Phase changes and the Clausius-Clapeyron equation
Kinetic theory and thermodynamics · 12 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATExam level
At a second-order transition at K, the molar heat capacity jumps by J mol K and the volume expansion coefficient by K. The molar volume is m/mol. By Ehrenfest's equation, the slope of the transition line is ______ Pa/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 5 $10^8$ Pa/K (±0.05)
For a second-order transition is continuous along the line: with . Subtracting: , so Pa/K.Why people get this wrong: Clausius–Clapeyron gives here, since both and vanish; Ehrenfest's equations replace it.
-
MCQExam level
At fixed temperature, raising the pressure on a substance that has two possible phases favours- the phase with the larger molar entropy
- the phase with the larger molar volume
- the phase with the smaller molar volume
- neither, because pressure does not affect which phase is stable
Answer and solution
Answer: C
, so the molar Gibbs energy of each phase rises with pressure at a rate equal to its molar volume. The denser phase (smaller ) rises more slowly and ends up with the lower . That is why pressure melts ice (water is denser) and turns graphite into diamond.Why people get this wrong: The entropy decides what temperature favours (), not pressure.
-
MCQExam level
In Landau theory, with . Just below , the equilibrium order parameter behaves as- jumps to a finite value at
Answer and solution
Answer: B
gives or . Below the non-zero root has lower , so : mean-field exponent (real fluids and magnets give about ). It starts from zero, so the transition is continuous.Why people get this wrong: A jump in needs a negative coefficient (or a cubic term): that is a first-order transition.
-
MSQExam level
Which of these are first-order transitions (with latent heat)?- melting of ice at 1 atm
- heating a fluid along an isobar above its critical pressure, from liquid-like to gas-like
- iron losing its ferromagnetism at the Curie point in zero field
- a type-I superconductor turning normal in a non-zero applied magnetic field
Answer and solution
Answer: A, D
Melting has a latent heat ( J/g for ice). Above the critical pressure there is no phase boundary at all: properties change smoothly. The Curie point in zero field is continuous: magnetisation goes to zero smoothly and only the heat capacity is singular. A type-I superconductor in a field goes normal at with a latent heat (the entropy jumps); only at zero field is the transition second order.Why people get this wrong: The same material can show a first-order or continuous transition depending on the field or pressure path.
-
MCQHard
Along a liquid–vapour coexistence curve, with an ideal vapour and negligible liquid volume, one can show (molar). For water, and J mol K. Near C the latent heat changes with temperature at a rate of about- J mol K: it falls as the temperature rises
- J mol K: it rises with temperature
- : the latent heat is a constant of the substance
- J mol K, that is
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Take the derivative of along the curve: . Along the curve ; for the ideal vapour and , giving . The terms cancel: J mol K. (Measured: water's falls from kJ/mol at C to at C, about per kelvin.) It keeps falling and reaches zero at the critical point.Why people get this wrong: Treating as a fixed property of the substance is fine over small ranges only.
-
MCQHard
Below about K, the melting curve of helium-3 has , although the solid is denser than the liquid. What does this tell you?- The latent heat of fusion is zero there
- The Clausius–Clapeyron equation does not apply to quantum liquids
- The liquid has a larger molar volume and a larger molar entropy
- The solid has a larger molar entropy than the liquid
Answer and solution
Answer: D
with liquid solid. The solid is denser, so . A negative slope then needs : the solid has more entropy. In solid helium-3 the nuclear spins are disordered (entropy per mole) while in the liquid they are ordered by Fermi statistics. Squeezing the liquid into solid therefore absorbs heat and cools it: Pomeranchuk cooling.Why people get this wrong: Clausius–Clapeyron holds for any two phases in equilibrium; it is pure thermodynamics.
-
NATHard
A Landau free energy per mole is with J mol K, J/mol and K. The jump in molar heat capacity at is ______ J mol K.Answer and solution
Answer: 5 (±0.05)
Below , and ; above, . below and above. At : J mol K, larger on the ordered side. No latent heat: entropy is continuous, its slope is not (second order in Ehrenfest's sense).Why people get this wrong: Dropping the factor in gives 0.05.
-
NATHard
Pure water is supercooled by K. In classical nucleation theory a spherical ice nucleus grows only if its radius exceeds . With J/m, K and latent heat per volume J/m, is ______ nm (two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.94 nm (±0.03)
A nucleus of radius changes the free energy by with (the bulk gain per volume, from near ). The maximum is at m. Such a nucleus holds thousands of molecules, which rarely gather by chance; hence deep supercooling of clean water.Why people get this wrong: Setting instead of maximising it gives (4.41 nm).
-
NATTop rank
A type-I superconductor has a critical field with T and K. The Gibbs energy per unit volume of the normal state exceeds that of the superconducting state by . Find the latent heat per unit volume absorbed when the sample turns normal in its critical field at K: ______ kJ/m (to two decimal places). Take T m/A.Answer and solution
Answer: 1.91 kJ/m³ (±0.02)
Entropy difference: . With , : , so . Here : J/m, and J/m kJ/m. It is positive because the normal state has more entropy, and it vanishes at and at (where the transition becomes second order).Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that itself depends on : the latent heat comes entirely from .
-
MCQTop rank
In Landau theory with a field, . At the same distance from the transition, the zero-field susceptibility above is how many times its value below ?- 1
- 1/2
- 4
- 2
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Let . Equilibrium needs , i.e. ; differentiating, at the equilibrium . Above: , . Below: , so . Ratio . Both diverge as (mean-field ).Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the curvature added by the term below gives a ratio of 1.