Quaternium-22 protects carbon steel in hydrochloric acid: 97 % inhibition

A cosmetic ingredient, Quaternium-22, cuts carbon steel corrosion in 1 M HCl by 97 %. We check the corrosion rates and adsorption with fibub's Tafel corrosion rate tool.

Steel is cleaned and descaled with hydrochloric acid in many factories, and the acid eats the steel too. A corrosion inhibitor is a chemical added in tiny amounts that sticks to the metal and slows the attack. A team in Egypt tested Quaternium-22, a water-soluble ingredient better known from hair conditioners, and found it blocks about 97 % of the corrosion of carbon steel in strong acid. This article shows how the Tafel corrosion tool turns a polarisation curve into a corrosion current and a rate in millimetres per year; the EIS fitter does the same job for impedance (EIS) spectra, the paper’s second method.

The paper in brief

The team put ASTM A35 carbon steel in 1.0 M hydrochloric acid with 0, 41, 69, 138 and 277 µmol/L of Quaternium-22 (Q-22), at 20, 30, 40 and 50 °C. They measured weight loss, polarisation curves (current against potential, swept slowly through the corrosion potential) and impedance spectra, and backed them with computer models of how the molecule sits on iron.

The best result was 97.21 % inhibition at 277 µmol/L and 20 °C. Q-22 slowed both the metal-dissolving (anodic) and hydrogen-making (cathodic) reactions, but mostly the anodic one, so it is called a mixed-type inhibitor. Its coverage of the surface followed the Langmuir isotherm (one layer of molecules, each site either full or empty), and the free energy of adsorption, −37.4 to −39.8 kJ/mol, sits between the values usually read as physical sticking (about −20) and chemical bonding (about −40). Protection fell as the acid warmed, which the authors put down to molecules letting go.

Checked with the tools

The paper’s tables of Tafel slopes and currents were not in the text we could read, so we did not redo them. Everything below is either a simulation built around the paper’s one headline number, or a recomputation from its stated ΔG°ads range. We say which.

Step 1: what does 97.21 % mean in current? Inhibition efficiency from polarisation is IE = 1 − icorr(with inhibitor) / icorr(blank), where icorr is the corrosion current density. So 97.21 % means the inhibited steel carries 2.79 % of the blank’s current, about one thirty-sixth.

Step 2: a simulated test. We made up a blank curve typical of steel in 1 M HCl (Ecorr −470 mV against a saturated calomel electrode, icorr 400 µA/cm², Tafel slopes 70 and 120 mV per decade) and an inhibited one with 11.16 µA/cm², Ecorr shifted 18 mV positive (well under the 85 mV that would make it purely anodic) and slightly steeper slopes, then added 4 % noise (Figure 1). The Tafel tool’s maths gave:

Simulated curve Tafel lines (80 to 200 mV) Wagner-Traud fit Rate, ASTM G102
Blank 393 µA/cm² 400 µA/cm² 4.6 mm/year
277 µmol/L Q-22 10.9 µA/cm² 11.2 µA/cm² 0.13 mm/year
Efficiency 97.2 % 97.2 %

A steel wall that would lose 4.6 mm a year in the bare acid loses about 0.13 mm a year with the inhibitor. The straight-line Tafel method reads both currents a little low, because the opposite reaction still adds 1 to 3 % of the current at 80 mV from Ecorr; the full Wagner-Traud fit, which the tool runs as well, has no such bias. Because both currents are read low by a similar amount, the efficiency barely moves. The polarisation resistance (the slope of potential against current right at Ecorr) went from 47 to about 2,000 Ω·cm², which with Stern-Geary also gives 97.2 %.

Polarisation curves, blank and with inhibitor (simulated)Polarisation curves, blank and with inhibitor (simulated)110100100010⁴-0.7-0.6-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2Potential (V vs SCE)|i| (µA/cm², log scale)Blank, 1 M HClWith 277 µmol/L Q-22fibub.com
Figure 1. Two polarisation curves we simulated with the Tafel tool's Wagner-Traud equation (2 % noise), the inhibited one with 2.79 % of the blank's corrosion current, the ratio the paper's 97.21 % implies. Not the paper's measured curves.

Step 3: what the adsorption energy says. The Langmuir constant follows from ΔG°ads as K = (1/55.5) × e^(−ΔG°/RT), where 55.5 mol/L is the concentration of water. Taken at 20 °C (a simplification: the paper’s range spans its four temperatures), −39.8 kJ/mol gives K = 2.2 × 10⁵ L/mol and −37.4 kJ/mol gives 8.3 × 10⁴ L/mol. At 277 µmol/L those predict a surface coverage θ = Kc/(1 + Kc) of 98.4 % and 95.8 %, bracketing the measured 97.21 % (Figure 2). So the headline efficiency and the reported adsorption energies agree with each other.

Langmuir coverage from the paper's ΔG°ads range (20 °C)Langmuir coverage from the paper's ΔG°ads range (20 °C)00.20.40.60.81050100150200250300Q-22 concentration (µmol/L)Surface covered, θΔG°ads = -39.8 kJ/molΔG°ads = -37.4 kJ/molPaper: 97.21 % at 277fibub.com
Figure 2. Langmuir coverage worked out from the ends of the paper's ΔG°ads range, taken at 20 °C (our simplification), with the paper's best efficiency as a dot. Our recomputation, not the paper's isotherm plot.

How we made the graphs

The script scripts/blog-figures/quaternium-22-corrosion-inhibitor-carbon-steel-hcl.mjs draws both charts and writes them into this page. Figure 1 uses bv (the Wagner-Traud equation), signed, tafel, fitBV, polarisationResistance, sternGeary and rateMmY from src/lib/sci/corrosion.ts, the maths of the Tafel corrosion rate tool, with iron’s equivalent weight and density from the same file. Figure 2 is the Langmuir formula worked out in the script itself; fibub has no adsorption-isotherm tool yet. From the paper: 97.21 % and the ΔG°ads range. Ours: every other number on the simulated curves (Ecorr, blank icorr, slopes, noise), and 20 °C for Figure 2.

How we test the maths

node tests/sci.mjs runs on every change. For this tool:

  • tests/sci.mjs (corrosion block): the tool’s example curve must give Ecorr −650 mV, icorr 10 µA/cm² and slopes 60 and 120 mV/decade; ASTM G102 must turn 1 µA/cm² on iron into 0.0116 mm/year; the Stern-Geary constant for 60 and 120 mV slopes must be 0.017372 V.
  • tests/sci-tools/tafel-corrosion-rate.mjs (added with this article): exact blank and inhibited curves must read 394.3 and 10.85 µA/cm² with straight Tafel lines and 400 and 11.16 µA/cm² with the Wagner-Traud fit, an efficiency of 97.21 %; G102 must give 4.640 mm/year for 400 µA/cm² on carbon steel (worked by hand).

Check it yourself

On the Tafel corrosion tool:

  1. Clear Potential and current, one pair per line and paste these 21 pairs (potential in mV, current in µA/cm², one pair per line): -652 -385.5, -632 -270.5, -612 -189.7, -592 -133, -572 -93.05, -552 -64.86, -532 -44.75, -512 -30.1, -492 -18.89, -472 -9.412, -452 0, -432 11.35, -412 27.49, -392 52.84, -372 94.76, -352 165.6, -332 286.7, -312 494.2, -292 850.5, -272 1463, -252 2515. This is our exact inhibited curve.
  2. Set Potential unit to mV and Current unit to µA/cm².
  3. Leave Tafel range from (mV) at 80, to (mV from Ecorr) at 200, and Metal on iron or carbon steel (equivalent weight 27.92, density 7.87).
  4. The headline should read icorr 11.2 µA/cm²: about 0.129 mm per year, and the table shows the Tafel-line row slightly lower, near 10.8 µA/cm².
  5. Divide by a blank of 400 µA/cm²: 1 − 11.16/400 = 97.2 % inhibition.

What researchers can use it for

  • Inhibitor screening: run the blank and each concentration through the Tafel corrosion tool and get icorr, slopes and mm/year for each in a minute, with the Wagner-Traud fit as a check on the straight-line reading.
  • Cross-checking efficiencies: compare IE from Tafel, from polarisation resistance (Stern-Geary) and from charge-transfer resistance fitted to EIS spectra with the EIS fitter; they should agree within a few percent.
  • Weight-loss coupons: the same tool’s weight-loss card turns mass lost, area and hours into mm/year for the gravimetric side of a study.
  • Reviewing a paper: check that a reported efficiency and ΔG°ads are consistent through the Langmuir relation, as above.
  • Teaching: shows students why corrosion currents are read on a log scale and why the Tafel range starts well away from Ecorr.

A tool we could build

An adsorption isotherm fitter that takes surface coverage (or efficiency) against inhibitor concentration at several temperatures, compares Langmuir, Temkin and Frumkin, and gives K, ΔG°ads, ΔH°ads and ΔS°ads with errors, would complete the inhibitor workflow.

Sources

  • Afifi, M., El Basiony, N. M., El-Tabei, A. S., Abdel Halim, S. and Ibrahim, M. A. M. (2026), Quaternium-22 as a High-Performance Corrosion Inhibitor for Carbon Steel in Acidic Media: Experimental and Theoretical Insights, Surfaces 9(2), 30, doi:10.3390/surfaces9020030. Open access under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (the page metadata links CC BY 3.0), checked on the journal page, 2026-11-16. Values used here: ASTM A35 carbon steel in 1.0 M HCl; Q-22 at 41, 69, 138 and 277 µmol/L; 20 to 50 °C; best inhibition efficiency 97.21 % at 277 µmol/L and 20 °C (polarisation); mixed-type inhibitor, mainly anodic; Langmuir isotherm with R² above 0.99; ΔG°ads from −37.4 to −39.8 kJ/mol; efficiency falls as temperature rises.
  • Corrosion rate from current density: ASTM G102, Standard Practice for Calculation of Corrosion Rates and Related Information from Electrochemical Measurements (equivalent weight 27.92 g and density 7.87 g/cm³ for iron, as the Tafel corrosion rate tool uses).
  • Langmuir constant from ΔG°ads with 55.5 mol/L for water: the usual convention in corrosion-inhibitor papers.

If you are an author or publisher and want a credit or a passage changed or removed, tell us and we will act quickly.

Tools in this article

Read next