm/2 means |sin⁡(ka/2)|<12, i.e. |k|<π/(3a): one third of the zone. So N/3=300 modes. In general N(ω)=(2N/π)arcsin⁡(ω/ωm).

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming modes are evenly spread in ω (giving 450).

  28. MCQExam level

    The phonon density of states g(ω) of a monatomic chain, near its maximum frequency ωm,
    1. falls smoothly to zero
    2. is constant
    3. diverges as (ωm−ω)−2
    4. diverges as (ωm−ω)−1/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    g(ω)=dNdω=2Nπ1ωm2−ω2. Near ωm, ωm2−ω2≈2ωm(ωm−ω), giving (ωm−ω)−1/2. This van Hove singularity comes from the flat dispersion (vg=0) at the zone edge; in 3D such points give kinks rather than divergences.

    Why people get this wrong: Expecting the density to vanish at the top of the band; it is largest there in 1D.

  29. NATExam level

    NaCl has static dielectric constant ε(0)=5.9 and high-frequency value ε(∞)=2.25. By the Lyddane-Sachs-Teller relation, ωLO/ωTO at k≈0 is ______ (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.62 (±0.01)

    LST: ωLO2ωTO2=ε(0)ε(∞). 5.9/2.25=2.622=1.62. The longitudinal mode is stiffer because its oscillating polarisation makes a restoring electric field that the transverse mode lacks.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the square root.

  30. MSQExam level

    Which statements about optical phonons near k=0 are correct?
    1. In an ionic crystal the TO phonon absorbs infrared light strongly.
    2. In silicon (two identical atoms per cell) the optical phonon is Raman active but not infrared active.
    3. The optical phonon frequency goes to zero at k=0.
    4. In a polar crystal the LO frequency is above the TO frequency.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    Oppositely charged ions moving against each other form an oscillating dipole: IR absorption at ωTO. In Si the two atoms are identical, so the vibration has no dipole (not IR active), but it modulates the polarisability (Raman active, 520 cm−1). Optical branches have finite frequency at k=0; it is the acoustic ones that vanish. In polar crystals the LO mode is pushed up by its macroscopic field.

    Why people get this wrong: Thinking "optical" means "seen with light" in every crystal; the name comes from ionic crystals.

← All topics · Timed mock test →