Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Multipole expansion

Multipole expansion

Electricity and magnetism · 73 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    A charge distribution has zero total charge and zero dipole moment, but is not spherically symmetric. Far away its potential typically falls off as
    1. 1/r
    2. 1/r2
    3. 1/r3
    4. e−r
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The l-th term of the multipole expansion goes as 1/rl+1: monopole 1/r, dipole 1/r2, quadrupole 1/r3. With the first two zero, the quadrupole term leads. (The field falls one power faster, as 1/r4.)

    Why people get this wrong: Confusing the potential (here 1/r3) with the field (1/r4).

  2. MCQWarm-up

    The electric dipole moment p→=∑qir→i of a set of charges does not depend on the choice of origin when
    1. the total charge is zero
    2. the charges all have the same sign
    3. the quadrupole moment is zero
    4. the charges lie in a plane
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Shift the origin by a→: r→i→r→i−a→, so p→→p→−Qa→ with Q=∑qi. The moment is unchanged for every shift only if Q=0.
  3. NATWarm-up

    Charges +1.0 nC at (1,0,0) cm, +1.0 nC at (0,1,0) cm and −2.0 nC at the origin. The magnitude of the dipole moment is ______ ×10−11 C m (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.41 (±0.01)

    p→=∑qir→i=(10−9)(0.01xˆ)+(10−9)(0.01yˆ)+0=10−11(xˆ+yˆ) C m, of magnitude 2×10−11=1.41×10−11 C m. The net charge is zero, so this is the same about any origin.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    The quadrupole tensor Qij=∑nqn(3xn,ixn,j−rn2δij) has trace Qxx+Qyy+Qzz equal to
    1. ∑nqnrn2
    2. 3∑nqnrn2
    3. 2∑nqnrn2
    4. 0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Trace =∑nqn(3rn2−3rn2)=0. The −r2δij part is there exactly to make the tensor traceless: the trace would only add a term proportional to ∇2(1/r)=0 outside the source.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    At equal distances from a point dipole, the field strength on its axis compared with that on its perpendicular bisector (equatorial plane) is
    1. the same
    2. twice as large
    3. half as large
    4. four times as large
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Er=2pcos⁡θ4πϵ0r3, Eθ=psin⁡θ4πϵ0r3. Axis (θ=0): 2kp/r3 along p→. Equator (θ=90∘): kp/r3 opposite to p→. Ratio 2.
  6. NATWarm-up

    A molecule has a dipole moment of 1.85 debye. In SI units this is ______ ×10−30 C m (to two decimal places). (1 D =3.336×10−30 C m.)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6.17 (±0.02)

    1.85×3.336×10−30=6.17×10−30 C m. One debye is roughly the moment of charges ±e separated by 0.21 Å, which is why molecular moments are a few debye.
  7. NATStandard

    Charges +1.0 nC, −2.0 nC and +1.0 nC sit on the z axis at z=−1.0 cm, 0 and +1.0 cm. Using the leading term of the multipole expansion, the potential on the z axis at z=10 cm is ______ V (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.8 (±0.02)

    Total charge 0; dipole moment q(−a)+q(a)=0. Quadrupole: Qzz=∑q(3z2−z2)=2×q×2a2=4qa2. On the axis V=14πϵ0Qzz2z3=2kqa2z3=2×8.99×109×10−9×10−410−3=1.80 V. (Exact sum: 1.82 V; the error is of order (a/z)2.)

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the 12 in V=12∑Qijrˆirˆj/4πϵ0r3 doubles the answer.

  8. MCQStandard

    For r>r′, with γ the angle between r→ and r→′, the expansion 1|r→−r→′|=∑lTl has terms
    1. Tl=rlr′l+1Pl(cos⁡γ)
    2. Tl=r′lrlPl(cos⁡γ)
    3. Tl=r′lrl+1Pl(cos⁡γ)
    4. Tl=r′lrl+1cosl⁡γ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    1|r→−r→′|=1r(1−2tcos⁡γ+t2)−1/2 with t=r′/r<1, and the generating function of the Legendre polynomials is (1−2tx+t2)−1/2=∑tlPl(x). So Tl=r′lPl(cos⁡γ)/rl+1: the smaller distance on top.

    Why people get this wrong: Using cosl⁡γ instead of Pl(cos⁡γ) is wrong from l=2 on.

  9. MSQStandard

    For a point dipole p→=pzˆ at the origin, which statements are correct (with k=1/4πϵ0)?
    1. Er=2kpcos⁡θ/r3
    2. Eθ=kpsin⁡θ/r3
    3. The field lines obey r=Csin2⁡θ.
    4. The field vanishes at some finite point with r>0.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    From V=kpcos⁡θ/r2: Er=−∂rV=2kpcos⁡θ/r3 and Eθ=−1r∂θV=kpsin⁡θ/r3. Field lines: dr/(rdθ)=Er/Eθ=2cot⁡θ gives ln⁡r=2ln⁡sin⁡θ+ const. |E|=kpr33cos2⁡θ+1≥kp/r3>0: never zero.
  10. NATStandard

    In a bent molecule each of the two equivalent bonds carries a dipole moment of 1.50 D, and the angle between the bonds is 104.5∘. The molecular dipole moment is ______ D (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.84 (±0.01)

    The components across the symmetry axis cancel; along it each bond gives pbcos⁡(θ/2). Total =2×1.50×cos⁡52.25∘=3.00×0.612=1.84 D.

    Why people get this wrong: Using cos⁡104.5∘ or forgetting the factor 2 are the usual slips.

  11. MCQStandard

    A distribution has total charge Q and dipole moment p→ about the origin O. About a new origin O′ at position a→ (measured from O), the dipole moment is
    1. p→+Qa→
    2. p→
    3. p→−a→
    4. p→−Qa→
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Positions measured from O′ are r→i−a→, so p→′=∑qi(r→i−a→)=p→−Qa→. Choosing a→=p→/Q (the centre of charge) makes the dipole moment vanish whenever Q≠0.
  12. NATStandard

    Around a point dipole pzˆ, the field is perpendicular to the dipole axis (Ez=0) on a cone of half-angle θ (measured from the +z axis, θ<90∘). θ is ______ degrees (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 54.7 (±0.1)

    E→=kr3[3(p→⋅rˆ)rˆ−p→], so Ez=kpr3(3cos2⁡θ−1). It vanishes where P2(cos⁡θ)=0: cos⁡θ=1/3, θ=54.7∘ (the "magic angle" of NMR).
  13. MCQStandard

    The work needed to turn a dipole p in a uniform field E from alignment with the field to the opposite direction is
    1. pE
    2. 0
    3. 2pE
    4. pE/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    U=−p→⋅E→: −pE when aligned and +pE when reversed. Work =ΔU=2pE. (The torque pEsin⁡θ integrated from 0 to π gives the same.)
  14. MCQStandard

    Four charges sit at the corners of a square in the xy plane: +q at (a,a) and (−a,−a), −q at (a,−a) and (−a,a). The non-zero components of Qij=∑q(3xixj−r2δij) are
    1. Qxx=Qyy=6qa2, Qzz=−12qa2
    2. Qxy=Qyx=12qa2 only
    3. Qxy=Qyx=3qa2 only
    4. Qzz=4qa2 only
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Diagonal: each charge has 3x2−r2=3a2−2a2=a2, and ∑q=0, so Qxx=0; likewise Qyy=0 and Qzz=∑q(−2a2)=0. Off-diagonal: Qxy=3∑qxy=3[qa2+qa2+(−q)(−a2)+(−q)(−a2)]=12qa2. Qxz=Qyz=0 since z=0.
  15. MCQStandard

    The multipole expansion of the vector potential of a closed current loop has no monopole (1/r) term because
    1. the current is steady
    2. the loop is small
    3. magnetic charges are too weak to measure
    4. ∮dl→′=0 around any closed loop
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    A→=μ0I4π∑l1rl+1∮r′lPl(cos⁡γ)dl→′. The l=0 term is μ0I4πr∮dl→′, and the vector sum of the elements of a closed loop is zero. The leading term is the magnetic dipole, A→=μ04πm→×rˆr2.
  16. NATStandard

    Two molecules, each with dipole moment 1.0 D, are lined up head to tail along a common axis, 0.50 nm apart. The magnitude of their interaction energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 10 (±0.1)

    U=p→1⋅p→2−3(p→1⋅rˆ)(p→2⋅rˆ)4πϵ0r3=−2p24πϵ0r3 for coaxial, parallel dipoles. kp2=8.99×109×(3.336×10−30)2=1.00×10−49 J m3; divide by r3=1.25×10−28 m3 and double: 1.60×10−21 J =10.0 meV, less than kBT≈26 meV at room temperature.
  17. NATExam level

    A charge of 1.0 nC is spread uniformly through a prolate spheroid with semi-axes a=b=1.0 cm and c=2.0 cm (along z). Its quadrupole moment Qzz=∫ρ(3z2−r2)dV is ______ ×10−13 C m2 (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.2 (±0.01)

    For a uniform ellipsoid ⟨x2⟩=a2/5, ⟨y2⟩=b2/5, ⟨z2⟩=c2/5. So Qzz=Q(3c25−a2+b2+c25)=2Q5(c2−a2)=0.4×10−9×3×10−4=1.2×10−13 C m2. Positive: prolate (cigar).
  18. MSQExam level

    The quadrupole moment of a nucleus is defined about its centre of charge by eQ=∫ρ(3z2−r2)dV in the state of maximum m. Which statements are correct?
    1. A prolate (cigar-shaped) nucleus has Q>0.
    2. An oblate (disc-shaped) nucleus has Q<0.
    3. A nucleus of spin 0 or 1/2 shows no spectroscopic quadrupole moment.
    4. Because the nucleus is charged, its quadrupole moment is the same about any origin.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Extra charge along z makes 3z2−r2 positive on average: prolate Q>0, oblate Q<0. A rank-2 tensor needs at least spin 1 to have a non-zero expectation value (Wigner-Eckart), so I=0,12 give zero. Since the nucleus has net charge, its dipole and quadrupole moments do depend on origin; that is why they are taken about the centre of charge.
  19. NATExam level

    The square quadrupole has +1.0 nC at (a,a) and (−a,−a), −1.0 nC at (a,−a) and (−a,a), with a=1.0 cm. Using the quadrupole term, the potential at a point in the xy plane on the line y=x, 20 cm from the origin, is ______ V (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.67 (±0.01)

    Only Qxy=Qyx=12qa2 is non-zero, so V=k2r5∑Qijxixj=k2r5⋅2⋅12qa2xy. On y=x, xy=r2/2: V=6kqa2r3=6×8.99×109×10−9×10−40.008=0.674 V. (A direct sum over the four charges gives 0.675 V.)
  20. MCQExam level

    A small dipole p sits on the line through a point charge Q>0, at distance r, with p→ pointing directly away from Q. The force on the dipole is
    1. 2Qp4πϵ0r3, towards Q
    2. 2Qp4πϵ0r3, away from Q
    3. Qp4πϵ0r3, towards Q
    4. zero, since the dipole is neutral
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    F→=(p→⋅∇)E→. With Er=kQ/r2 and p→=prˆ: Fr=p∂rEr=−2kQp/r3, i.e. towards Q. Physically the negative end is nearer to Q and is pulled harder than the positive end is pushed.

    Why people get this wrong: A neutral object feels a force in a non-uniform field.

  21. MSQExam level

    Consider the average electric field over the volume of a sphere of radius R. Which statements are correct?
    1. For charges entirely outside the sphere, it equals the field they produce at the centre.
    2. For charges entirely inside, it equals −p→4πϵ0R3, where p→ is their dipole moment about the centre.
    3. For a point dipole inside, the average is zero because the dipole field averages out over angles.
    4. The field of an ideal point dipole contains a term −p→3ϵ0δ3(r→).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    Outside charges: V is harmonic in the sphere, so by the mean value theorem the average field is the field at the centre. Inside charges: the average equals −p→/4πϵ0R3 wherever they sit inside. The angular average of 3(p→⋅rˆ)rˆ−p→ is zero, so all of that average comes from the contact term −p→δ3/3ϵ0: integrating it over the ball gives −p→/3ϵ0, divided by 43πR3 gives the result.

    Why people get this wrong: Dropping the delta term makes the average zero, which is wrong; it matters for hyperfine splitting and for the field inside matter.

  22. NATExam level

    A ring of radius 10 cm in the xy plane carries line charge λ=λ0cos⁡ϕ with λ0=1.0 nC/m. The magnitude of its dipole moment is ______ ×10−11 C m (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3.14 (±0.01)

    p→=∫λr→dl=∫02πλ0cos⁡ϕR(cos⁡ϕ,sin⁡ϕ)Rdϕ=πλ0R2xˆ. Numbers: π×10−9×0.01=3.14×10−11 C m. The total charge is zero, so the result does not depend on origin.
  23. NATExam level

    A thin hemispherical shell of radius R (the half with z>0) carries uniform surface charge σ0. Its dipole moment about the centre of the sphere is κσ0R3zˆ. The value of κ is ______ (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3.14 (±0.01)

    pz=∫σ0(Rcos⁡θ)R2dΩ=σ0R3⋅2π∫0π/2cos⁡θsin⁡θdθ=σ0R3⋅2π⋅12=πσ0R3. The x and y parts cancel by symmetry. Because the net charge 2πR2σ0 is not zero, this value belongs to the centre as origin.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the sin⁡θ in dΩ gives 2σ0R3.

  24. MCQExam level

    A small charge distribution with quadrupole tensor Qij=∑q(3xixj−r2δij) sits in an external field. Besides the qV and −p→⋅E→ terms, its energy contains
    1. −12∑ijQij∂Ej∂xi
    2. −13∑ijQij∂Ej∂xi
    3. −16∑ijQij∂Ej∂xi
    4. +16∑ijQij∂Ej∂xi
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Taylor-expand V: W=∑q[V0+xi∂iV+12xixj∂i∂jV]. The last term is −12∑qxixj∂iEj. Since ∇⋅E→=0 for external sources, we may replace xixj by xixj−13r2δij=13(3xixj−r2δij), giving −16∑Qij∂iEj.

    Why people get this wrong: The factor 16 comes from 12 (Taylor) times 13 (the definition of Qij).

  25. MCQExam level

    How many independent components does the electric quadrupole tensor Qij have in general?
    1. 9
    2. 6
    3. 3
    4. 5
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    A 3×3 tensor has 9 components; symmetry (Qij=Qji) leaves 6; tracelessness removes one more: 5. This matches the 2l+1=5 spherical components q2m, m=−2,…,2.
  26. NATExam level

    A diatomic molecule has a dipole moment of 1.08 D and a bond length of 127 pm. If it were fully ionic (±e at the nuclei), its moment would be e×(bond length). The percentage ionic character, pactual/pionic×100, is ______ % (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 17.7 (±0.2)

    pionic=1.602×10−19×1.27×10−10=2.035×10−29 C m =6.10 D. pactual=1.08×3.336×10−30=3.60×10−30 C m. Ratio =0.177: about 17.7% ionic.
  27. MCQExam level

    Far from the linear quadrupole (+q, −2q, +q on the z axis at −a, 0, +a), the potential at polar angle θ is proportional to
    1. cos⁡θ/r2
    2. (3cos2⁡θ−1)/r3
    3. sin2⁡θ/r3
    4. cos2⁡θ/r3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    With axial symmetry, V=kQzz2r3P2(cos⁡θ)=kqa2r3(3cos2⁡θ−1), using Qzz=4qa2. It is positive along the axis (the +q ends are nearer) and negative in the equatorial plane, where it is −kqa2/r3.
  28. MCQExam level

    Two equal point dipoles are held a fixed distance apart, free to rotate. Which arrangement has the lowest interaction energy?
    1. Side by side, antiparallel
    2. Side by side, parallel
    3. Perpendicular to each other
    4. Head to tail along the line joining them
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    U=k[p→1⋅p→2−3(p→1⋅rˆ)(p→2⋅rˆ)]/r3. Head to tail: k(p2−3p2)/r3=−2kp2/r3. Side by side antiparallel: −kp2/r3. Side by side parallel: +kp2/r3. Perpendicular (one along rˆ): 0. Lowest: head to tail, which is why polar molecules form chains.

    Why people get this wrong: Antiparallel side by side is stable but only half as strongly bound as head to tail.

  29. MCQExam level

    A single point charge q sits at (0,0,d). About the origin, its quadrupole component Qzz=q(3z2−r2) is
    1. qd2
    2. 2qd2
    3. 3qd2
    4. 0, since a point charge has no quadrupole moment
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Qzz=q(3d2−d2)=2qd2, and Qxx=Qyy=−qd2. A displaced point charge has every multipole about the origin: it is the expansion of q/|r→−dzˆ|, with l-th term qdlPl(cos⁡θ)/rl+1.

    Why people get this wrong: Only about its own position does a point charge have no higher moments.

  30. MCQExam level

    Two identical point dipoles of moment p lie on one line, both pointing along it (head to tail), a distance d apart. The magnitude of the force between them is
    1. 2p24πϵ0d3
    2. 6p24πϵ0d4
    3. 3p24πϵ0d4
    4. 2p24πϵ0d4
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The interaction energy is U=14πϵ0d3[p→1⋅p→2−3(p→1⋅nˆ)(p→2⋅nˆ)]. Head to tail: p→1⋅p→2=p2 and (p→⋅nˆ)2=p2, so U=−2p24πϵ0d3. Force F=−dU/dd=−6p24πϵ0d4: attractive, magnitude 6p2/4πϵ0d4.

    Why people get this wrong: The first option is the energy, not the force; differentiating d−3 brings down a factor 3 that is easy to drop.

← All topics · Timed mock test →