Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Defects and dislocations

Defects and dislocations

Solid state physics and devices · 77 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Defects and dislocations.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    A Schottky defect in an ionic crystal such as NaCl is
    1. a cation that has left its site for an interstitial position
    2. a pair of vacant sites, one cation and one anion, so the crystal stays neutral
    3. a foreign ion sitting on a regular lattice site
    4. an extra half-plane of atoms inside the crystal
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    In a Schottky defect the missing ions have gone to the surface. In an ionic crystal they must go in neutral sets: one cation vacancy and one anion vacancy for NaCl. The density falls slightly because volume is added with no extra mass.

    Why people get this wrong: An ion moved to an interstitial site leaving a vacancy behind is a Frenkel defect; the density does not change.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    For a pure edge dislocation, the Burgers vector b→ and the dislocation line direction ξˆ are
    1. parallel
    2. antiparallel
    3. perpendicular
    4. at 45° to each other
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Close a Burgers circuit around the extra half-plane: the closure failure b→ points across the half-plane edge, at right angles to the line. Edge: b→⟂ξˆ. Screw: b→∥ξˆ. Mixed: anything in between, with constant b→ but changing line direction.

    Why people get this wrong: Parallel (or antiparallel) is the screw dislocation.

  3. MCQWarm-up

    Which of these is a planar (two-dimensional) defect?
    1. A vacancy
    2. A screw dislocation
    3. An F centre
    4. A stacking fault
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Defects are sorted by dimension: point (vacancy, interstitial, substitutional atom, F centre), line (edge, screw, mixed dislocations), planar (grain boundaries, twin boundaries, stacking faults, surfaces) and volume (voids, precipitates). A stacking fault is a plane on which the stacking sequence is wrong, e.g. ABCAB|ABC in fcc.

    Why people get this wrong: A dislocation is a line, not a plane, even though it moves on a slip plane.

  4. MCQWarm-up

    An F centre in an alkali halide is
    1. an electron trapped at an anion vacancy
    2. a hole trapped at a cation vacancy
    3. an anion pushed into an interstitial site
    4. a pair of neighbouring cation vacancies
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    An anion vacancy looks positive to an electron (a negative ion is missing). An electron bound there has discrete levels like a particle in a box; transitions between them absorb visible light and colour the crystal (KCl violet, NaCl yellow-brown). F is from the German Farbe, colour.

    Why people get this wrong: A hole at a cation vacancy is a V centre, the "anti" of the F centre.

  5. NATWarm-up

    The vacancy formation energy in a metal is 1.00 eV. The equilibrium fraction of vacant sites n/N at 1000 K is ______ ×10−6 (to two decimal places). Use kB=8.617×10−5 eV/K.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 9.12 × 10⁻⁶ (±0.03)

    n/N=e−Ev/kBT with Ev/kBT=1.00/(8.617×10−5×1000)=11.605. So n/N=e−11.605=9.12×10−6: about one site in a hundred thousand.

    Why people get this wrong: Writing exp(−E/2kT): the factor 2 belongs to Schottky pairs and Frenkel defects, not to single vacancies in a metal.

  6. MCQWarm-up

    Every crystal above absolute zero contains some vacancies in equilibrium because
    1. vacancies lower the internal energy of the crystal
    2. the entropy of mixing vacancies among sites lowers the free energy F=U−TS at small concentration
    3. the Pauli principle forbids filling every site
    4. impurities always push atoms out of their sites
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Each vacancy costs energy Ev, but placing n vacancies among N sites can be done in N!/[n!(N−n)!] ways. The entropy term −kBTln⁡W falls faster than linearly at small n, so F always has a minimum at some n>0: n/N≈e−Ev/kBT.

    Why people get this wrong: Vacancies cost energy; they exist despite the energy, because of entropy.

  7. MCQWarm-up

    In steel, small carbon atoms sit in the gaps between the much larger iron atoms. This kind of point defect is
    1. a substitutional impurity
    2. a vacancy
    3. an interstitial impurity
    4. a Schottky defect
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    An impurity atom squeezed into the spaces between host atoms is an interstitial impurity. Only small atoms (H, B, C, N) fit this way. A substitutional impurity replaces a host atom on its own site, as zinc does in copper (brass).

    Why people get this wrong: Substitutional means taking a host atom's place, which needs a similar atomic size.

  8. MCQStandard

    A crystal has N lattice sites and Ni interstitial sites. If EF is the energy to move one atom from a lattice site to an interstitial site, the equilibrium number of Frenkel defects (n≪N,Ni) is
    1. Ne−EF/kBT
    2. NNie−EF/kBT
    3. Nie−EF/2kBT
    4. NNie−EF/2kBT
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Choose n vacant lattice sites and, independently, n occupied interstitial sites: W=(Nn)(Nin). Minimising F=nEF−kBTln⁡W with Stirling gives n2/[(N−n)(Ni−n)]=e−EF/kBT, so n≈NNie−EF/2kBT.

    Why people get this wrong: The factor 2 in the exponent comes from creating two point defects (a vacancy and an interstitial) for one energy cost.

  9. NATStandard

    In a metal with vacancy formation energy 0.90 eV, the equilibrium vacancy concentration at 900 K is how many times that at 600 K? (Nearest whole number; kB=8.617×10−5 eV/K.)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 331 (±3)

    n900n600=exp⁡[EvkB(1600−1900)]. Ev/kB=10444 K and 1/600−1/900=5.556×10−4 K−1, product 5.80. e5.80≈331.

    Why people get this wrong: Taking the ratio of the temperatures (1.5) or of the exponents, instead of the exponential of the difference.

  10. MCQStandard

    The Burgers vector of a perfect (unit) dislocation in an fcc metal of cubic lattice constant a has magnitude
    1. a
    2. a3/2
    3. a/2
    4. a/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    A perfect dislocation's Burgers vector is the shortest lattice translation. In fcc that joins a corner to a face centre: a2⟨110⟩, length a22=a/2, the nearest-neighbour distance.

    Why people get this wrong: a3/2 is the bcc Burgers vector a2⟨111⟩; a is simple cubic.

  11. MCQStandard

    Which kind of dislocation can change its slip plane by cross-slip, moving by glide alone?
    1. A pure edge dislocation
    2. A pure screw dislocation
    3. Both, equally easily
    4. Neither: changing plane always needs diffusion
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The slip plane must contain both b→ and the line. For an edge dislocation these are perpendicular and fix one plane. For a screw they are parallel, so any plane containing the line is a possible slip plane, and the screw can glide off onto another one: cross-slip.

    Why people get this wrong: An edge dislocation leaves its plane only by climb, which needs vacancies or interstitials to arrive or leave (diffusion).

  12. MCQStandard

    Climb of an edge dislocation (motion perpendicular to its slip plane)
    1. needs atoms or vacancies to diffuse to or from the edge of the extra half-plane, so it is thermally activated
    2. happens at any temperature under a shear stress alone
    3. is the same as cross-slip
    4. conserves the number of atoms in the extra half-plane
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    To move up or down, the extra half-plane must lose or gain atoms along its edge. That happens by absorbing vacancies (or emitting them), so climb is non-conservative and needs diffusion: it matters at high temperature (creep, recovery, polygonisation).

    Why people get this wrong: Glide is conservative (no atoms added or removed); climb is not.

  13. NATStandard

    A single crystal is pulled with a tensile stress of 100 MPa. The normal to the active slip plane makes 60∘ with the tensile axis and the slip direction makes 35∘ with it. The resolved shear stress on this slip system is ______ MPa (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 41 MPa (±0.2)

    Schmid's law: τR=σcos⁡ϕcos⁡λ=100×cos⁡60∘×cos⁡35∘=100×0.5×0.8192=41.0 MPa.

    Why people get this wrong: Using sin⁡ for either angle; and note ϕ+λ≥90∘ always (here 95∘), so the Schmid factor never exceeds 0.5.

  14. MCQStandard

    How many independent slip systems of the type {111}⟨110⟩ does an fcc crystal have (counting a direction and its reverse once)?
    1. 3
    2. 6
    3. 8
    4. 12
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    There are 4 distinct {111} planes (the faces of an octahedron), and each contains 3 close-packed ⟨110⟩ directions: 4×3=12 slip systems. This large number is why fcc metals (Cu, Al, Au) are so ductile.

    Why people get this wrong: Counting 8 octahedral faces double-counts parallel planes.

  15. MCQStandard

    In a bcc metal the Burgers vector of a perfect dislocation is
    1. a⟨100⟩
    2. a2⟨110⟩
    3. a2⟨111⟩
    4. a6⟨112⟩
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The shortest lattice vector of bcc joins a corner to the body centre: a2⟨111⟩, length a3/2. Slip runs along these close-packed body diagonals, mostly on {110} planes.

    Why people get this wrong: a6⟨112⟩ is a Shockley partial in fcc, not a lattice vector at all.

  16. MSQStandard

    Which statements about vacancies in a pure metal are correct?
    1. Their equilibrium concentration rises exponentially with temperature.
    2. Rapid quenching from near the melting point can freeze in an excess of vacancies.
    3. Typical formation energies are of order 1 eV.
    4. Their equilibrium concentration is independent of the formation energy.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    n/N=eSv/kBe−Ev/kBT: Arrhenius in T and very sensitive to Ev (about 1 eV: Cu 1.3, Al 0.7). Vacancies need diffusion to reach sinks (surfaces, dislocations), so a fast quench leaves the high-temperature population behind, measurable as extra electrical resistivity.

    Why people get this wrong: The concentration depends exponentially on the formation energy; that is the whole point of the Boltzmann factor.

  17. NATStandard

    Near its melting point of 1300 K a metal has an equilibrium vacancy fraction of 1.0×10−4. Ignoring the formation entropy, its vacancy formation energy is ______ eV (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.03 eV (±0.01)

    Ev=−kBTln⁡(n/N)=8.617×10−5×1300×ln⁡(104)=0.11202×9.2103=1.03 eV.

    Why people get this wrong: Using log base 10: ln(10⁴) = 9.21, not 4.

  18. MCQStandard

    In which of these crystals are Frenkel defects (rather than Schottky defects) dominant?
    1. NaCl
    2. KCl
    3. AgBr
    4. CsCl
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Frenkel defects need a small ion that fits in an interstitial site. In the silver halides the Ag+ ion is small and polarisable and moves easily into interstitial sites, so cation Frenkel pairs dominate (and make AgBr an ionic conductor and photographic material). The alkali halides have Schottky pairs.

    Why people get this wrong: Both kinds exist everywhere; the question is which costs less energy.

  19. NATStandard

    A metal has vacancy formation energy 1.00 eV. Ignoring the formation entropy and taking kB=8.617×10−5 eV/K, the equilibrium vacancy fraction at 1000 K is larger than at 800 K by a factor of ______ (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 18.2 (±0.1)

    nv/N=e−Ev/kBT, so the ratio is exp⁡[EvkB(1800−11000)]. Ev/kB=11605 K and 1/800−1/1000=2.5×10−4 K−1, giving e2.901=18.2. A 25% rise in temperature multiplies the vacancy count eighteenfold.

    Why people get this wrong: Exponentials of 1/T do not scale like T: the ratio is not 1000/800=1.25.

  20. MCQStandard

    Which statement about where a dislocation line can end is correct?
    1. It can end anywhere inside a perfect crystal.
    2. It can end only at a surface, at a grain boundary, at a node with other dislocations, or close on itself as a loop.
    3. It must always form a closed loop, so it can never reach a surface.
    4. It ends wherever its Burgers vector changes direction.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The Burgers vector is the same everywhere along a dislocation line, because the closure failure of a Burgers circuit cannot change as the circuit slides along the line through good crystal. If the line simply stopped inside perfect crystal, a circuit beyond the end would close and one before it would not, a contradiction. So lines end on free surfaces or boundaries, meet others at nodes (where the Burgers vectors add up), or close as loops.

    Why people get this wrong: The line direction can wander, but its Burgers vector cannot change along it.

  21. NATStandard

    A cube of side 1.0 mm is sheared plastically by edge dislocations of Burgers vector 0.25 nm that glide right through it on parallel slip planes, each one moving the top relative to the bottom by b. The number of dislocations that must pass to give a shear strain of 1.0% is ______ ×104 (to one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4 ×10⁴ (±0.05)

    A shear strain γ over height h means the top moves γh=0.010×1.0 mm =10 μm. Each dislocation crossing the crystal adds b=0.25 nm, so n=10−5/0.25×10−9=4.0×104 dislocations. Plastic flow is the sum of very many tiny atomic-scale steps.

    Why people get this wrong: Each dislocation that crosses gives a step of exactly one Burgers vector, not one lattice constant of any length.

  22. MCQExam level

    In an ionic crystal MX with N ion pairs, the energy to form one Schottky pair (one M vacancy plus one X vacancy) is Ep. The equilibrium number of Schottky pairs is approximately
    1. Ne−Ep/kBT
    2. Ne−Ep/2kBT
    3. 2Ne−Ep/kBT
    4. Ne−2Ep/kBT
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The n cation vacancies and n anion vacancies are placed independently: W=(Nn)2. Minimising F=nEp−2kBTln⁡(Nn) gives n2/(N−n)2=e−Ep/kBT, so n≈Ne−Ep/2kBT.

    Why people get this wrong: The pair is one energy cost but two independent entropies; that halves the exponent.

  23. NATExam level

    In AgBr, take the number of interstitial sites equal to the number of Ag sites and the Frenkel formation energy as 1.10 eV. The fraction of Ag ions on interstitial sites at 600 K is ______ ×10−5 (two decimal places; kB=8.617×10−5 eV/K).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.4 × 10⁻⁵ (±0.02)

    With Ni=N: n/N=e−EF/2kBT. 2kBT=0.10341 eV, so the exponent is 1.10/0.10341=10.637 and n/N=e−10.637=2.40×10−5.

    Why people get this wrong: Dropping the 2 gives 5.8×10−10, five orders of magnitude too small.

  24. NATExam level

    Estimate the elastic energy of a dislocation as 12Gb2 per unit length. For copper, G=45 GPa and b=0.256 nm. The energy per atomic length b of dislocation line is ______ eV (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.36 eV (±0.02)

    Energy per length =12×45×109×(0.256×10−9)2=1.475×10−9 J/m. Times b: 3.775×10−19 J =2.36 eV. Several eV per atom plane is far more than kBT, so dislocations are not equilibrium defects: entropy can never pay for them.

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting to multiply by b to get energy per atom along the line.

  25. MCQExam level

    In an fcc metal a perfect dislocation splits into two Shockley partials: a2[1‾10]→a6[2‾11]+a6[1‾21‾]. By Frank's b2 rule, the elastic energy after splitting is what fraction of that before (ignoring the stacking fault and the interaction)?
    1. 1/3
    2. 1/2
    3. 2/3
    4. It is larger: 4/3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Check the vectors add: a6(−2−1,1+2,1−1)=a6(−3,3,0)=a2(−1,1,0). Energies go as b2: before a2/2; each partial a236(4+1+1)=a2/6, two give a2/3. Ratio (a2/3)/(a2/2)=2/3<1, so splitting lowers the energy; the partials repel until the stacking-fault energy between them balances.

    Why people get this wrong: Adding lengths |b| instead of b² would make the split look unfavourable.

  26. NATExam level

    Taylor's relation for work hardening is τ=αGbρ. For aluminium, G=26 GPa, b=0.286 nm, α=0.3 and a dislocation density ρ=1014 m−2. The flow stress is ______ MPa (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 22.3 MPa (±0.1)

    ρ=107 m−1. τ=0.3×26×109×0.286×10−9×107=2.23×107 Pa =22.3 MPa. Doubling the stress needs four times the dislocation density.

    Why people get this wrong: Using ρ instead of √ρ.

  27. NATExam level

    In a crystal with 1012 m−2 mobile dislocations of Burgers vector 0.25 nm moving at an average 1.0 mm/s, the plastic shear strain rate is ______ s−1 (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.25 s⁻¹ (±0.005)

    Orowan: γ˙=ρmbv‾=1012×2.5×10−10×10−3=0.25 s−1. Each dislocation crossing a crystal of height h shears it by b/h, which is where the formula comes from.

    Why people get this wrong: Mixing mm/s with m/s gives an answer 1000 times too big.

  28. MCQExam level

    Frenkel's estimate of the shear stress needed to slide one perfect atomic plane rigidly over another is about G/2π. Real annealed metal crystals start to slip at 10−4 to 10−5 of G because
    1. real crystals have a much smaller shear modulus than measured
    2. dislocations let the slip happen one line of atoms at a time, which needs only a small stress
    3. thermal vibrations melt the slip plane
    4. the slip planes in real crystals are not close packed
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    A dislocation is the boundary between slipped and unslipped regions. Moving it by one b shifts each atom near the core by a small amount, never breaking all bonds across the plane at once. The Peierls stress needed is tiny in close-packed metals, so the yield stress is set by obstacles to dislocations, not by bond strength.

    Why people get this wrong: G is measured from small elastic strains and is correct; it is the rigid-slip picture that is wrong.

  29. NATExam level

    A symmetric low-angle tilt boundary of misorientation 0.50∘ is a wall of edge dislocations with b=0.25 nm. Their spacing is ______ nm (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 28.6 nm (±0.1)

    For small angles, θ=b/D (in radians), so D=b/θ=0.25/(0.5×π/180)=0.25/0.008727=28.6 nm.

    Why people get this wrong: Using θ in degrees gives 0.5 nm, which would be one dislocation every two atoms.

  30. MCQExam level

    The elastic energy per unit length of a straight screw dislocation in a cylinder of radius R is Gb24πln⁡Rr0. As R→∞ this energy
    1. diverges logarithmically, so it must be cut off at the crystal size or at the distance to other dislocations
    2. tends to a finite value Gb2/4π
    3. falls to zero as 1/R
    4. grows as R2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The shear strain around a screw falls as b/2πr, so the energy density 12Gγ2∝1/r2; integrating over 2πrdr gives ∫dr/r=ln⁡(R/r0). In a real crystal R is roughly the spacing between dislocations, whose fields cancel beyond that, giving the usual estimate of about Gb2/2 per length.

    Why people get this wrong: A 1/r² energy density does not give a convergent integral in two dimensions.

← All topics · Timed mock test →